tv Politics Nation With Al Sharpton MSNBC December 4, 2016 5:00am-6:01am PST
find out how american express cards and services can help prepare you for growth at open.com. billionaire boys club. donald trump stacking his cabinet with the ultra rich. how will democrats respond? we'll talk to congressman elijah cummings. also, standing up to the trump agenda. how sanctuary cities won't be able to stop the deportations. plus, dylann roof, acting as his own lawyer, potentially grilling survivors and victims' relatives. and the jury in the walter scott case, weighing the fate of his killer. the politics nation legal panel weighs in. from rockefeller center in new york, this is "politicsnation" with al sharpton.
>> good morning. i'm al sharpton. for the 65 million americans who voted for hillary clinton, only to wake up to find a government controlled by republicans, here's a reminder. the country has been here before. >> election 2004 return the president to office and most of the congress will be going back as well. republicans picked up senate seats in six states and on the house side, the gop widened its majority. this leaves the democrats doing a lot of soul searching today. >> rural voters see democrats as too smug, too urban, too elite. now the party faces an identity crisis. should it move toward liberals like dean and hillary clinton or try to appeal to red states? >> for the left, 2004 was demoralizing and yet on election night one of the few democrats
who won that year to become a first time senator had a message for those he called skeptics. >> and i had three words for them, the same three words that are going to carry us because as dr. king said, the ark of the moral universe is long, but advance towards justice, as long as we help bend it that way, i have three words for them. what are those words? yes, we can. thank you, illinois. i love you! thank you! >> the left fought back. in 2005, president bush tried to privatize social security, but democrats stopped him. then he botched a response to hurricane katrina. and in the midterms, democrats rolled a wave of backlash, winning back the house. two years later, that first time senator won the presidential
election. democrats took control of the senate, this past week donald trump began packing his cabinet with millionaires and billionaires and doubled down on a right wing agenda, filled with giveaways to corporations and more. >> we're going to massively lower taxes and make america the best place in the world to hire on regulation. we're going to eliminate every single wasteful regulation. by the way, we are repealing and replacing obamacare. we will construct a great wall at the border. and the nice part, our victory was so great, we have the house, we have the senate, and we have the presidency. >> today as democrats debate the way forward, they should remember they fought back before and won. >> joining me now is congressman
elijah cummings, democrat for maryland. thank you for being here, congressman. >> i'm glad to be with you, reverend. >> first, i want you to take a listen to what a wise man said the day right after the 2004 election when democrats were demoralized. >> it has been our philosophy if we continue to press and press hard on those issues that affect people on a day to day basis, that that hopefully will yield success. we have some evaluating to do. we have a lot of evaluating to do. one thing i don't want us to do is take the focus after those things that affect our people on a day to day basis. >> congressman, in the trump era, what does it mean to keep your focus on issues affecting people on a day to day basis? >> reverend, without a doubt, jobs have to be number one. if a person does not have aob
at a livable wage, they cannot take care their families, it is hard for them to have hope and see a better future for their children than what they had. and so we have got to concentrate on jobs. we got to look at some of the things that president elect trump has said during the campaign. and in instances, we may be able to work with them, but hold them to the promises that benefit americans, but where there is fraud, waste, abuse, bigotry, racism, things of that nature, that we're going to have to fight them at every level. and we have got to show the american people, we got a message for the american people that we hear about them. we care about the fact that they are now working harder, and earning less, if you put inflation in there, and we got to make sure that we are telling them that we have solutions to address their problems and have been trying to address those
problems for years, particularly with the obama administration, but what we found is that we have had maximum opposition, not only to the president, but to the democratic congress, and so we do have work to do. we have to be vigilant. >> let me push you on that work to do. because we just had a democratic leadership fight, you supported minority leader nancy pelosi. but do the democrats need to change their messaging? do they need to change their message to get to the american public what they want to get to them in terms of wage stagnation and in terms of jobs, in terms of concerns for average workers that polls tell us were really turned around by the trump candidacy, even though many may feel -- many of us feel they were being misled in terms of some of what was committed,
promised or even represented. >> reverend, you are absolutely right. i think we could do a far better job of messaging when i think about the things that you just mentioned, minimum wage, and supporting unions and i can go on and on, those are things that we don't just see as good politics, but more importantly, that democrats truly believe in regardless of the politics. so the question is, are we getting over to the american people, making them hear us, but at the same time, reverend, making them understand that a trump administration from what we can see is going to probably be doing everything in their power to destroy unions. >> let me ask you this before we run out of time. you're the ranking democrat on oversight. and the gop chairman is -- said this week that he won't let it go when it comes to hillary
clinton. will he investigate the conflict of interest of donald trump that has been raised? he wants to go at mrs. clinton. what about these conflicts of interest that the incoming president may have? will that be investigated by the oversight committee? >> he claims that he's going to hold donald trump to the same standards, but, reverend, we have asked now -- or six times in the last two or three weeks for them to do something and we had radio silence. >> congressman elijah cummings, not radio silent on this show. we will be watching and waiting and also moving to make sure america works fairly and equally for everyone in the congress. thanks for your time. >> thank you, reverend. now, let's bring in joan walsh from the nation. and matt welch, editor at large of reason magazine. thank you for being here.
