Skip to main content

tv   In the Dead of Night  MSNBC  August 6, 2011 1:00pm-3:00pm PDT

1:00 pm
a life once lived and a person lost. in the hushed quiet of a nebraska farm at night, in the home of these beloved church-going grandparents. >> they touched the lives of so many people. >> the unspeakable. >> i started up the stairs. there was blood on the walls. >> an execution they called it. >> a very brutal crime scene. >> then another blow. evidence pointed to a member of the family as one of the
1:01 pm
killers. then, a confession. >> i said grandma, none of us understand any of this. >> case closed. except for one little thing. this gold ring. it told a different story. who did it belong to? >> i said, that's like looking for a needle in a haystack. >> when they found out, everything changed. >> she said, you won't believe this but they arrested two other people. >> suddenly this case closed was blown wide open. >> i know what happened and no one will believe me! >> confessions. crime scene dna, confusion, and then a new investigation of the investigator. you wake up one morning and they say you're a criminal. what really happened in the dead of night? captions paid for by nbc-universal television good evening and welcome to "dateline." i'm ann curry. the case was unusual and not only because it happened in a small church-going community. for one thing no one could come up with a motive. the crime seemed totally arbitrary. for another thing, a confession usually ends the investigation,
1:02 pm
but in this case, it was only the beginning. here's keith morrison. ♪ >> reporter: it was late, past midnight, when the farmhouse loomed up in their headlights. no sign of life. not to them, anyway. he hit the brakes. this was the place. they grabbed their weapons, headed for the house. a window unlocked. pay dirt. the prairie takes on a sweet, rolling pitch as it tucks into a nebraska corner an hour south of omaha. here the rich black soil has
1:03 pm
grown solid and faithful american. a tiny remnant who have planted themselves in and around a place called murdock, the sort of place where heads turn when a stranger drives by. and a family's name is carved on a local stone. it was easter sunday, 2006. a big farm yard and like every year, an easter egg hunt. >> grandma and papa's yard. >> reporter: or mom and dad to tami who brought her own son, like always. >>y found their easter eggs. they found their easter baskets. mom always made every individual easter basket special to that child. >> reporter: they were like that where wayne and sharmon stock, generous, steady, always there for their children. the eldest steve and daughter tami, the youngest andy.
1:04 pm
>> they were loving parents. >> i don't think they ever missed a game of any of ours. dad would stop farming just to be at a game. same way with mom. >> reporter: wayne stock was a businessman farmer. ran the stock hay company, and a very successful business it was. wayne owned a thousand acres of land along with rental property. sharmon was locally famous for her specialty cakes, wedding and otherwise. they were church youth leaders. keith served on the school board. >> busy people. >> yeah. >> very, very. they touched the lives of so many people. >> reporter: she was a teacher's aide for 17 years at a rural school. taught lessons also that didn't end in class. >> one thing i always heard from mom was take responsibility for your actions, be responsible. >> she would praise you and just keep pushing you to do better. she always wanted us to be better people.
1:05 pm
there wasn't enough hours in the day for them. they were constantly i'm doing this or i'm doing that, or i have to help or i have to make a salad for this, or i'm running here, i'm running there. it was -- they were constant helpers. they helped everybody. and they did live life to the fullest. they surely enjoyed it. >> reporter: and then came that easter sunday, 2006. church services, a big family dinner, that easter egg hunt for the grandkids. their last day on this earth. >> can't forget that one day. my kids remember it. they talk about it all the time. >> reporter: i suppose as last days go, that wouldn't be a bad one. >> no, it wasn't. >> reporter: andy had missed the easter party. spent the day with his future in-laws but left his young puppy with his parents. >> called mom and dad on my way home. and said i'm going to come get the dog. they said, oh, no, he can just stay here.
1:06 pm
he'll be fine. you know, he sleeps on the porch. and we'll watch him till monday morning. no, i'll come get him. >> reporter: would history have been different had he listened to his parents? hard to know, of course. >> they met me on the deck at the back of the house. and we talked about easter and what they did, and they each gave me a hug and i went home. >> reporter: you remember that moment, it makes you feel pretty emotional, doesn't it? >> yeah. yeah. >> reporter: next morning, andy, who was being groomed to run stock hay himself some day, drove the half mile from his place to his parents' farm, ready to go to work. >> i drove in and i went in the shop. and dad's pickup was there, which i thought was a little bit strange. so i thought, well, i'll see if he took mom's car somewhere and looked in the garage and her car was there. picked up the phone in the house. there was no dial tone.
1:07 pm
that's when my heart kind of sunk that for some reason was a little bit of a trigger in my mind. >> reporter: something was wrong. >> something was wrong. i thought i better go upstairs. as i started up the stairs, there was some blood on the walls and, you know, i knew it was bad. >> reporter: it's got to be surreal, a moment like that. does your mind even register? >> no. i think the good lord protects us. >> reporter: yeah. >> till i rounded the corner, and saw dad laying there on the floor. and it was a horrible thing. >> reporter: it was perhaps the central moment in his life so far. nothing would be the same after this. what did you do when you found them? >> i never made it past the landing. my cell phone was out in my pickup, and just turned around, went to call for help. >> reporter: the ambulance was there in 12 minutes. their first lawman in 20.
1:08 pm
andy stood outside in shock, calling family without even knowing what happened or what to say. >> andy's wife and i work together. she answered the phone call. and she didn't even recognize andy's voice. and they've been together for nine years. >> reporter: your own wife. >> she came in the back and said, tam, something's wrong. andy just called and said come quick. dad's laying in a pool of blood. >> reporter: but like the rational farm folk they are, 30 miles away and close to the nearest hospital, they did not assume the worst. even when they tried to call back andy, who now wasn't answering. >> we were both like something's really wrong. and the minister called and said, you need to come home. and i said, i'm not going
1:09 pm
anywhere until you tell me what's wrong. and they said, your mom and dad have been killed. and i think i did start screaming. and we headed towards the farm to be with andy. never in a million years would you think that you'd see your parents' house taped off by that yellow tape. >> reporter: it was a stunning crime. big news throughout the midwest. the stocks the most unlikely victims. wayne found on the upstairs landing dead of a shotgun blast. wife sharmon murdered in her own bedroom. a telephone in hand as if trying to call for help. the county sheriff advised caution. >> right now this is an unsolved homicide. whether it's somebody local or somebody from another town, we don't know at this time. >> reporter: who could have murdered wayne and sharmon stock? and why? coming up -- as an entire community struggles
1:10 pm
to absorb the horror in their midst, the stocks' children face another stunning shock. >> it was like is this really happening? when "in the dead of night" continues. i remember the days before copd.
1:11 pm
my son and i never missed opening day. but with copd making it hard to breathe, i thought those days might be over. so my doctor prescribed symbicort. it helps significantly improve my lung function, starting within 5 minutes. symbicort doesn't replace a rescue inhaler for sudden symptoms. with symbicort, today i'm breathing better, and that means... game on! symbicort is for copd, including chronic bronchitis and emphysema. it should not be taken more than twice a day. symbicort may increase your risk of lung infections, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking it. [ whistle ] with copd, i thought i might miss out on my favorite tradition. now symbicort significantly improves my lung function, starting within 5 minutes. and that makes a difference in my breathing. today i'm back with my favorite team.
1:12 pm
ask your doctor about symbicort. i got my first prescription free. call or click to learn more. [ male announcer ] if you can't afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help.
1:13 pm
just a couple of hours after wayne and sharmon stock's son discovered their bodies in their rural nebraska farmhouse on easter monday 2006, the word got around. law enforcement swarmed the scene, neighbors expressed shock in that understated midwestern way. >> they're just typical nebraska farm background people, and you wouldn't expect it. >> reporter: andy stock, as you can see in these pictures taken on that very day, stood next to his pickup in utter shock waiting for his brother and sister to arrive. and he struggled to process it all.
1:14 pm
as his father's words echoed in his mind. >> i'll never forget july of '05. dad and i were working together. we were standing there, and he looked at me and he said, son, he said, when it's my day to go, hold your head high, keep living life. i'll never forget that. >> reporter: but it was all happening so fast. wayne and sharmon stock had been gunned down in the safety of their own home, the sanctity of their own bedroom. why would anyone want them dead? and who? andy was the last to see his parents alive, the one who found their bodies in the morning, which made him, bizarre though it sounds, a potential suspect. >> before i even saw steve and tami, they had put me in a car and took me to another town and questioned me in a room. >> reporter: trying to establish whether or not you were involved.
