tv John King USA CNN August 29, 2011 4:00pm-5:00pm PDT
just a tiny bit of rain. i'm concerned about the flood just like my puppy. it's definitely raining more because it's 5:00 now. back to you. this is my last report because it is my bedtime. it is really raining, the wind has picked up. this is the biggest ever it has been. everybody, take care. and please stay inside. otherwise, you might blow away. >> she's going to be on cnn "american morning" tomorrow morning. amazing reporting. thank you. that's it for me. thanks very much for watching. i'm wolf blitzer. in north america, "john king, usa" starts right now. thanks for joining us, john king has the day off. in vermont tonight, hundreds of people remain cut off without power or a way out. hurricane irene has torinoed picturesque brooks and steams
into life-threatening torrents. we'll get an update in a few minutes. but first, breaking news on the international manhunt for moammar gadhafi and members of his family. several hours ago, a senior rebel commander told cnn that one of his sons, khamis gadhafi died sunday night. also today, algeria revealed it had allowed gadhafi's wife and daughter and two of his grown sons and some of his grandchildren to enter the country for what they call humanitarian reasons. nic robertson is in tripoli now. can you update us on the latest on this humanitarian so-called giving of them refuge in alge a algeria? >> reporter: you know, one of the interesting things is that algeria still recognizes moammar
gadhafi as the leader of libya. so what happened in the early hours of the day is that moammar gadhafi's wife, daughter, two sons, showed up at the border and crossed over into algeria. they said they're taking them in on humanitarian grounds. they want them back and if algeria doesn't send them back they'll consider this a -- an aggression against the will of the libyan people. so clearly, this government -- this new emerging leadership here takes this very seriously, gloria. >> sure. and since the family left, what does this tell us about the rebel strong hold? i mean, these people managed to get out. >> reporter: you know, there's a massive part of this country that the rebels really don't control, and i don't think anyone really knows even the
rebels, even gadhafi himself really knows exactly where a front line might be drawn and exactly who sides with who. the coastline here is where most of the population is. it's almost 1,000 miles long. that's the slif thever that the rebels have. but the south of the country, maybe a hundred kilometer, a hundred miles south of that -- south of the coast line, for hundreds and hundreds of miles into the desert further south, that really still has a lot of gadhafi loyalist, tribes that are loyal to him. it's sparsely populated so really, there's a lot of area where gadhafi could be hiding. and where there is still tribes loyal to him. so it's far from done for the rebels. it's interesting that they say they killed one of gadhafi's sons, khamis, over the weekend. they have offered no evidence. they said things like this before and it's proven not to be true. now the rebel leaders have said they've lied intentionally, a
week ago they captured three of gadhafi's sons. they lied intentionally to try to create fear among gadhafi's loyalists. when we hear statements that they killed one of his sons, i think we need to take that with a pinch of salt, if you will. i know it's a psychological operation against gadhafi's loyalists. >> i want to follow up on your exclusive yesterday about the lockerbie bomber. you discovered him apparently in a coma. what are the rebels saying today about the possibility of extraditing him back to scotland? >> they're saying they're not going to do it. which is very interesting because the reason that they're giving publicly is because they're saying there's no extradition treaty with these countries and therefore, that's why they won't go ahead. but another dimension, political dimension. the tribe is hugely important for this government, they need to get them on their side away from gadhafi so he can build this interim government and send
gadhafi outside of the country would send a signal to this tribe, a negative signal. so they want to send a positive signal. get the tribe on their side, help firm up their leadership here. >> local politics. thanks so much, nic robertson. gadhafi's grown son hannibal is among the members who entered algeria today. dan rivers discovered, he left behind evidence his family behaved like animals. a quick word of caution, some of the images you are about to see are deeply disturbing. >> reporter: meet a 30-year-old ethiopian nanny who describes how she was horribly tortured. >> she took me to a bathroom and tied my hands behind my back and tied my feet. she taped my mouth. and she started pouring the boiling water on my head like this.