let's pick up on the last part. if republicans refuse to do oversight on trump including conflicts of interest, how can democrats hold his feet to the fire? >> they don't have a ton of power. representative cummings asked for several inspector general reports on conflict of interest, on the comey letter. i think he has an aggressive agenda, but i don't -- i don't know -- they'll get a report. but they don't have hearing power, you know. they can make a big deal at hearings that others scheduled. as we saw in the last session, it is tough getting to the bottom of things when you're in the -- >> are there ways that can dramatize this, by refusing to -- for example, you hear the threat by some to go ahead and investigate hillary clinton, no matter what. and in fact at the rally the other night, that donald trump
had, they were still yelling lock her up. watch this. >> we did have a lot of fun fighting hillary, didn't we? right. >> i mean, will the republicans go forward and could this back fire and create an opening for the democrats? >> i don't think the republicans will go forward. i feel like while donald trump said this and people are chanting lock her up, lock her up, most people i feel like are ready to move on and most republicans are so eager to repeal obamacare, so eager to do all the policies to look at abortion rights, to do all the other things they have been talking about and i think because they have both houses of congress, to waste time prosecuting hillary clinton, that's really -- they may not have donald trump for eight years, so to waste that i think would be -- would be stupid. i talked to a lot of his
supporters and trump supporters aren't waiting for him to lock her up. they say this and it is something fun to say, but i don't think they're -- they see it as a mandate. >> not digging in from your conversation? >> no. >> matt, is there an opportunity, a lot of us are looking at the confirmation hearings. trump has just appointed -- or at least nominated some millionaires and billionaires this week with all kinds of interesting backgrounds. >> you're saying there is millionaires in government? >> i didn't just say -- >> i mean -- >> the confirmation hearings, doesn't that give an opportunity for democrats to bear down. there is nothing barring them from going after some of the things that we are hearing in the background of some of the nominees. >> i hope in that process that they're very selective, it is more just that wilbur ross is a
cajillionaire. picking the right fight among people who have the actual opportunity to do things that democrats and nondemocrats alike think are bad, that is is key, just throwing up your hands in the air and saying they're all bad, all rich, all republican, that's not going to get it done. a president gets deference with most of his cabinet. >> unless they're selective in your opinion. >> i agree with that. i think every hearing is an opportunity to air the things in their backgrounds that don't jive with trump's promises. but i think sessions will be a big one. i think steve mnuchin, the treasury secretary, goldman sachs guy, apparently there is a trump voter who just discovered that she was evicted by mnuchin's old company, one west. she's despondent she voted for trump, believed his promises, he was going to drain the swamp and
now we have swamp thing as treasury secretary. and, i mean, i think tom price will be a big target. but you're right, everyone can't be subject to the same level -- >> price at hhs was the one who consistently went after obamacare. but yamesh, how concerned, to matt's point, should democrats be about the fact that all of these multicorporate connected wall street millionaire guys, how concerned should democrats be about that or should it be on specific issues and specific things that much of the public may not even know about some of the nominees' background. >> i think should be concerned about both, democrats i'm talking to are concerned about the fact you have people who have run private equity firms, who have all this money, making decisions about people and really not going to have the kind of working class, even working class white voters but
working class of all races at heart when they make these decisions. but the other thing -- >> you don't have a working class person nominated. what happened to all of the blue collar workers, and all of the people he was rallying in key states, nobody liked that is nominated for this -- >> sarah palin is calling the carrier bailout crony capitalism, which it is. >> really? she figured that out all by herself? >> i'm not praising her. i am just noticing that there are already cracks in the coalition. and i think the hearings are an opportunity to -- >> i think there are microcracks at this point. i don't think people voted for donald trump to make sure that someone with a perfect blue collar pedigree is going to be the head of the department of commerce. >> but an understanding of blue collar people may be something that you can at least get some light in. everybody stay with me. lots more ahead. ahead this hour, accused charleston church shooter dylann roof goes on trial this week.