1:15 pm
>> yeah. did gunshot residue tests on skin, fingernails, clothing. >> what's that like? you're in grief. >> it's pretty surreal. like is this really happening? you see it on "csi" on tv. it's like, do they really do that? >> they do. >> they do. it's easy. nothing to hide. an hope book. >> reporter: andy stock didn't realize it at the time but investigators were soon looking hard at him. after all, he was there, he had opportunity and he may have had motive. he might have had something to gain from his parents' death. why? andy stock was the already designated heir to the stock hay company, which some people might
1:16 pm
consider a family fortune. as investigators questioned andy, csi units were busily working the crime scene as well. >> it was a very brutal crime scene. it was one of the worst i've ever seen. >> reporter: one of those leading the investigation? david kofoed, the head of the csi squad in douglas county. from omaha, an hour away, he was called in to help the smaller cass county sheriff's department. >> what really bothers me is that these two people were just sleeping in bed and the male victim was apparently crawling away and he was shot in the head. clearly an execution. >> reporter: close up. >> close up. and the female victim was along the side of the bed holding a phone in her hand, and she had been shot in the eye at close range. so it was very much an execution. there was a lot of blood
1:17 pm
high-velocity spatter fragments, and it was a biological kind of nightmare. it was in the upstairs, so we had to try to get up the steps without stepping on things. >> reporter: investigators found out pretty quickly how the stocks' killer or killers who entered the house. a screen had been lifted, a window appeared to have been forced open leading into the laundry room. from there it appeared the killer's route might have gone past the now empty easter basket sharmon had made, through the well kept kitchen, then up the stairs to where the stocks lay sleeping. four shotgun shells leaving a trail to the bullet. wayne tried to get up but was shot in the knee. the gun fired so close to him, it left this huge powder burn in the head. then wayne was shot in the head. sharmon killed, too, as she tried to call 911. then it became apparent, it wasn't just one killer, but at least two. >> when we did the blood pattern analysis, we saw a void area at the top of the steps.
1:18 pm
i said the first day, and after we had done the analysis, and my person that's truly trained and qualified to be a blood pattern expert, she -- we both said there was a void there. >> reporter: which could only mean one thing. as one of the killers fired at wayne stock from behind, this area, called a void area, was where another killer would have been standing. the second killer sprayed with blood spatter instead of a wall. kofoed and his team found a wealth of evidence outside the house, too. >> it was a big farm operation. and there was a lot of out buildings and it was complicated by the fact that they'd had an easter egg hunt the day before. so we had a lot of shoe prints and stuff. >> reporter: but one print stood out. >> i saw a shoe print in the mud that was unusual. by a flower bed near the front door. >> reporter: and beyond the flower bed, there was a virtual trail of evidence left by the likely killers.
1:19 pm
>> in a gravel driveway, there was a marijuana pipe and about ten feet from it, there was a flashlight, and those two things were obviously out of place. >> reporter: you could sort of imagine the television show "csi." >> right. >> reporter: there's a light, oh, there's a -- it's just too easy. but there it was. >> it was there. i think one thing i knew pretty much right at the beginning was i could visibly see blood on the outside of the flashlight. we knew that had to be involved. >> reporter: but then a real breakthrough. a newspaper carrier called in to report that he and his girlfriend saw something. they'd been driving down this country road middle of the night about a mile from the stock farmhouse down there. and just here outside this cemetery, they saw a car just parked here. strange cars just don't get parked on country roads outside murdock, nebraska, at 3:00 in the morning.
1:20 pm
it was tan or light brown, four-door sedan said the young man. and what really stuck out was that this car later passed them in the same area that same night. this time driving 60 or 70 miles an hour. it was in a rush, it appeared, to get away. investigators now had a number of clues. that car, seen by the newspaper carrier. the flashlight with what appeared to be blood on it. the marijuana pipe. and detectives were probably looking for more than one killer. but a motive? who knew? not a thing was missing. wallets, purses, gun collections, even a safe hidden in the bedroom floor, all untouched. but all that evidence. and asking questions of those closest to the stocks would soon pay off because just a week later an arrest and a confession.
1:21 pm
and another shattering blow to the stock family. coming up -- stories surface of a long simmering feud between the beloved farming couple and the family's black seed. >> just knowing that, i had my >> was the killer at his own family's on you could save a bundle with geico's multi-policy discount. geico, saving people money on more than just car insurance. ♪
1:22 pm
geico, saving people money on more than just car insurance. a vacation on a budget with expedia. make it work. booking a flight by itself is an uh-oh. see if we can "stitch" together a better deal. that's a hint, antoine. ooh! see what anandra did? booking your flight and hotel at the same time gets you prices hotels and airlines won't let expedia show separately. book it. major wow factor! where you book matters. expedia. that i put on my children's plate. that's why we use all-white meat,
1:23 pm
breading that is whole grain with omega-3 and no preservatives. it is my goal to make the highest quality, best-tasting nugget on the market. i want consumers to go, "dang, that's a good nugget."
1:24 pm
andy stock was and still is a grief stricken man. and it wasn't long before investigators restored him to his family and dropped him from their list of possible suspects in the awful murders of wayne and sharmon stock. besides, as detectives questioned the couple's large extended family, another relative's name came up quite often actually. matt livers. he was wayne and sharmon's nephew, 28 years old. he attended the easter dinner the afternoon leading up to the murder. but he wasn't there by virtue of being a family favorite. in fact, livers was considered a black sheep. he bounced from job to job. never finding his niche. family members told police matt was slow, different. he had no criminal record, but there was, they said, an ongoing problem between matt and the stocks. they described disagreements, sometimes heated. they said sharmon had a dislike for matt. the stock's oldest son steve -- >> i think in my head i went to
1:25 pm
it a little bit just knowing that they hadn't gotten along real well. i had my own suspicion. >> reporter: just two days after the murders, detectives visited matt livers' former employer, asked about his personality, rumors that he had a temper. they put a watch on him and went through his garbage, too. this was in lincoln, about 30 miles from the murder scene. then eight days after the bodies were discovered they asked matt livers to come in and answer some questions. >> you're free to leave at any time. >> i'm here to cooperate with you gentlemen. >> reporter: he was unerringly courteous, deferential to the two detectives questioning him. said he'd never been interviewed by police before. >> what do you think happened? >> i don't have any idea. i would like to know why. who, what, when, where and how and why? you know, why would somebody do this to such good people, very christian people?
1:26 pm
very likable people. >> reporter: livers told them after the big family dinner with the stocks, he drove home the half hour to lincoln where he stayed all night with his girlfriend sara and sara's young son and a roommate. he did admit to having disagreements with his uncle wayne over the various family issues, but those were minor, he said. >> any problems between you guys? >> years ago we kind of had a tiff. yeah, but you know, that's been done, forgotten. >> after five hours of questioning, matt livers agreed tie a polygraph. >> do you know for sure who caused the death of wayne stock? >> no. >> reporter: if he was looking to clear himself of suspicion by taking that test, it did not have the desired effect. >> your subconscious body is telling the machine. you cannot fool it. >> i didn't have anything to do with this. >> you did.