>> reporter: her crime, she refused to beat hannibal's toddler who wouldn't stop crying. >> dan rivers joins us now from tripoli. dan, that story is absolutely heart breaking. it's horrifying. we know that hannibal himself may be in algeria. do we have any idea what's happened to the wife who this woman says did this to her? >> reporter: and the short answer is no, we don't. we understand from the algerians that hannibal has crossed the border into algier eriaalgeria, wife, aline, a former lebanese model, we don't know where she is. we're seeing what apparently according to this ethiopian nanny is the most barbaric
torture for no reason at all. >> what's the international reaction to this story? is there any way to prosecute this woman? >> reporter: well, there's been a phenomenal reaction from viewers, from people going on to the cnn.com website. we have been in touch with the state department, for example, in the u.s. i think there is an enormous amount of interest in her story. people clearly want to do something about it and we're working to try and make that happen in as effective a way as possible. the problems here on the ground are obvious. this is still a sort of hostile environment in every sense. so hospitals are difficult here, but we are trying to get something done to help this lady. >> hopefully, she can get some medical treatment. dan, you also got an exclusive look at the compound that was used by gadhafi's sons. i want to play that and talk to you at the other end about it.
>> this is the main sitting room of a party house we think was used by colonel gadhafi's sons, hannibal and you can see it's full of the evidence of drinking. there's dom perignon rose. johnny walker blue label. this obviously looks like it was a big, expensive tv system. i think it was an awesome tv system. >> what kind of impact will these pictures have? >> reporter: well, i mean, we spoke to the rebel commander that is in charge now of that compound. he said he was disgusted by what he saw, shocked as well. he said colonel gadhafi gave the impression that he spent his whole life living a modest existence in a bedouin tent and to come in and see that, that was quite hard for them to take. but it's clear from what we have seen that the money was no object to the gadhafi sons and family.
everything was the very best that money could buy. incredible decadence and overindulgence in these beach houses. it wasn't just one, but a series of villas. we were told in one that at one point before the rebels arrived dozens of swiss watches. we walked into another as they were rifling through hundreds of bottles of very expensive champagne. quite incredible scenes and scenes that are really difficult for the libyan people to stomach given the long 42 years of suffering under considerable gadhafi's regime. >> one would think. thank you so much, dan rivers for being with us. i'd like to add the note that the nanny who was burned has received an outpouring of concern from our viewers. cnn is working with humanitarian organizations to get help for her. as soon as that is finalized we'll let you know how you can
help. you can go to cnn.com/impact. with us now from new york, we have cnn national security contributor fran townsend who advised president bush and now is on the external advisory boards of the cia and homeland security department. in may of 2010, she visited high-ranking libyan officials at the invitation of the libyan government and also with us is the national security analyst peter bergen with me here in washington. let me start with you, fran. the family is now or so we think part of it in algeria. what does this tell us about whether gadhafi's days are numbered? >> you know, gloria, it's interesting to me that where we find that they're in algeria because it was cnn that reported about a week ago that they had attempted to flee to tunisia where they refused to accept them. look, this i think all is part of gadhafi's exit from the scene, if you will. there's no question he wanted to
find -- he clearly was looking to find safe haven for his family. he had to deal with the rebels what ijs. and the hunt is on for him, but it becomes frankly less imperative for gadhafi to flee now that he's got his family or a good portion of his family out of harm's way. >> do you think he's preparing for martyrdom? >> i do. he's said from the beginning, it's not what i think, but he said his preferences were to die and have his blood spill on libyan soil. i think this is part of his preparation plan before he has to confront that. >> peter, does it matter in the long run if gadhafi is actually found, tried or killed? >> shush ure it matters, but capturing him and then trying saddam was obviously important to a lot of iraqi people. but it didn't end the insurgency. quite the opposite.