and he's representing himself. what that could mean for the families who will have to face him. also, a potential showdown at the longest running protest in recent american history. but, first, the fight to stop threats of deportation. i'll talk to a leader of the movement, an undocumented immigrant himself. the holidays should bring joy. so why are you still putting up with complicated cash back cards? some cards limit where you earn bonus cash back to places they choose... then they change those places every few months. quicksilver keeps it simple. with quicksilver you always earn unlimited 1.5% cash back on every purchase, everywhere. 'tis the season for simple. what's in your wallet?
the great north calls >>announout for heroes.waits... train your army and lay waste to your rivals! play vikings-war of clans-for free! ♪ gaviscon is a proven heartburn remedy that gives you fast-acting, long-lasting relief. it immediately neutralizes acid and only gaviscon helps keep acid down for hours. for fast-acting, long-lasting relief, try doctor-recommended gaviscon.
he wears his army hat, he gets awalks aroundliments. with his army shirt looking all nice. and then people just say, "thank you for serving our country" and i'm like, that's my dad. male vo: no one deserves a warmer welcome home. that's why we're hiring 10,000 members of the military community by the end of 2017. i'm very proud of him. male vo: comcast. hillary supports totally open borders. there goes your country. there goes your country, folks. and strongly supports sanctuary cities like san francisco.
we will cancel all federal funding to sanctuaries. >> it was one of donald trump's key campaign threats. a warning he'll cut off federal fru funds to so-called sanctuary cities, areas that refuse to ordinate with federal law enforcement to deport undocumented immigrants. at least 39 cities fit the bill. and since the election, some have come forward, vowing they'll keep on protecting immigrants. new york city mayor bill de blasio delivered that message at trump tower. los angeles mayor eric garcetti says he'll resist trump on this issue. >> immigration is the responsibility of our federal government. we have been very clear. it is not the responsibility of lapd. i think anything that would take away federal aid would cause social, economic, and security
problems and so i'm hoping we can have this conversation separate and without threats. >> joining me now is caesar vargas, co-founder of the dream action coalition. he's an undocumented immigrant. thank you, first of all, for being here, caesar. >> thank you so much for having me. >> you're an attorney. do mayors have the legal basis for resisting trump on deporting immigrants? >> well, first, i hope the mayor and the governor who said new york city is a sanctuary city actually commit to those words, it is not just a campaign rhetoric. but it is not only legal -- >> as well as garcetti and others. >> absolutely. but it is not only legally defensible, but critical to our national security, to assure and allow cities to enact sanctuary laws to assure its taxpayer residents regardless of immigration status that their local government will protect them from federal overreach, when in case they infringe on the peace and security. and most importantly, we have
seen that states can provide more protections and cities to its residents and that establishes jurisprudence. the most important thing is, one, the president does have to enforce the law, but he has to enforce the law accordingo our constitutional rights. and most importantly, he has to respect state constitutional protections, city charter protections. >> let me push you on that a little. let me play the devil's advocate. what do you say to those opponents who say but the law must be enforced? >> well, we have seen in history where we are the same place, you had that fugitive slave act, back one of the most controversial laws of the 19th century. this law congress passed. but in this situation -- those situations, northern states passed special legislation to defy the federal government because they saw that states and cities could provide that legal protection to its residents. and the federal government
cannot force states or cities to strip its residents on protections that the states or cities have provided. so when we come here about, well, the president has -- yes, but here he has to enforce the law, by the state and city charters. >> let me raise something else to you that touches concerns here from people. after the election, trump said that he'll deport two or three million undocumented immigrants. watch this. >> what we are going to do is get the people that are criminal and have criminal records, gang members, drug dealers, a lot of these people, probably 2 million, could be 3 million, we're getting them out of our country or we're going to incarcerate. >> are there 2 million to 3 million undocumented immigrants with criminal records? help me with the fact check here. >> first, migration policy institute has said there is approximately 600 to 700,000