1:27 pm
>> i did not. >> you did. >> no, i didn't. >> reporter: for more hours the detectives locked horns with livers. despite his continued denial of involvement, they knew he was lying. >> we've had too many people sitting in that chair that think they're smart and they're not. >> no. you're dumb as a brick. okay? you made a mistake. and you got to pay for it. >> reporter: why were investigators here in nebraska so convinced matt livers was lying? well, besides the polygraph, there was the state profiler who suggested that this is the sort of crime committed by young males who know their victims. how else would they know to find the farmhouse way out in the middle of nowhere if they didn't know them? and add to that, said the profiler, this is the sort of crime that appeared to be very personal. an execution. matt livers rang those bells, all of them, and rang them
1:28 pm
loudly. eventually, detectives got quite explicit, telling livers he was headed for death row. unless he would start giving them what they knew to be true. >> you don't admit to me exactly what you've done, i'm going to walk out that door and do my level best to hang your ass from the highest tree. you're done. >> this is your one shot. we put the olive branch out right now and attempt to help you. okay? electric chair, gas, lethal injection. >> reporter: it was that technique that produced the desired effect. rough, perhaps, but matt livers started confessing. >> you got a gun. >> right. >> and you took that gun back to your uncle and aunt sharmon's house, right? right or wrong? come on now. >> right. >> reporter: now that the cat was out of the bag, livers began
1:29 pm
filling in more of the blanks. how the murder went down, for example. >> you put the gun to her face and blew her away. >> okay. >> and then as i headed out, i just stuck it to him and blew him away. >> reporter: then a bonus. remember how that blood spatter indicated a second killer was involved? well now before they trooped him off to jail, matt livers gave them a name to match the void on the wall. so perhaps it's not so surprising that in the elation of the moment, detectives had no idea, not a clue, that they had just jumped down an alice in wonderland rabbit hole. coming up -- the case snares a second suspect, not just with an accusation, but with what appears to be damning evidence. >> now, that was the real smoking gun. i mean, you got him.
1:30 pm
>> reporter: when "in the dead of night" continues.
1:31 pm
1:32 pm
1:33 pm
i'm alyssa rhee berger. at least 31 americans were killed in the navy seals crash. president obama is in camp david and talked about the crash. a aaa credit rating for the first time ever. standard & poor's decided to take it down a notch after the debt ceiling decision. the children of wayne and sharmon stock were still reeling from their grief as they bury their parents less than a week after perhaps the most horrific murder their little town had ever seen. and then to grief add shock. late one evening son andy answered his phone and heard the
1:34 pm
news from one of the detectives. andy called his sister. >> about 12:30 at night. he says, tam, i need you to be awake. are you awake? i said, yeah, what's going on? he said, they arrested matt and nick. and i said, matt and nick who? and he said, our cousin matt and nick sampson. >> reporter: it was true. matt livers had confessed to the murders of his aunt and uncle. >> put the gun to her face and blew her away. >> reporter: and he'd named an accomplice. 22-year-old nick sampson. a cousin of matt's on another branch of the family tree. >> my husband had given me the phone. i was sitting up in bed. and i said, andy, should i be shaking? he said, that's normal, the shock. >> reporter: but matt livers had been with them at easter dinner just a few hours before. now he said that he and nick had returned to kill his aunt and uncle.
1:35 pm
>> our first reaction was someone need to tell our grandma. she had just lost her only son, skm and her grandson is being arrested for this. and just like us, she's like, i don't understand. and i said, grandma, none of us understand any of this. >> reporter: did it give you any sense of at least somebody has been found responsible? did it make you feel any better? >> we move on to the next phase of this. we're going to wonder for the rest of our lives. i was relieved to know they had somebody. >> reporter: with livers already in jail, police descended on murdock to arrest nick sampson. he was a cook at bulldog's bar in murdock. he was a guy by his own admission liked to drive too fast, had a problem with marijuana as a teenager, had done two separate stints in boys' homes, and now sampson had been printed and processed, then, like livers, questioned on videotape. >> i guess i'll just ask you flat out.
1:36 pm
why do you think you're here? >> i think they think that i'm involved with the murders. >> reporter: but nick sarp -- sampson, unlike his co-defendant -- >> i had absolutely nothing to do with this. >> reporter: during three hours of questioning, did not confess to anything. >> if something's left at that house, okay, with your dna and your prints, how are you going to explain how it got there? >> i'm not. because i don't think you have my dna anywhere near that house because i've never been in that house. never, ever, once in my entire life have i ever been in that house. >> reporter: he agreed to take a polygraph. but again it wasn't quite what the accused hoped for. the polygrapher showed that sampson was deceptive when he denied being at wayne stock's home when wayne was shot. and investigators seized on that
1:37 pm
to ratchet up the pressure. >> you were at the house when he was killed. >> no, i was not. >> your body's telling me otherwise. we need to get past that. what's going on there? >> i honest to god was not at the house when they were killed. >> reporter: but the investigators did not believe nick sampson. after all matt livers had already told them nick sampson was behind the whole thing, that the two of them actually planned the crime together on their cell phones in the two days or so before the murder. and so, said the detectives, they were pretty sure. matt livers was telling the truth. nick sampson was lying. >> you were there when they were shot. >> i was not there. >> i want you to understand how the system works. >> i do understand. i'm getting framed for something i didn't [ bleep ] do. >> reporter: but it didn't look good for nick sampson. he denied being a marijuana user any more, but he had had trouble with the drug before.
1:38 pm
and investigators found that marijuana pipe at the scene. when detectives visited nick's grandfather in murdock, the old man told them that a month ago nick borrowed a 12 gauge shotgun from him, the same gauge weapon that was used in the murders. then investigators executed a search warrant at sampson's home in palmyra. among the items seized, from under the bed, that 12 gauge borrowed from his grandfather, and a pair of blue jeans, examined by csi chief david kofoed's team. >> we had a pair of pants. it looked like it had blood on it. we tested that with phenolphthalein and that tested positive. >> reporter: then there was more. remember that car seen by the newspaper carrier parked a mile from the farmhouse the night of the murders? detectives had found it, they believed. a 1997 ford contour owned by nick sampson's brother. and it had been cleaned and
1:39 pm
detailed actually at 5:30 easter monday morning just hours after it had apparently been used in the murders. who details a car at 5:30 in the morning? >> that's exactly why the detectives thought it was pretty suspicious. >> reporter: but wait, it gets even better. the car had been searched for evidence once and nothing was found, but then csi chief kofoed got a call from one of the lead investigators. >> when matt confessed, he said he threw the shotgun in the backseat of the ford contour. he said maybe you can find some transfer evidence there. take another look at it. i said, well, maybe we missed it. >> reporter: so they examined the car again. and this time, lo and behold, a stain was found just below the steering wheel on the dashboard. a stain found by csi chief kofoed himself. >> i just took it along that edge and wiped it because i figured that way i wouldn't miss anything.
1:40 pm
and it reacted. >> reporter: so you got a hit, though? >> i got a presumptive positive, yes. >> reporter: and before long, tests confirmed that what the csi chief found under the dashboard was indeed blood, the blood of wayne stock, the victim. only one way it could get there, carried by livers and sampson. with the confession and now real physical evidence to back it up, many in the community thought case closed. oh, but they were mistaken. coming up -- a piece of evidence that had gone unnoticed turns the case upside down. is this the ring of truth? when "in the dead of night" continues. what if we turned trash into surfboards? whatever your what if is, the new sprint biz 360 has custom solutions to make it happen, including mobile payment processing,
1:41 pm
instant hot spots, and 4g devices like the motorola photon. so let's all keep asking the big what ifs. sprint business specialists can help you find the answers. sprint. america's favorite 4g network. trouble hearing on the phone? visit that i put on my children's plate. that's why we use all-white meat, breading that is whole grain with omega-3 and no preservatives. it is my goal to make the highest quality, best-tasting nugget on the market. i want consumers to go, "dang, that's a good nugget." an accident doesn't have to slow you down. with better car replacement, available only with liberty mutual auto insurance, if your car is totaled, we give you the money for a car one model year newer. to learn more, visit us today. responsibility. what's your policy?
1:42 pm
if you open up a charge card account with us. [ male announcer ] identity thieves never stop coming up with ways to steal from you. they can open up an account in your name and go on a serious spending spree. do you have cufflinks? mm-hmm. gold ones? [ male announcer ] not on our watch. we're lifelock. go to and learn how our patented billion point database can help protect you. call 1-800-lifelock today. lifelock. relentlessly protecting your identity.