it gathered steam. there are gadhafi sympathizers. i'm sure gadhafi's planned for some kind of insurgency to kind of follow his fall from power. so even if gadhafi is taken from the scene, enough people identify with his regime that libya is likely to have some kind of civil unrest for a long time. >> fran, let me ask you this. is bringing gadhafi to justice a rebel decision or is it a nato decision and what is justice? >> well, in the first instance, it will be a rebel decision, the national transition council is the governing, if you will, body for the moment. and libya remains a sovereign country and so if he becomes into their control, it will be an empty decision. if there was nato support, you must expect they'll consult nato and probably the united states, given the level of u.s. support. >> well, let me -- let me ask you this, peter. given the fact that libya son the edge right now, does this
validate the obama/nato strategy because it's clear that the rebels are doing quite well? they haven't gotten gadhafi, but they're winning. >> i think it does surely. not a single smoernldier has died. this is similar to the kosovo interventi intervention. this is done without a great deal of blood and treasure on our part and the results will speak for themselves. there were naysayers at the beginning. it seemed to take a long time. these things don't happen overnight. and, you know, the bosnia intervention took at least three months. so it was to be expected that this was not going to be something that you just overthrow the regime immediately. >> fran, did people get a sense early on that gadhafi was going to go quicker and is that a problem politically for the president? >> i think as long as he goes it's not a political problem for the president.
i mean, i think there was an expectation, gloria, that he would go quicker. and it took nato a little while. if anyone has got some sort of bruises from the engagement, it's nato. nato really took a while to get their rhythm down. and their increased bombing campaign helped the rebels ultimately to succeed. and so i do think that in the end, as long as gadhafi is gone, the president's policy is a success. >> and fran, you have met him. i have to ask you what you think he's got cooking in his own mind now that his family is out. we talked about martyrdom, but is there any escape you think planned or do you think he's there till the finish? >> i actually take him at face value on this. i think he's planning to be there to the finish. i think his family is not at all signed on that. i think the sons you have seen the sort of luxury they have lived in themselves. they are not as tough or crazy as gadhafi himself.
the real question is will the sons try to flee? one comment real quick on the nanny. the horrific injuries that she suffered, this is not an isolated incident. remember one of his sons and wife were charged in switzerland which caused a big conflagration and that was because they had abused a nanny. this horrific conduct is part of a pattern. >> okay. thank you so much, fran and peter. and there's another developing story tonight and that one is in vermont. where the state's governor is warning people to brace for more flooding and more loss of life. we'll speak with governor up next.
pile on the products. or challenge all that effort with olay. simply sweep on the new total effects dark circle minimizer. it tightens and helps conceal to beautifully reveal younger-looking eyes. it's a clean sweep. the nascar na, i know pleasing fans is a top priority, 'cause without the fans, there'd be no nascar. just like if it weren't for customers, there'd be no nationwide. that's why they serve their customers' needs, not shareholder profits. because as a mutual, nationwide doesn't report to wall street, they report to their customers. and that's just one more reason why the earnhardt family has trusted nationwide for more than 30 years. nationwide is on your side.
in vermont tonight, three people are confirmed dead in the flooding caused by hurricane irene. a little bit ago, the state's emergency management agency warned that even though the floodwaters have receded from levels we saw yesterday, most rivers and streams remain above normal levels and are still quite dangerous. with us on the phone is vermont governor peter shumlin. thanks so much for being with us. we know you're quite busy. first of all, governor, can you
give us an update on whether the waters are finally receding? >> well, they are from the smaller tributaries, but our major rivers which they flow into are still rising so we have our challenges ahead. >> i understand that this afternoon, you spoke with the president. can you tell us what you asked him for? >> well, i should tell you the president reached out to me. he's been extraordinary as has his entire team. he's going to dispatch his director of fema up here tomorrow, senator napolitano has been in constant contact with us. but really what he said is governor, i want to do whatever i can do to help vermont dig out -- >> but what do you need right now, because you have people who are isolated in small communities. so what do you need from the federal government? >> well, the biggest thing we need right now is resources bigger than ourselves. we're kind of a self-reliant up here in vermont, self-sufficient. we don't ask for much, but we're at a time where we need
resources in terms of water, food, engineering help so we can get water systems and sewer systems up. we continue to struggle with huge challenges. we just got absolutely whacked by the flooding. >> when you say totally isolated, you mean without any communication, you don't know whether people are sick? you don't know whether they're injured? >> no, we're in there. the red cross and fema is on the ground, but the challenges that in many of the smaller communities, they can't get out if they need to hospitals without helicopters. we don't have many in vermont. >> there is also a missing person i gather in vermont. has that -- >> well, this is the toughest part is that as you probably know, we lost one woman on the first day of the flood in wilmington, vermont. today, we found two other individuals who worked for the city of rutland.