people with some criminal records. but let's be very careful. who are the people with criminal records? sometimes it could be a parent who has worked with fake papers, who -- >> which is called a criminal -- creates a criminal. >> we saw in arizona, sheriff joe arpaio was targeting latinos and immigrants and charging them with felonies. in that case, let's be careful about those terms. when we see donald trump talk about persecuting immigrants, you're creating social unrest because we're not just targeting undocumented immigrants. many of the families have u.s. citizens spouses, u.s. citizen children. it creates social unrest when we talk about this type of rhetoric. >> caesar vargas, thank you for your time this morning. >> thank you so much for having me. >> coming up, one holdout among jurors in a police shooting that grabbed national headlines. will they buy this officer's
claim that he fired out of fear? but, first, dollars and nonsense. why trump's carrier deal just doesn't add up. that's next. coaching means making tough choices. jim! you're in! but when you have high blood pressure and need cold medicine that works fast, the choice is simple. coricidin hbp is the only brand that gives powerful cold symptom relief without raising your blood pressure. coricidin hbp.
even if you're trying your best. along with diet and exercise, once-daily toujeo® may help you control your blood sugar. get into a daily groove. ♪ let's groove tonight. ♪ share the spice of life. ♪ baby, from the makers of lantus®, ♪ slice it right. toujeo® provides blood sugar-lowering activity for 24 hours and beyond, ♪ we're gonna groove tonight. proven blood sugar control all day and all night, and significant a1c reduction. toujeo® is used to control high blood sugar in adults with diabetes. it contains 3 times as much insulin in 1 milliliter as standard insulin. don't use toujeo® to treat diabetic ketoacidosis, during episodes of low blood sugar or if you're allergic to insulin. allergic reaction may occur and may be life threatening. don't reuse needles or share insulin pens, even if the needle has been changed. the most common side effect is low blood sugar, which can be serious and life threatening. it may cause shaking, sweating, fast heartbeat, and blurred vision. check your blood sugar levels daily. injection site reactions may occur. don't change your dose of insulin
without talking to your doctor. tell your doctor about all medicines you take and all your medical conditions. taking tzds with insulins, like toujeo®, may cause heart failure that can lead to death, even if you've never had heart failure before. don't dilute or mix toujeo® with other insulins or solutions as it may not work as intended and you may lose blood sugar control, which could be serious. find your rhythm and keep on grooving. ♪ let's groove tonight. ask your doctor about toujeo®. ♪share the spice of life. ♪♪ still using tampons and pads? there's an alternative that women are raving about. switch to the divacup. it provides up to twelve hours of leak-free protection. plus, it's easy to use, clean, and incredibly comfortable.
that's why over ninety percent of women who tried the divacup said they'd recommend it. i'm so glad my girlfriends told me about it. for reliable period care you'll feel great about, switch to the divacup. aljoh-the latest in health and beauty. i just want to let all of the other companies know that we're going to do great things for business, no reason for them to leave anymore. these companies aren't going to be leaving anymore. they're not going to be taking people's hearts out. they're not going to be announcing like they did at carrier that they're closing up and moving to mexico. donald trump boasting about the nearly 1,000 jobs he says he stopped from moving to mexico. carrier agreed to keep the jobs here, in exchange for $7 million in taxpayer money.
obviously we're happy for those workers. but what about others in the same boat? like the 300 workers at the plant right up the block? they're also about to lose their jobs next year. these are the workers and are happy for their colleagues, but wondering why they didn't get help too. >> the issue we have is is that i feel like the president-elect trump has put himself in a box now to where we got millions of manufacturing jobs across this entire united states that -- they're going to be, like, am i next, are you going to come around with your stick and be able to go to every ceo of these companies and save these jobs and keep all the jobs in america? >> the truth is trump's strategy is unrealistic to save jobs. you need a policy, not a publicity stunt.