1:43 pm
as april turned to a midwest may, less than two weeks after the murders of wayne and sharmon stock, cass county sheriff's investigators were in mop-up mode. they had arrested 28-year-old matt livers. he'd confessed. and he'd named an accomplice, his cousin, 22-year-old nick sampson. so the cass county sheriff's department called in the press and announced that one of the most shocking crimes in this part of nebraska in decades was solved. >> people ask us is this closure on the case. it's not. it's another chapter, turning a page. >> reporter: though he was right, the sheriff had no clue just how much work there was yet to be done. but for the stocks' children,
1:44 pm
the arrest brought a small measure of relief. at least, they decided, they could try to move on, as they knew their parents would have wanted them to. >> i could hear mom and dad say, tami, you can let this eat you alive or you can go on and be the best that you can be and do what needs to be done. and that is family. and so we can dwell on it, but we choose not to. because that's not what mom and dad would want. >> reporter: now the system could grind forward, too, and the system provided defense attorneys, jerry soucie for nick sampson, julie bear for matt livers. >> first thing he says is, look, i told them i did this, but i didn't do this. and you've got to believe me. >> reporter: they all say they didn't do it, right? >> i've been lied to a lot as a defense lawyer. so the cynical side of me goes, mm-hmm, right.
1:45 pm
>> reporter: yet bear and soucie were puzzled, too. there were things that just didn't quite add up. both nick and matt and their live-in girlfriends swore up and down that on the night of the murder they were at home asleep 25 miles away. and nick claimed, despite what the cops believed, he'd never talked to matt by phone or in person the week before the murders. what? >> the first thing i simply was concerned about was what was the evidence against nick sampson, regardless of whether he did it or not? i just had to know what the evidence was. >> reporter: then quite by chance, this tiny piece of what seemed to be evidence showed up. police missed it the morning after the murder. one sharp-eyed cop just happened to notice it a couple of days later. it was this gold ring on the kitchen floor. >> i thought somebody took it off to wash their hands and fell down and they forgot about it. >> reporter: but at the time it could have belonged to the victim. >> it could have.
1:46 pm
>> reporter: except one thing people should know about the stock house, nothing was ever out of place. so one of the investigators picked up the ring, bagged it and tagged it as evidence. it was a size 10, a man's ring, bearing a message. >> the inscription said "love always, corey and ryan." they wanted to find out who was a ryan and who was cori. >> reporter: who was cori and who was ryan? they asked the stocks' children, nobody knew anybody by those names. didn't recognize the ring either. but as they were arrested and put in jail, one of kofoed's officers kept puzzling about that ring. on the inside were three tiny letter, aaj. the manufacturer perhaps? well, yes. turned out to be a place called a & a jewelers, buffalo, new york. >> i remember one of the girls in shipping had indicated that there was a call from somebody in the nebraska police department.
1:47 pm
>> reporter: mary martino was running what was left of buffalo's a & a office just then. why what was left? the places with going out of business. massive layoffs. 200 jobs lost. by the time nebraska cops started calling, mary was one of only three people left to clean up the buffalo office and close it down. and now, here was this investigator asking mary to track down a ring the company likely shipped years ago. and you said what? you got to be kidding? >> i said that's like looking for a needle in a haystack. however, she mentioned homicide. >> reporter: and that's when mary martino heard about the ring and the double homicide and the fact that nobody else at the
1:48 pm
company seemed able to help. >> she said she had made several attempts and no one was willing to assist her. >> reporter: so mary martino said she'd see what she could do. >> two teenagers from wisconsin whacked out on drugs and want knowing what they were doing. out of control. >> reporter: when "in the dead of night" continues. [ female announcer ] the counter. in most homes, it gets all the action. bring it -- with bounty. in this lab demo, one sheet of bounty leaves this surface as clean
1:49 pm
as 2 sheets of the bargain brand. why use more when you can use less? bounty. the one-sheet clean picker-upper. yes! ha ha! [ clicking ] ♪ what happened? power went out, want a hot dog? [ female announcer ] oscar mayer selects are made with 100% beef and have no artificial preservatives.
1:50 pm
1:51 pm
>> reporter: mary martino was running what was left of buffalo's a & a office just then. what was left? the place was going out of business. i got to 118 and i said, this is dwg to be impossible. she had a colleague made a computer grid of more than the 3,000 stores a & a shipped to across the country, a block of dates when the ring might have been ordered, and cross-reference that with the in skripgs. >> how long did that take. fofr me rkt i fw.
1:52 pm
lo and behold, after three days of searching, there it was. >> it was wisconsin, i know that. >> the ring of the sent from beavertown, wisconsin. it was bought for a boy named ryan, and it soon gathered dust in the cab of a pickup truck. then the strangest thing happened, the truck was reported stolen from here on ryan's farm just a few days before the murders of wayne and sharmon
1:53 pm
stock. jim rohrer was a detective. when they suspected it was some local joyride, instead, what a surprise. >> our dispatch had received confirmation from a parish down in louisiana that they had the stolen truck. >> stolen in wisconsin and abandoned way down in louisiana. >> that's a long way to go. >> what did you think. a couple kids on a joyride that seems to be able a short span of time. .
1:54 pm
he had suicide issues, drug issues. >> he was a little slow. he just didn't seem to grasp things quite as well as a typical person. >> his police was a 17-year-old named jessica reed, a former honor roll student and cheerleader, turned a troubled teen after divorce. she had mixed up with drugs, and in turn, hester. >> there were a few by the beaver dam that fit the descriptions of chuck and sheri. speaking with them, once these two individuals did make their way back to wisconsin, they get a convention with involving them
1:55 pm
from the residents down in beaver dam. >> weren't exactly master criminals, were they? >> no, not by any sense of the word. two teenagers from wisconsin, what c whacked out on drugs and not knowing what was happening. >> but their jobs were not sure what the state had found. that's when rory got the call from nebraska, heard how that ring turned up at the scene of a double murder, heard how they tracked it back to a walmart in beaver dam, cory, ryan and the stolen truck. >> that must have been a shock to get that information, to have it cross your desk. >> that pretty much send a chill down your spine.
1:56 pm
how is this young man tied to t the. provides a chilling glimpse of what may have happened inside that farmhouse. >> obviously that guy is up there killing somebody. >> unless, of course, she's lying. when "in the dead of night" continues.
1:57 pm
1:58 pm
spring arrived. the stock farm turned from brown to green. and wayne and sharmon's children struggled the best they could to put their lives back in place. >> they both wanted us to strive for so much more and said, you know, you can always do better. >> reporter: and so they may not have noticed so much the riddle that sprouted along with the corn. two towns, murdock, nebraska, beaver dam, wisconsin, more than
1:59 pm
500 miles apart. now united, undeniably, by a single band of gold. that ring sold in a beaver dam walmart and found days after the murder in the kitchen of the stock farmhouse. how did it get there? matt livers never said anything about a ring when he confessed to killing wayne and sharmon stock. nothing about a stolen truck or out of control wisconsin teenagers either. one of whom, jessica reid, out on bail over the vehicle theft, responded to an invitation to visit the wisconsin detective, jim roarer. >> she had to know somewhere in the back of her mind that maybe they know more or want to talk to me about more than just a stolen truck. >> reporter: did she? in fact, as she settled in, young ms. reid seemed to view the police interview as little more than a nuisance to be endured. >> my grandma's coming into town, and i kind of -- i want to do this, but i want to do it a
2:00 pm
little bit faster. this going to take forever. >> reporter: jessica was all of 17. did she wonder why the wisconsin cop was joined by investigators from nebraska? >> i really want to know what nebraska has to do with this? because i don't think we even entered nebraska. >> reporter: didn't go to nebraska, didn't know anything about a gold ring, she said. she and fester just stole a truck, she said, and fueled by massive dose of over-the-counter cough syrup, went off in search of the ocean before running out of gas and money and leaving that pickup truck in louisiana. but then they showed her a picture of a marijuana pipe, which, along with the gold ring, turned up at the stock farmhouse. and jessica reid's mantle began to crack. >> okay. i did steal -- i stole a whole bunch of money from somebody. i don't know who, i don't know where. i just remember stealing a whole bunch of money. yes, we did lose that pipe when they stole this money. >> reporter: reid then blurted
2:01 pm
it out. at this farmhouse, now apparently to her surprise, in nebraska, greg fester sneaked in through a window and let her in the back door. in the kitchen she said she found $500 in an envelope. then she said, they left. and the ring? well, now she admitted finding it in that stolen pickup, putting it on, then feeling it slide off her thumb inside that house. where was all this going? >> the reason i ask you is that the two people upstairs in their bed were shot to death. >> and you're saying that me and greg did it? >> i'm telling you, you're telling us you're in this house, okay? did you not -- >> oh, my god. i never killed anybody. okay? i really didn't. this is so seriously -- i didn't do it. i took money. that's all i did. i swear to god, that's all i did was take money.