we found one, and we're searching for the other. we had a young -- a man die in ludlow, who drowned there. so we are at three confirmed deaths and we are searching for a fourth individual. and these are just devastating stories that break your heart. the other challenge we have is just the amount of infrastructure that we've lost. i mean, covered bridges. we have lost cemeteries, businesses, houses. you know, whole communities are struggling to stay afloat here in terms of the kind of losses that we're experiencing. so it's really been a tough, tough whack for us here in vermont. >> well, do you have any idea the kind of economic damages it's going to cause your state? >> you know, we're still in crisis management. i'm trying to save lives and get people to safety. we have evacuated our entire state hospital as an example. it's under water. much of the functions of the state government are under water. at water bury, we're evacuating seniors and low-income seniors from mobile homes and other
areas. we are trying to get them to safety. so we'll be doing the financial assessments in the coming weeks, but right now we're still in crisis mode. >> i have to ask you one last question, did you expect it to be this bad? >> you know, in fairness, we were warned that it would be this bad. we were told by the weather service that we were going to get the eye of the storm and we did. so we prepared for the worst and hoped for the best and frankly we got delivered the worst. but, you know, the national weather folks told us four days out that vermont was going to get the eye. but the rest of the nation wasn't paying attention. our emergency management people did an extraordinary job making preparations. we set up obviously shelters throughout the state. we had our water teams, high water equipment distributed across the state in anticipation that we'd be whacked everywhere. we were right. so i would say that we did expect it. we hoped it would change, but we knew it was coming. >> okay. thanks so much, governor, for being with us. we know it's a very difficult
time for you in the state of vermont. >> thanks for all your sympathy. we deeply appreciate it. >> good luck. with all the attention on hurricane irene, it's hard to believe that today marks six years since hurricane katrina hit new orleans in the gulf coast. next, i'll ask james carville and mary matalin, have we learned anything? hey, the new guy is loaded with protein! really? 25 grams of protein. what do we have? all four of us, together? 24. he's low fat, too, and has 5 grams of sugars. i'll believe it when i--- [ both ] oooooh... what's shakin'? [ female announcer ] as you get older, protein is an important part of staying active and strong. new ensure high protein... fifty percent of your daily value of protein. low fat and five grams of sugars. see? he's a good egg. [ major nutrition ] new ensure high protein. ensure! nutrition in charge! that when you live in the fast lane,
you need a mortgage lender who's just as fast and responsive. [ rob ] i'm rob jones, professional race car driver and former fighter pilot. so, you might say i know a thing or two about fast. it takes a lot to keep up with my hectic schedule, but quicken loans has never let me down. they closed my loan fast, their rates and fees were low, and their crew kept me updated through every step of the process. quicken loans is a lot like me -- we're both engineered to amaze. helps defends against occasional constipation, diarrhea, gas and bloating. with three strains of good bacteria to help balance your colon. you had me at "probiotic." [ female announcer ] phillips' colon health. [ male announcer ] they'll see you...before you see them. cops are cracking down on drinking and riding. drive sober, or get pulled over.
six years ago today hurricane katrina hit the gulf coast and new orleans was not ready. today at the white house, fema administrator craig fuget asked how the lessons learned from katrina influenced the response to hurricane irene. listen to this. >> we can't wait to know how bad it is before we get ready. we have to go fast, we have to base it upon the potential impacts. that's why we look at these forecasts we get from the hurricane center and bemake the decisions -- we make the decisions based upon what the potential impacts can be. if you wait until how bad it is, it becomes harder to change the outcome. >> with us from new orleans republican strategist mary matalin and democratic strategist james carville. thanks for being here. you heard craig fugate.