paul drugmkrugman points out tr would have to do a deal like this every week for 30 years to save as many jobs as obama saved with the auto bailout. those 1.5 million jobs made a huge difference to those families. and to the economy in general. but, of course, pundits on the right hated the auto bailout. folks like sean hannity. >> day number 70, radicalism, you can believe in, commander and ceo. that's what we have tonight, folks. and who better to take charge of an industry in trouble than your federal government. what we're left with tonight is government running american business with your hard earned tax dollars. >> are you surprised that sean hannity is singing a different tune now with trump in charge? me neither. >> in a major win for american workers, donald trump tweeted
that he has brokered a deal with air conditioning manufacturer carrier to keep about 1,000 jobs that it was planning to send to mexico right here in america. >> we're happy for those thousand workers who are keeping their jobs. but no one should pretend it is a substitute for an actual agenda to create jobs. so nice try, mr. trump. but we got you. [dad] alright, buddy, don't forget anything! [kid] i won't, dad... [captain rod] happy tuesday morning! captain rod here. it's pretty hairy out on the interstate.traffic is literally crawling, but there is some movement on the eastside overpass. getting word of another collision. [burke] it happened. december 14th, 2015. and we covered it. talk to farmers. we know a thing or two because we've seen a thing or two. ♪ we are farmers. bum-pa-dum, bum-bum-bum-bum ♪
my name is jamir dixon and i'm a locafor pg&e.rk fieldman most people in the community recognize the blue trucks as pg&e. my truck is something new... it's an 811 truck. when you call 811, i come out to your house and i mark out our gas lines and our electric lines to make sure that you don't hit them when you're digging. 811 is a free service. i'm passionate about it because every time i go on the street i think about my own kids. they're the reason that i want to protect our community and our environment, and if me driving a that truck means that somebody gets to go home safer, then i'll drive it every day of the week. together, we're building a better california.
tomorrow morning, a juror will resume deliberations in the walter scott shooting. there is apparently one holdout juror in the case. the jury deadlocked about the guilt or innocence of police officer michael slager. the case got national attention after this video was released showing scott running away as he was shot by officer slager. scott was originally stopped for a broken taillight. this week emotional testimony
from scott's mother. >> he said they tasing me and i heard him groaning like he was in in excruciating pain. >> the officer faces 30 years to life behind bars if found guilty. the jury seemed to be focused on this question, did officer slager believe he was shooting in self-defense? >> in my mind, fear, scared. >> joining me now defense attorney and former prosecutor karen desoto, and ariva martin, managing partner at the law firm martin and martin. karen, to you first, what should we make of the fact that one juror, just one, is the holdout
here. >> it is interesting because this happens all the time in murder trials. reasonable doubt a high standard for jurors and it is not unusual in murder cases. this is the ultimate serious high as you can go is criminal penalties and a lot of times it is not unusual to have one juror hold out because they are not firmly convinced for some reason. and so we don't know if the holdout is for the murder charge or the manslaughter charge in this case, we haven't gotten that information yet. so we don't know exactly what information unless, of course, you have more information on that. >> we don't. ariva, what is your take on this? >> i think this is really troubling, rev. we have seen so many cases, african-american, unarmed african-american men be shot by police officers, many of the cases involving white police officers as is the case of walter scott. and you see this videotape and for the millions of people that saw that videotape, that was proof positive. that was all the evidence that
we thought would be needed for justice to be delivered for the scott family. and now to have this jury say on two occasions that they don't think they can reach a unanimous decision is very troubling. >> you brought up -- >> this is a troubling case. >> you brought up an unarmed black man. i went to charleston, around this, right after it happened. the fact is this jury is all white with the exception of one juror. does this in any way affect how they approached or should approach their case? >> you would like to think, rev, that race doesn't matter and the fact that the jurors, the majority of them are white isn't what is causing one juror not to be able to make a decision. but i think in the court of public opinion, if there is a deadlock if this juror is unable to reach a unanimous decision, i think the country will have to explore, examine, raise that question about whether this is about race. >> let me ask you before we run