2:02 pm
i don't want to go to jail for murder because i didn't do it. >> reporter: then who did? remember, matt livers had already confessed and named nick sampson as his accomplice. >> tell us who you were with. >> i was with greg. that's all i was with. i was with greg. >> reporter: but wait a minute. she must have known matt and nick. so the investigators showed her pictures. no idea who they were, she said. never saw them before. >> if they did it, i swear to god, they are some dumb people. >> reporter: then she was told the electric chair stood ready for her if she refused to cooperate, and jessica reconsidered. >> this guy, i don't know why, but he does look kind of familiar. >> reporter: that's nick sampson, who looked kind of familiar. and from there, as the hours wore on, jessica's story shape shifted as did the players time
2:03 pm
and again. until it evolved eventually into a tale that began easter night at bulldog's bar in murdock, where nick sampson, you'll recall, worked and ended at the stock farmhouse. >> all i remember hearing in this house was, bang, bang, bang, bang, bang. and so i was like, that's not good. so i cruised down because obviously that guy's up there killing somebody. i don't want to stick around and have to deal with this [ bleep ]. excuse my language. i'm sorry. but i don't know what happened up there. >> reporter: then with that off her chest, jessica looked at the photo of nick the man she claimed was the mastermind of the murder. >> it sounds really dumb, but i wish he wouldn't have been a murderer. >> why? >> he's really hot. why do the hot ones got to be
2:04 pm
the dumb ones? >> reporter: it evaporated in a jail cell. while detectives focus next on jessica's partner in crime, greg fester. >> conned me into going with her. >> reporter: it was all jessica's idea, said fester, stealing the truck, the ridiculous trip across the country. as for the murder in the farmhouse, that was the guy they met outside bulldog's bar, he said. who squeezed into their stolen pickup truck, led them to the stocks' farmhouse, went upstairs and just started shooting. >> he kind of ran into the room and he -- i heard this scream and he shot again. we all run out of the house. >> reporter: but then, surprise, surprise, fester insisted the man who committed the murders was not nick sampson. wasn't even matt livers, who had already confessed that he was the killer.
2:05 pm
no, greg fester said, it was some friend he communicated with via text message. a guy he called thomas. so a little confusing perhaps, but for the investigators from nebraska, it seemed to be starting to come together. what was their sense of things after that first day of questioning? >> i think sense of accomplishment mainly because we do have confessions from greg and jessica for the homicides. >> reporter: let's go out and have a beer time? >> well, it's a reason to pretty much do a high five. >> reporter: that's just what these investigators did. now with greg fester and jessica reid in jail, detectives set about finding physical evidence to back up their claims. and incredibly, once again, one little thing, not a ring this time, but a cigarette box was about to turn the whole business upside down all over again. coming up -- inside the box, what? a letter from jessica reid. and what she wrote stunned investigators. i killed someone, he was older. i loved it.
2:06 pm
when "in the dead of night" continues. ease of cooking is very important to me. perdue perfect portions is great on busy nights. five chicken breasts individually wrapped, so you can use what you want and put the rest in the refrigerator. and the best part is it only takes 10 minutes. it's my go-to meal.
2:07 pm
2:08 pm
and started earning loads of points. you got a weather balloon with points? yes i did. [ man ] points i could use for just about anything. ♪ ♪ there it is. [ man ] so i used mine to get a whole new perspective. ♪ [ male announcer ] the new citi thankyou premier card gives you more ways to earn points. what's your story? citi can help you write it.
2:09 pm
as spring mellowed into summer in southeast wisconsin, detective jim roarer looked for evidence to support or refute the story told by jessica reid and greg fester, stories that they had witnessed but did not commit the gruesome murders of wayne and sharmon stock in murdock, nebraska. roarer went to reid's place, a sort of flophouse for teens, as he called it. >> what we're looking for is anything at all that would tie them to nebraska or any other location that they were at during their crime sprees. >> reporter: oh, and he found it all right. here, hidden behind a picture frame, was this cigarette box, and inside, a shotgun shell, 12
2:10 pm
gauge, the same gauge as used in the murders. and there was more folded up in that little box. this letter apparently meant for greg fester, that said, quote, and this bullet? well, bunny, it's the only thing left. and i loved it. but that's something we'll talk about one day. but it's here also because that's something i did for you. me. and for you to love me as much as i love you. that's the end of the quote. when you read the material that you found, what did you think? >> that this was so bizarre. that gives you a mind-set of the type of person we were dealing with. >> reporter: then, roarer found a notebook. incredibly, with more words penned by jessica reid. "i killed someone. he was older. i loved it. i wish i could do it all the time. if greg doesn't watch it, i'm going to just leave one day and i'll do it myself." pretty scary. 17 years old.
2:11 pm
>> what this is telling us is that she truly was involved in pulling the trigger on at least one of the people there. >> reporter: time for another meeting with jessica. >> you got some explaining to do. and i'm willing to tell you right now i am at the end of my rope over this whole thing between you and young gregory. i'm giving you one opportunity and one opportunity alone to come completely clean with every bit of your involvement in this. so you quit dancing around with me because i know the truth. >> greg blew a guy's head off. and he shot a hole through the lady's face. >> reporter: there, she'd said it. it was greg fester who killed the stocks. but why would she then write that note? >> greg killed someone. he was older. i loved it. i wish i could do it all the time. if greg doesn't watch it, i'm going to leave one day and go do
2:12 pm
it myself. you're in a lot of trouble, young lady. >> i didn't kill this guy, though! i didn't have a gun! how am i supposed to kill somebody without a gun? i watched greg do it. i didn't kill anybody. i'm not kidding. i did not kill anybody. i promise you guys this. >> you know what? 17 years old and you have just thrown the rest of your life away. >> reporter: she tried to explain the words, changed her story again, confessed to firing one gunshot. then admitted something else quite shocking. that she had enjoyed it. >> okay. i'll tell you guys like i liked the adrenaline of it. >> i know you did it. >> i didn't like what caused the adrenaline rush. but i liked the adrenaline rush. >> reporter: that's a real shocker for you. you don't run into that in this little town too often. >> well, no. and you don't run into it with a young girl either. >> reporter: ballistics tests
2:13 pm
soon confirmed that the shell found in reid's cigarette box matched spent shells found at the murder scene. the murder weapon, stolen from the same wisconsin farmhouse where reid and fester stole the red pickup truck. blood found on reid's clothes and fester's shoes matched the victim, wayne stock. and icing on the cake. dna found on the gold ring and the marijuana pipe matched only fester and reid. both were charged. first degree murder. of course, as all this was happening, back in nebraska, no one outside law enforcement knew a thing. the stock children were certainly in the dark, as they struggled to grip the wheel of their new strange lives. >> we have just lost both our mom and our dad. to lose one is horrible, but to lose both of them. and not have those parent figures that kept this family
2:14 pm
going. where do we go? how do we help andy with the farm? how do we -- how do we let our children have a normal life? >> reporter: meanwhile, in their cells in county jail, matt livers and nick sampson knew not a wit about these developments. then well into june, defense attorney soucie heard the words that changed everything. >> i got a call saying they've arrested reid and fester. up in wisconsin. and we got no details on it at all. >> reporter: but when they did, the lawyers just knew their clients were innocent. >> everything clicked. you knew exactly what the case was at that point. >> reporter: or did they? if the attorneys for matt livers and nick sampson thought their clients were suddenly in the clear, they had some more thinking to do. because now the question was were matt and nick in it together with jessica and greg? >> talk to them.