did we learn the lessons of katrina from looking at irene? >> irene and katrina are two, both separate kind of events in their own way, but we learned some lessons in terms of preparedness. but the big thing is our flood protection is substantially better here. we're still not where it needs to be, you know, in terms of the pumps, but we're significantly better than we were on august 29th, six years ago. and i think in about another four years with we're going to be in pretty good shape here. but you wouldn't want to have a catastrophic engineering failure again like we had in 2005. that's very hard to prepare for. but, you know, i think that, you know, i think they have learned a lot. they had to have. >> mary, presidential candidate ron paul of texas said that the nation would be much better off without the federal emergency management agency. i want you to listen to what he said about fema, then we'll talk about it.
>> fema is not a good friend of most people in texas because all they do is come in and tell you what to do and can't do, you can't get in your houses and they hinder the local people. and they hinder volunteers from going in. so there's no magic about fema and more people are starting to recognize that and they're a great contributor to financing. >> is he right about fema? >> he makes a number of points. what he didn't make there but is a valid one is about their insurance capacity. we should not be insuring irresponsibility. it is about rationalizing risk, he makes that point. he makes the larger point about the cost of fema, but most americans would say that disaster relief, recovery and rebuilding is a function of government. you could get economies of scale. does it break down on the ground? yes, it does. is it better when the local
first responders and the state responders are working in collaboration with fema before and after and working into the future? we're still working with fema six years after the fact here. so a lot depends on the local relationships, but i'm a very small government conservative as you know, gloria, but fema is a -- i think is a legitimate function of the federal government in collaboration and not to be interfering with the first response to a nation disaster. >> but james, mary raises an interesting point, you have to figure out way to pay for disaster relief, and the number two man in the house, eric cantor said, and i quote, those federal monies are not unlimited and what we have always said is we offset that which has already been funded. so he's saying you've got to go
dollar for dollar here and off set it. >> again, he's been off setting the cost of loss, but disasters are a part of life. we have had hurricanes and tornados, anything. we have had floods. look at the great mississippi river flood of 1927. look at what the people have gone through in vermont right now. you live in a big country, you have big risks that are in that. great nations deal with these things and deal with them on a fairly regular basis. i don't buy the fact that this country is unable to respond. we have a disaster, we have a huge earthquake in the los angeles basin, which is a real possibility. god knows what that would entail then. you have to do everything you can. we can't deny the fact that we live in a big country and our country is subject to risk. that's just part of the way it is. we have to deal with it. that's what great nations do. >> mary, i want to ask you, because both of you are involved in the community there in new orleans. you moved there after hurricane katrina. what advice do you have to
people who are trying to recover from an event like hurricane irene, given what you have seen in new orleans? >> that -- well, the first piece of advice would be the one that governors across the east coast were making. when they tell you to evacuate, get out of there. they're not kidding about that. the second piece of advice i think people understand since katrina is there is an element of personal responsibility. we see these things coming, don't rush out to the grocery store at the last minute. people should be prepared if you live in an area like this, you should have flashlights and take care -- and james' favorite, the ice chest. you can do things to be prepared. but at the end of the day before any element or level of government can get to you, your neighbor, you should be in a position to help your neighbor and in your neighborhood.
that's the very first line of defense. >> james, what about the rebuilding process? even psychologically when you see your possessions destroyed, maybe your business destroyed, how -- what advice would you give to people to cope? >> well, i mean, look at what's happened here. we still -- we obviously -- recovery is uneven. there's more good than bad. let's admit that it's more good than bad. one of the things that we learned is, this is a little bit like you have a child who has a near-death experience and all you want to do is hug that child. you're going love the that one even more and i think people here it's a real sense of pride and what's been accomplished is a real sense of we still have our city. we have our culture and our way of life. we want to relish it and enjoy and participate it in more than ever. i think you have that. i'll make one case in terms of preparedness. if you do anything, listen to
cnn contributor russell an array. when you see something coming, tune in to what he has to say. that's my advice to you. >> thanks so much to james and mary. james will be sticking around with us for another segment in a few minutes. thanks to both of you. >> thank you. we'll head back overseas in a moment. serious pro-democracy people who have been risking their lives are taking another tactic. where do you go to find a super business?