2:15 pm
present him with do you know these people. >> reporter: and? >> not a clue. >> reporter: maybe he was lying to you. >> reporter: kwh when "in the dead of night" continues. almost tastes like one of jack's cereals. fiber one. uh, forgot jack's cereal. [ jack ] what's for breakfast? um... try the number one! [ jack ] yeah, this is pretty good. [ male announcer ] half a day's worth of fiber. fiber one. when i got my medicare card, i realized i needed an aarp... medicare supplement insurance card, too. medicare is one of the great things about turning 65, but it doesn't cover everything. in fact, it only pays up to 80% of your part b expenses. if you're already on or eligible for medicare, call now to find out how an aarp... medicare supplement insurance plan,
2:16 pm
insured by unitedhealthcare insurance company, helps cover some of the medical expenses... not paid by medicare part b. that can save you from paying up to thousands of dollars... out of your own pocket. these are the only medicare supplement insurance plans... exclusively endorsed by aarp. when you call now, you'll get this free information kit... with all you need to enroll. put their trust in aarp medicare supplement insurance. plus you'll get this free guide to understanding medicare. the prices are competitive. i can keep my own doctor. and i don't need a referral to see a specialist. call now to get a free information kit. plus you'll get this free guide to understanding medicare. and the advantages don't end there. choose from a range of medicare supplement plans... that are all competitively priced. we have a plan for almost everyone, so you can find one that fits your needs and budget. with all medicare supplement plans, there are virtually no claim forms to fill out. plus you can keep your own doctor and hospital that accepts medicare.
2:17 pm
and best of all, these plans are... the only medicare supplement plans endorsed by aarp. when they told me these plans were endorsed by aarp... i had only one thing to say... sign me up. call the number on your screen now... and find out about an aarp medicare supplement insurance plan. you'll get this free information kit... and guide to understanding medicare, to help you choose the plan that's right for you. as with all medicare supplement plans, you can keep your own doctor and hospital that accepts medicare, get help paying for what medicare doesn't... and save up to thousands of dollars. call this toll-free number now.
2:18 pm
summer, 2006. a rain of confusion washed over the farms and furrows around murdock, nebraska. the arrests 500 miles away in wisconsin of two teenager in connection with the savage shotgun murders of prominent farm couple wayne and sharmon stock sowed seeds of doubt in the official version of events. that version had this an open and shut case against two local men. confessed killer matt livers and the accomplice he named nick sampson. their arrests trumpeted weeks earlier in banner headlines and news conferences. now, these latest arrests of teens jessica reid and greg fester announced so quietly had many wondering what was the connection among these four alleged killers. >> i called a newspaper reporter. i says, you won't believe this, but they arrested two other people. >> reporter: sampson's defense attorney jerry soucie and
2:19 pm
livers' attorney julie bear spread the word themselves to local reporters. >> he called me back about three hours later. and he says, i got the arrest warrant from wisconsin. and he said, do you want to read it? i said, oh, yeah. >> reporter: you got that from a newspaper reporter? >> i got that from a newspaper reporter. >> reporter: it didn't come from the prosecutor's office. >> no, it was being sealed. i met him at a bar and for the price of a budweiser i was able to read the affidavit of the arrest warrant. >> reporter: those affidavits slipped to attorneys by a reporter contained details culled from the hours and hours of police interviews with greg fester and jessica reid. >> greg blew a guy's head off. >> reporter: and told the story of the 12 gauge shotgun. the shells, the ring, the marijuana pipe and, most tellingly, that dna. irrefutably linking reid and fester to the crime scene. suddenly, it was all beginning to make sense to those public defenders. remember, they'd been skeptical when their new clients professed innocence, but ever since then, they'd been asking themselves
2:20 pm
one very simple question, where was the evidence? and in their six weeks of looking for it, they had found, well, none. after all, livers' girlfriend, a woman with an impeccable reputation, insisted matt was home all night with her, 30 miles away in lincoln t night of the murders. the same with nick sampson's girlfriend who swore he never left their house that night. and she passed the polygraph. >> if she would have thought that nick had done this, she would have thrown him under the bus in a heartbeat. there's just no doubt about that. >> reporter: then the lawyers went looking for evidence of the phone calls matt described in his confession, calls in which he and nick supposedly planned the murders and the records revealed there wasn't one call, not one between matt and nick in the days before the murder. >> that phone communication never took place. you know, it simply didn't occur.
2:21 pm
>> reporter: but couldn't they have used, you know, those kind of phones that you can buy that you can't trace? >> that's theoretically possible, but there's no evidence of that. >> reporter: add to that a ballistics test confirmed the gun found under nick's bed was not the murder weapon. the spot on nick's jeans thought to be blood wasn't human blood at all. and now the arrests of these teenagers from wisconsin, two people clearly present at the crime scene, but never mentioned at all in any of matt livers' hours and hours of police interviews. all this led julie bear to head over to the jail to ask matt livers face-to-face about these alleged accomplices, reid and fester. >> present him with, you know, this is what's being said. do you know these people? >> reporter: and? >> not a clue. not seen them, never spoke to them. >> reporter: maybe he was lying to you. >> not a chance. >> reporter: it would take another month for copies of
2:22 pm
those videotaped interrogations of jessica reid and greg fester to inch their way over to the defense attorneys. but when they finally did? more surprises. like this comment during the interrogation of jessica reid. >> i know there was nobody else there. it was just me and greg. that's what happened. i am not kidding. and if no one believes me, then i really want to go back to my cell. >> reporter: there were, she said, no other killers. just her, just greg. and that whole story about meeting nick sampson at bulldog's bar? she made it up, she said, after detectives showed her a picture of the place and asked her if it looked familiar. for nick sampson's lawyer, the case was now as good as done. is must be a good feeling. >> no, it wasn't. it was a good feeling to know your client's innocent. it is bad feeling to know your client's still in jail, you can't get him out. the cops are coming up with every other kind of theory they can think of to drag him in.
2:23 pm
>> reporter: oh, yes. there was, remember, that blood from victim wayne stock found in a car connected to nick sampson and spotted near the murder scene. so the prosecutor wasn't about to drop charges against mr. sampson. and he, sitting in jail, had become suicidal. >> nick was in really, really bad shape. and so at that point, i'm trying to do m.a.s.h. psychiatric holding him together, it's going to work out, it's going to work out. >> reporter: but would it? the summer dragged by followed by a depressing september. and then first week of october, the county attorney nathan cox met the press. the murder case against nick sampson was dropped. sort of. >> since there's no statute of limitations on murder, the state reserves the right to refile the charges in the future. >> reporter: hardly the news the stock family expected or wanted to hear.
2:24 pm
though they handled it with surprising grace. >> it's not for us to judge or, you know, to make a statement on that because we don't know. it was this and then it was that and then it was this and then it was that. >> reporter: but imagine being nick sampson. on that amazing day. >> he was cloud nine. it was incredible feeling. >> reporter: after five months in jail, he was free. >> it was incredible. i'm finally out. >> reporter: but nick sampson, even free, was not carefree, not by any means. some things could never be the same again. >> i was constantly looking over my shoulder. seeing who was behind me. you know. >> reporter: so there was a real genuine itch in your back fear that somebody was going to come after you? >> come after me, come after my family. you know? revenge. >> reporter: because around this
2:25 pm
county in rural nebraska were a great many people perhaps a majority who were still quite certain of nick's guilt. after all, his own cousin matt admitted full out that they both killed those lovely people. >> i was upset, at a loss of why my own cousin could do this to me. >> reporter: why would he do it to you if it wasn't true? >> to make himself look better. just using me as a scapegoat. >> reporter: nick sampson was now off the hook. but what about matt? coming up. true, he confessed to the murders, but was there more to the story? a tape surfaces of what he said to investigators the very next day. >> i've been just making things up to satisfy you guys. [ male announcer ] imagine all of your missed opportunities
2:26 pm
in one place. the winning horse you could have picked. ♪ that "old flame" you should have called. ♪ that leap of faith you never took. but there's one opportunity that's too good to miss. the lexus golden opportunity sales event, with exceptional values on the lexus is. but only until september 6th. see your lexus dealer. that i put on my children's plate. that's why we use all-white meat, breading that is whole grain with omega-3 and no preservatives. it is my goal to make the highest quality, best-tasting nugget on the market. i want consumers to go, "dang, that's a good nugget." ugh, great. you may be going up, but those roots are bringing you down! try root touch-up by nice 'n easy.
2:27 pm
to extend the life of your color. nice 'n easy has 50% more shades, so you can find your seamless match. with root touch-up by nice 'n easy.
2:28 pm
2:29 pm
two department officials say it appears the helicopter was shot down. and around 30,000 people attended potential presidential candidate rick perry's prayer rally today. perry asked to pray for president obama and other u.s. leaders. now back to "in the dead of night." the autumn moon in nebraska, that troubled year of 2006, watched over a crop of confusion. nick sampson struggled with the bitterness the long jail-bound nightmare had planted in his soul while the children of wane and sharmon stock tried to make sense of the release of the man they had been told had killed their parents. >> it's a difficult situation. none of us are attorneys.