you know, the ones who do such a super job, they're backed by the superguarantee®? only superpages®. wherever you are, wherever you're going, you'll find the super business you need. so next time, let the good guys save the day. get the superguarantee®, only at superpages®. in the book ... on your phone or online. at exxon and mobil, we engineer smart gasoline that works at the molecular level to help your engine run more smoothly by helping remove deposits and cleaning up intake valves. so when you fill up at an exxon or mobil station, you can rest assured we help your engine run more smoothly while leaving behind cleaner emissions. it's how we make gasoline work harder for you. exxon and mobil.
serious -- syria's crackdown cost them an important friend. they have lost their confidence in syria's leader. syria's demonstrators are trying something new. for the first time they're appealing for foreign protection. cnn's ivan wattson is watching the development from istanbul. >> reporter: gloria, the protesters have been out for more than 5 1/2 months despite a crackdown that claimed more than 2,200 lives and some have adopted a new strategy. take a look at the videos. it shows some siyrian protester clapping and demanding that people want international protection. you can see them holding up signs that say we need
international protection. this is a sharp change in the past. the syrian protesters have specifically said they do not want any type of libya-style foreign military intervention. in fact, one prominent syrian opposition group has come out with the statement saying it totally opposes any kind of foreign military intervention. or armed resistance inside saying this would erode the popular international support and the moral high ground that the syrian revolution has enjoyed thus far. meanwhile, growing pressure from foreign governments, neighbors of the syrian regime here in turkey. the turkish president coming out and saying he has lost all confidence in his former syrian ally. take a listen. >> we have reached a point where anything would be too little too late. frankly, i would say that we have lost our confidence. >> reporter: turkey is joined by the arab league which is also criticized the ongoing violence in syria which claimed at least
five more lives according to reports. but even syria's closest allies, iran and the shiite lebanese movement while voicing ongoing support for the regime, they too have said it's time for them to carry out reforms and listen intently to some of the demands of the syrian people. signs that they too, these close allies, are concerned about the bloody direction this country is taking. back to you, gloria. and anderson 360 is coming up at the top of the hour. >> in 20 minutes we are on flood watch. millions of americans continuing to feel the effects from irene. flooding is major concern. vermont was particularly hard hit. look at the bridge washed over. we'll head to vermont live. we'll speak to a reporter who is trapped in a town in prattsville, new york, as that place was devastated.
>> when the flood first started happening yesterday, i'm telling you the water, it's like an established community. it wasn't even there. that's how bad it was. it was all under water. when we tried to figure out how to get out, everybody laughed at us. they said there's no way out. all the surrounding roads are flooded. and the power is out. so it's kind of too dangerous to drive through, so we decided to stay at the red cross shelter and come down here this morning. >> we'll tell you what it's like for residents tonight. we're following the revolution in libya. several of gadhafi's family members have escaped to algeria. how they did it, and the question of course remains where is gadhafi? we'll talk with reporters in tripoli. and plus, nic, he tracked down the lockerbie bomber. apparently on his death bed. and new reports about the convicted child rapist warren jeffs. he fell ill, he was rushed to
the hospital. tell you why he's now in a coma. he looks very different. a very different looking warren jeffs than we saw a couple of weeks ago. his followers remain faithful, however. >> warren jeffs may be in prison for the rest of his life, but in hilldale, utah, where thousands of jeffs followers live, he is still the prophet. >> do you believe the evidence they showed the jury? >> i believe the evidence is ill gotten and manufactured. that's what i have to go by. >> so you believe that -- >> i know that the government can do that. >> gary tuchman's report tonight. also at 10:00 p.m. and all that at the top of the hour. >> thanks so much, anderson. we'll be watching. in a new cnn poll confirms a new front runner in the republican race. who that is in a minute. i'm going to ask james carville if it's bad news for the democrats. to play all the hite '80's
woman: hit it, mr. butters. ♪ ♪ take on me... ♪ ....take on me ♪ take me on... anncr: there's an easier way to save. get online. go to geico.com get a quote. 15 minutes could save you 15% or more on car insurance. a living, breathing intelligence that's helping drive the future of business. in here, inventory can be taught to learn. ♪ machines have a voice. ♪ medical history follows you. it's the at&t network -- a network of possibilities... committed to delivering the most advanced mobile broadband experience to help move business... forward. ♪ i'm not crazy about these light fixtures. kitchen's too small.