2:30 pm
none of us are in law enforcement. and you're just sitting there trying to take it all in, trying to figure out, okay, how does this work? why does this happen? >> reporter: hadn't their cousin matt livers confessed? at least he was still in custody. as were those two teens from wisconsin. so it wasn't as if the whole case was falling apart. at least not yet. but if anyone did not feel confused in the october chill, it was defense attorneys bear and soucie, who were as sure as the summer day that both nick sampson and matt livers were innocent, despite what matt told police during his interrogation. >> it was just screaming to me false confession. there was every indication in there that there was a problem. >> reporter: what made it look like a false confession? >> as reports start coming in, we start learning that none of the details that matt provides are accurate.
2:31 pm
>> reporter: something else investigators may not have understood but perhaps should have. matt livers, as his friends and family knew very well was slow. he had a low i.q., at least the sort of i.q. people can measure. in a conversation with authority figures under pressure, matt livers was prone to being led. he was gullible. >> there was a portion of the questioning where they won't let him finish his sentence. they're belittling him. they're screaming at him. they're threatening him with the death penalty. >> reporter: and he believed them when they said those things. >> yes, very much so. >> reporter: and one moment stood out. defense lawyers say. when detectives should have realized just how little matt livers understood what was happening to him. here it is. watch what happens when they ask him to be a man and take responsibility. >> you consider yourself a man? stand up. >> he takes them very literally
2:32 pm
and starts to rise up out of his chair. >> reporter: he's going to stand up. >> he's going to stand up. >> no, be a man, okay? >> reporter: were those detectives even paying attention to the sort of man they were talking to? maybe not. just after nick sampson's release, julie bear received a dvd she'd never seen before. even though she'd asked months earlier as was her right, for all the available material. this is a tape of matt livers in a second interview the day after his confession. once he'd had a chance to regain his equilibrium. >> the absolute truth is i was never on the scene. i don't know if nick is the actual person involved in this. i've been just making things up to satisfy you guys. >> reporter: how long was that second tape withheld?
2:33 pm
and by whom? months and months and months after because he said those things the day after his confession. >> right. >> i don't know that nick is involved in this because we never -- i mean, you can check my phone records. we never talked on thursday or friday about this. and the only reason i picked him out of that crowd was i heard through the grapevine that his brother's car was used. >> what are you telling me this now for? what do you think will accomplish now? >> nothing. i'm just trying to come clean, i mean. >> reporter: now, that was a bombshell. livers' own attorney had never been told by authorities that he'd recanted his confession. so basically from the official story, his recantation simply disappeared? >> right. >> reporter: the cass county sheriff's department declined "dateline's" request for interviews or explanations of how this happened or, for that matter, anything else about the case, but in december, 2006, seven months after the murders, prosecution experts finally
2:34 pm
agreed, too, livers' confessions were deemed unreliable. >> i went over to the jail and matt was in his cell and we told him, you know, it's over. you're going home. and, you know, i probably had the biggest hug from a man that i've ever had in my life. >> reporter: cass county prosecutor nathan cox was, once again, left to make the announcement. >> it's not my intention to try to convict somebody that is not guilty. that's not why i'm in this business. but winning isn't the issue. the issue is whether justice is being done. >> reporter: with that, after more than seven months in jail, matt livers was free.
2:35 pm
>> i'm innocent. i had absolutely nothing to do with this. >> reporter: and the doubters in the town all around him vanished for him in the joy of it all. >> i just went crazy, praise the lord, praise, thank you, thank you, praise the lord type thing. >> reporter: sara was there, of course, to take him home. they are now, by the way, mr. and mrs. livers. >> best day of my life. best day, besides marrying my wife here. sorry. >> reporter: what was it like watching him come out of there? ? >> it was awesome. a relief. just great to be able to be with him again and everything. >> it was a wonderful day. >> reporter: but why in heaven's name did he confess in first place? finally now that he was free, we could ask him. a lot of the audience watching will say, come on. nobody's going to confess to something they didn't do. especially something so horrible as the murder of your own relative. >> well, they changed their
2:36 pm
tactics on me. my rear end was going to be in the frying pan. they were going to be going for the death penalty. >> reporter: you're scared. >> yeah. tremendously. i thought if i tell them what they wanted to hear, that i could get to go home. >> reporter: how did nick's name come up? >> they asked me who else was involved and i started just throwing out names. finally when i said nick's name, then that's when they seemed they were happy and believed me. >> reporter: but the damage is done. the whole thing has left matt and his cousin nick at a loss for words to each other. what has this done to your relationship with matt? >> ruined it. completely. it hurts knowing that he couldn't be man enough after all this happened to apologize. >> reporter: what's he chosen to do, forget all about it? forget about you? >> i think he wants to forget it ever happened. people give me [ bleep ] about it all the time. i try to make a joke out of it.
2:37 pm
but it hurts every once in a while. >> reporter: what will it take to convince them that you're an innocent man? >> i don't think anything will. >> reporter: you're going to have to live under this cloud for the rest of your life? >> probably. unless i move. >> reporter: yeah, well. >> i don't want to move. i love murdock. that's my home. >> reporter: but if it seems strange to you that an innocent man could remain so long under suspicion, imagine how bizarre it was about to become as the accused and the accuser play out a truly disturbing drama we'll call trading places. coming up -- troubling accusations about one of the lead investigators. so you wake up one morning and they say you're a criminal.
2:38 pm
2:39 pm
2:40 pm
the county jail in plattsmouth, nebraska, that is.
2:41 pm
only those two teenagers remained behind bars, charged with murdering wayne and sharmon stock. the d.a. had let matt livers and nick sampson go. which to a suspicious family was puzzling. after all, hadn't the head of csi, david kofoed found a blood sample that tied them to the crime? it must have seemed to you as if they were letting two murderers back on the street. >> that was the way i felt. >> it did seem like they were just letting them go, but i guess nobody knew any different. >> reporter: in fact, some of the investigators remained convinced sampson or livers or both had to be involved somehow. they didn't buy the notion that two drug-addled teenagers just happened to stumble on the place by pure chance in the dark. and anyway, fester, remember, said the main shooter, the guy that led them to the farm was a local named thomas, with whom
2:42 pm
fester had been communicating by phone before the murder. but detectives could find no evidence whatsoever against this thomas or anyone else. and meanwhile, jessica reid kept trying to persuade investigators that nobody else was there besides her and fester, of course. >> i am not lying! if i was lying, i would not still be going on about this. >> reporter: she'd been saying that for months. >> i know what happened and no one will believe me. >> reporter: and though she was right about that, the detectives did not believe her. they still suspected livers and sampson of some involvement. why? remember way back at the beginning of our story, that speck of evidence that csi chief kofoed had found this a car connected to nick sampson and spotted near the murder scene? here's the stain right here on the filter paper that kofoed
2:43 pm
swiped under the dashboard of the car. a second search of the car, by the way. the first by an officer under kofoed turned up nothing. this was blood from the murder victim, wayne stock. how would it get there? it was the fbi that started asking that question. not of livers or sampson. the fbi's investigation was aimed at the local investigators who handled the case. in fact, csi chief david kofoed himself. and after months of digging, the fbi concluded that kofoed must have planted that swipe of blood himself. phony evidence to nail down a shaky case. it was a bombshell. david kofoed, division commander of the csi unit in douglas county, nebraska, was indicted on four federal charges including falsifying records and violating livers' and sampson's civil rights. kofoed pleaded not guilty to all charges, defiantly told reporters he'd rather go to prison than resign, even passed
2:44 pm
the polygraph and was cleared in an internal sheriff's department investigation. so you wake up one morning and they say you're a criminal. >> well, it kind of was like that, but it was more of a long process. and i didn't do it. i just didn't. and it doesn't make any sense. >> reporter: kofoed blamed the stain on accidental contamination. somehow, he said, blood from the victim, wayne stock, ended up on that filter paper probably out at the murder scene and somehow the kit containing that same filter paper was what he later used on the car. but kofoed did admit he broke the rules, failed to log the evidence properly, even misdated the report. >> i did make a mistake. i didn't follow procedures. and that bothers me. and there's no way around that. that was wrong because i'm a boss, because i'm supposed to set the example. >> reporter: it is a little disconcerting, though.