what's next? 607 franklin st. ♪ sea bass... ♪ ooohhh! ♪ i like it. yeah, i love the kitchen. [ male announcer ] the epa-estimated 42 mpg highway chevy cruze eco. perfect for finding your way home. i know what works differently than many other allergy medications. omnaris. omnaris, to the nose. did you know nasal symptoms like congestion can be caused by allergic inflammation? omnaris relieves your symptoms by fighting inflammation. side effects may include headache, nose bleed, and sore throat. got allergy symptoms out of my way. now life's a picnic. [ man ] omnaris. ask your doctor. battling nasal allergy symptoms? omnaris combats the cause. get omnaris for only $11 at omnaris.com.
rick perry is on top in a new cnn poll. republicans and independents lean to the gop. the previous front-runner mitt romney is a distant second. here to go over the numbers, cnn contributors erick erickson, editor of redstate.com. and democratic strategist james carville is with us again. thanks for being here. let's take a look at this poll, because it's kind of
interesting. we have -- we polled republicans choice for a nominee in 2012. without giuliani and sarah palin in the race. you see here, perry 32%. romney way behind, 18%. bachman 12%, gingrich 7%. paul, 6%. on down the line. let me start with you, eric. is there a new front-runner here and is his name rick perry? >> gloria, it's shaping up for that way. i'm still not convinced yet. i think we need to see a few more weeks of polling. this is a big bounce out of his announcement in charleston and then through new hampshire and iowa. he hasn't been in any debates yet. i would like to see his performance in the debates that's where things got held up with fred thompson and he came out with big bounces. he has more staying power than wes clark. there's a cnn debate, an nbc
debate coming up. if he can stay on top, then he's the front-runner and it's not a bounce. >> well, james, clearly this is a very unsettled republican field. but is rick perry conceivably the guy that you as a democrat might want to run against? >> well, the republicans are not really asking me. but yes, i think he would be fine. i mean, he's in iowa saying that social security is unconstitutional and john thune was saying the biggest question he gets is please don't cut my social security and medicare. i think eric's analysis is right on. three debates coming up. i think come early october we'll have a good sense of how strong that rick perry is. but i also think eric would agree on this, that i'm surprised that romney is as weak as he is. i would expect the race to be more tied. our poll was confirming. i have seen other polls that show the roughly same thing.