2:45 pm
>> it is disconcerting, but it is also the reason why i say this is ridiculous to accuse me of planting evidence. why would i screw it up? why wouldn't i log the evidence in? why would i make mistakes that point the finger at me. >> reporter: if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it's probably a barnyard duck. >> absolutely. but this doesn't look like a duck. it doesn't quack like a duck. it just doesn't. >> reporter: the federal jury in omaha heard the case and took just an hour to acquit kofoed of all counts. but the state of nebraska wasn't satisfied. appointed a special prosecutor and charged kofoed with evidence tampering. and this time, after a week-long trial before a cass county judge on what one headline called "a dark day for law enforcement" kofoed was found guilty. >> you understand what you were convicted of? >> yes, your honor. >> reporter: at sentencing the career law enforcement man stood up and again denied planning any evidence said the truth would eventually come out. >> i don't believe this is the last of this case for me.
2:46 pm
i'm going to continue on. that's nothing personal with you. >> reporter: but the judge, acknowledging he was moved by letters written by livers and sampson asking him to throw the book at kofoed, did just that. >> the defendant has not acknowledged any wrong doing. he's not appeared to be particularly remorseful. >> reporter: the sentence? 20 months to 4 years. kofoed is in a minimum security state prison. he is appealing his conviction. >> you talk about forgetting to write the report but you don't forget about logging in the evidence. he not only forgot, but he falsified a lot of stuff on the report. that's a bad thing to say it's okay to plant evidence just because the guy's guilty, because how else do you know who is guilty or who is not guilty? >> reporter: no matter whom you believe on the blood issue, there are two people who know in living technicolor exactly what happened at the stock farmhouse that night. and one of them is about to tell
2:47 pm
us. jessica reid, on the evil of easter night. >> two people are dead because of me. >> reporter: and coming up next so i was the guy who was never going to have the heart attack. i thought i was invincible. i'm on an aspirin regimen now because i never want to feel that helplessness again. [ male announcer ] be sure to talk to your doctor before you begin an aspirin regimen. talk to your doctor, and take care of what you have to take care of.
2:48 pm
perdue perfect portions is great on busy nights. five chicken breasts individually wrapped, so you can use what you want and put the rest in the refrigerator. and the best part is it only takes 10 minutes. it's my go-to meal.
2:49 pm
2:50 pm
it's a virtual given in legal circles, when it comes to cutting a deal for a lighter prison sentence, the first criminal to the courthouse win. and in cass county, nebraska, the first to the kroocourthouse accused killer jessica reid. she pled guilty to second degree murder charges in exchange for testimony against greg fester. when it came to him, it seemed certainty prosecutors were certain to seek the death
2:51 pm
penalty. when the couple were roused from their own bedroom easter sunday night and shot to death, if any case warranted the death penalty, this was surely one. the judge ruled the county attorney missed the deadline to announce his intention to seek the death penalty. so first degree murder for greg fester was off the table. before long, a new deal was reached, both fester and reid pleaded guilty to murder in the second degree, and in march 2007, not yet a year since the killings, they entered a courtroom. >> you went to the sentence something. >> i did, the first time i saw him. i didn't think i could feel so much anger and sorrow and sadness. >> i remember thinking, i don't
2:52 pm
want to meet this man. >> in the courtroom, jessica and greg each apologized to the family. and the judge handed down their sentences. for fester, two consecutive life terms, for reid no break at all, the same sentence, two life terms, back to back, no parole ever. and for the stock family, ever graceful in forgiving people afterwards, a rare flash of anger. >> i hope they live a miserable life, because it's turned our lives upside down. they made the choice to go into that house, mom and dad didn't have a choice. my son, who will never know his grandma and grandpa, doesn't have a choice. >> what really happened that night? what led two wisconsin teenagers to throw away their lives by so
2:53 pm
callously killing a nebraska farm couple everyone loved? perhaps only two people in the world know what happened inside that farmhouse and why. and one is now speaking out. >> two people are dead because of me, you know? and i'm -- i have a very hard time with that still. >> jessica reid is 21 now, herda meaner, her presence as she sits with us here could easily be that of a kindergarten teacher. instead she knows she will die in prison and says she's haunted by what happened in that farmhouse. >> what was it like to watch those people die? >> hell. >> and when you see it in why are head? >> it makes my heart drop. that's the one thing in this world that i can't go back and
2:54 pm
fix. >> jessica and fester had been driving aimlessly through wisconsin, iowa, nebraska, breaking into homes along the way. in one she too grabbed a shotgun, a .410. on easter night, there they were, both armed, drugged and wired. and they drove down another backroad completely at random, and greg said stop. and at what turned out to be the stock farmhouse, in they went. greg was like, follow me real quick. so i followed him. and we went upstairs and when i turned around greg had turned on a light in the room. and i seen this guy laying in the bed, i said, come on, let's go, let's do something, because is there were people there. >> what was the feeling you had then? >> panic. it was like craziness, god, what if they wake up? >> but? >> he just turned and went to
2:55 pm
that room. the guy had rolled out of bed, they were wrestling with the gun, and i was startled and my gun went off. and i have no idea where that shot went. >> sources close to the investigation, though, tell "dateline" there's reason to believe that whether jessica knows it or not, her wild shot may have been the fatal one, may have struck wayne stock in the head, with evidence of the blast obliterated by another shot from greg fester's 12 gauge. >> and greg shot the guy in the back of the head, and he went back in the room and shot the lady. >> he ran on the stairs and i ran after him, and that ring that they found, it flew off. i didn't know until later when they showed me a picture of it. i knew i lost that ring, but i didn't know where. >> what was it like in the
2:56 pm
truck? >> we didn't say anything. i started crying at one point and greg just looked at me, he was like, don't do that. >> what about those letters, the words found later in that house with reid's belongings, words she wrote boldly admitting to her crimes? >> i killed someone. he was older, i loved it, i wish i could do it all the time. if greg doesn't watch it, i'm going to just leave one day and do it myself. i don't understand it. >> i hate hearing -- it's kind of like how everything was portrayed. i hate hearing it. >> because it was how everything was portrayed? >> because i'm not like that. >> were you like that at the time? >> no. that was my way of showing greg i was okay with it. when he told me not to cry, it was like, what? i'm not supposed to feel bad about this?
2:57 pm
i mean, how can you have no remorse for this at all? >> to them it meant that you were a cold hearted killer and you enjoyed the process and people saw you, probably still see you as some kind of monster? >> yeah. >> it's all a black hole of regret now, of course. except for one good thing she did. she refused to implicate two men who had nothing to do with the murders. turned out a golden chance to cut herself a better deal with prosecutors by lying and nailing nick and matt. >> do you kick yourself about that sometimes? >> no. >> why not? >> because when i wake up in the morning, i can look at myself and be okay. they're where they should be, on the streets, because they didn't do anything. and i'm where i should be, you know? >> a lot of the members of their family believe that they got away with it, what would you say to those people with their
2:58 pm
suspicions. >> to stop being suspicious? >> because? >> they weren't there, they had nothing to do with this. >> for the stock family, it's just not that simple. can you believe jessica, they asked? they're driven by a common sense instill eed at an early age by their parents. they keep asking who and why? who did this? >> i'd like to know the honest truth about everything. i hope some day we can all sit down, look at each other and say were these two involved? yes or no? definitely? was the blood planted? yes or no, definitely? i don't know if we'll ever know those answers, but i hope some day we'll know. >> a post script, andy has taken over the farm now, built a new house where he hopes to make some better memories. matt and nick are still
2:59 pm
struggling to get back their good names. the citizen who went way beyond the call to find the evidence that saved them shrugs as if it's no big deal. >> i heard homicide. if it was somebody in my family, i would have wanted to assist them. >> poor police work almost did their clients in, even as the very same cops brilliantly tracked the one piece of evidence that saved them and finally identified the real murderers, a simple gold ring. >> had they not been able to trace that ring to its owner in wisconsin, i'm really afraid we'd have two guys sitting on death row for something they didn't do. >> and for more on this story, log on to that's all for now, i'm ann curry, and for all of


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on