it's not just an outlier. >> let me raise that to eric about mitt romney. i was surprised also to see him being so weak. and this poll also shows that perry has 37% of the tea party support. is that romney's problem or evangelicals? >> i think romney's problem is across the board. i hear a lot saying romney will hang on to his natural constituency but i don't know what that is. his basic claim to fame is that he was a jobs guy and perry was a career politician, but he got elected in 1994 he'd be the career politician. >> isn't he establishment? isn't he just the establishment? >> he's the establishment guy to a degree, but he's the establishment degree but by default. republicans typically elect the guy who they perceive as the front-runner. the big exception to that was 1980 when the establishment guy was george h.w. bush. and he fell to reagan. you know, i'm not surprised because if you look at all the polling consistently, romney has been capped out at a third of
republican voters. he's been fitted by so many being in the race. as it starts to consolidate i think it works against him. >> i want you guys to take a look at this poll we did and we looked at evangelical or born-again republicans and their preference by candidate. again, you can see perry very much in the lead there with 39%. romney 15%. if you ask me, that's a lot among evangelicals among romney. but the surprise here is bachman behind there at 11%. james, what does that say about her staying power with the evangelical community? is she losing those people? >> they don't think she can win. they think perry can win. they're pretty savvy politically. you give them a choice between two people. perry had the prayer rally. he said he's got problems with evolution and all of the things
that's music to their ears and he's with them. it's paying dividends and they concluded he's a better candidate for the general election than michele bachmann is. >> history tells us while evangelicals are important in early primaries like iowa and south carolina, they don't generally get their candidates nominated. could that be different this time? >> you know, gloria, if we look after labor day whoever is the front runner for the republicans after labor day has been the nominee for every election since 1994 other than 2008 when it was rudy giuliani with mccain at his heels. it may be perry come labor day but the polling of people who consider themselves born again and evangelicals is displaced or misplaced by the fact that a lot of these people care about fiscal issues, too. they are looking at a guy like
romney and romneycare in massachusetts and they are thinking he's not our guy. the question is who do i think can beat barack obama. >> you have run campaigns and forget about perry on the issues. just as his performance as a candidate it's hard to do that, but just his performance as a candidate, how do you think he's been so far in this first couple of weeks? >> he's been a good candidate for the evangelicals and a good candidate for iowa and south carolina voters. republic republican. he's doing good on his side of the fence and romney is in a jam. he has to figure out a way to
attack him. i think the democrats won't attack perry until this is over. the most democrats i talked to are happy to let him have the bit in his mouth and run. >> both of you fellows stay with us. up next we'll talk about michele bachmann and how she brought god into the race. her campaign said it was just a joke, but there are lightning bolts from the political left. [ bell dings ] [ car door closes ] ♪
an accident doesn't have to slow you down. with better car replacement available only with liberty mutual auto insurance, if your car's totaled, we give you the money for a car one model year newer. to learn more, visit us today. responsibility. what's your policy? male announcer: be kind to your eyes with transitions lenses. transitions adapt to changing light so you see your whole day comfortably and conveniently while protecting your eyes from the sun. ask your eyecare professional which transitions lenses are right for you. female announcer: are you a vsp member? your satisfaction with transitions lenses is guaranteed. visit specialoffers.vsp.com/ transitions or ask your vsp doctor.
humor whether sharp or lame can have serious implications. here's the latest example. michele bachmann's joke during a town hall in florida. listen to this. >> washington, d.c., you would think by now they would get the message. an earthquake, a hurricane -- [ laughter ] >> are you listening? the american have done everything they can. now it's time for an act of god and we're getting it. >> we're back with james carville and eric ericson. was that a joke, james? the left is going crazy over this. >> the left are making fools of themselves. of course it's a joke. and she says enough stupid things and does enough stupid things, you know, if we start taking jokes out of context we'll end up with sanitized, boring -- mitt romney will run for everything in the whole world.
oh, wow. look at this. there's michele making a fool of herself again. what is this? i called some friends who aren't inclined to agree with michele bachmann and they said the same -- the same feeling i had. we have to stop this. make fun of something like concord or lexington, but this woman was obviously joking. the crowd knew she was joking. you know, you get on the campaign trail and these people get tired. they'd like a laugh now and then. she's entitled to that. left wing barbs don't need to make things up. >> it's low hanging fruit. it's an anti-washington joke. >> it is a joke and there is a larger point here. i wish folks in the media will forget about the politicians talking religion. people in the media need to stop
talking about religion. it's something that's incited the issue on michele bachmann, the new yorker about her faith which in turn bill keller said influenced his opinion on the republican presidential field. i read liz's column that a lot of left wing blogs were linking to comments about michele bachmann and he got facts about christian theology wrong, mischaracterizing what main stream christian theology says. we have a nation that 70% of people according to barna say they are christian and you have a media talking about christians and getting the basic facts wrong. it's causing things to whip up into frenzies where there shouldn't be ones like this. >> in the long-term, can this backfire for the democratic party? >> i think the theology