out of time, karen, the fact that when officer slager says that in hindsight he wouldn't have chased walter scott in the first place, what is a jury supposed to make of that? >> i think they had an expert on that says that when you're under traumatic experiences like that, you only as a police officer have a couple of seconds. so thinking back on it, i think his thing was he could have handled it multiple different ways, or at least that's what the defense was trying to grasp with that. that he could have done it differently, unfortunately he's a police officer, and because of his training, you have to think quick and think fast and sometimes you make mistakes and sometimes you don't. >> the chase, we saw it -- let's tu turn to another case. this week, the trial dwbegins f dylann roof. he'll be representing himself. that means he could cross-examine survivors and victims' family members during the trial. he's accused of gunning down
nine black worshipers in june of 2015. authorities say he targeted the victims because of their race. areva, how unusual is this courtroom scenario? >> it is very unusual, rev, because you have a federal capital murder case, very complicated case, even for lawyers, particularly lawyers that don't have specific experience in capital murder cases. so to have an individual with no legal training, no expertise, representing himself is highly unusual and you hit on one of the salient points here, that this shooter, this murderer will further humiliate, demean these family members, the survivors who will have to give testimony during this trial and not just face roof as a defendant sitting at a table, but actually have to be questioned by him and have to confront him to discuss the most painful thing y can ever imagine that has happened to them. this is going to be an incredibly emotional situation
for the family. >> karen, the judge said that dylann roof, he found him to be, quote, highly intelligent as -- is he intelligent enough to be his own attorney? >> absolutely not. people who are autistic are highly intelligent, that doesn't mean they should be attorneys and in death penalty cases be trying cases. i think this case is really disturbing on a lot of levels. his defense attorneys have been trying to take the reins back and the judge really is denying them. again, the death penalty this is not a case where you want him cross-examininin cross-examining. that's disturbing on a lot of levels. in the beginning of this case, we had motions on whether or not he was even sane enough to even be involved in the case, and now that they have ruled that he is in fact sane enough, now they're going to let him try his own case? it is very disturbing. >> let me go back to the human element here that i raised that
you picked up, the families, the victims' families, having to face this man who killed a loved one and no one knows what he will do, how -- look into their eyes, you have to sit there and look at a man who gave you the most painful experience in your life. i mean, i've never heard or even imagined of this kind of situation. >> it is going to be traumatizing to say the least. and we're going to have to see how the judge lets this play itself out in a trial. we don't know what dylann roof's agenda is. clearly he has an agenda. he had an agenda when he went into that church and sat quietly and waited and then murdered nine people. he has an agenda by asking his very skilled set of attorneys be relieved as council. and i think the agenda is to further traumatize these families. >> they said he wanted a race war. how do we know he won't use this
as a platform for marking and more pain who knows what he's going to do? it is really, really a scary situation to me. karen and areva, thank you for being here. coming up, a picture is worth a thousand words. what mitt romney's face could tell us about the trump transition. plus, the most surprising phone call i've gotten in years.
i thought i married an italian. my lineage was the vecchios and zuccolis. through ancestry, through dna i found out that i was only 16% italian. he was 34% eastern european. so i went onto ancestry, soon learned that one of our ancestors we thought was italian was eastern european. this is my ancestor who i didn't know about. he looks a little bit like me, yes ancestry h many paths to discovering your story. get started for free at ancestry.com coaching means making tough choices. jim! you're in! but when you have high blood pressure and need cold medicine that works fast, the choice is simple. coricidin hbp is the only brand that gives powerful cold symptom relief without raising your blood pressure. coricidin hbp.
high profile meetings with photos that generated instant mockery. >> -- ever in your career seen a serious adult who is wealthy, independent, has been a presidential nominee, suck up at the rate that mitt romney is sucking up? >> but sources tell nbc, romney's name is now not in the top tier of candidates. so what is this all about? what was this all that we were watching? also, rick perry's name threat flo -- floated for the department wonder why. maybe because of this. >> three areas of government are gone, commerce, education and the what's the third one there? let's see. i would do away with education, the -- commerce -- and let's
see. i can't -- the third one, i can't. sorry. oops. every one of those and, by the way, that was the department of energy i was reaching for a while ago. so -- >> it was the department of energy he couldn't remember. so now some wonder if trump is just trolling perry with this possibility. so is trump using his transition to settle scores and satisfy his own ego? and if so, what will he do in the oval office? let's bring back our panel, joan yamesh and matt. what was trump doing to mitt romney? >> i will never try to get into donald trump's head. didn't work this whole campaign. let's talk about the effect of what donald trump is doing, not just on mitt romney, but on the party. mitt romney represents the kind of beating heart of
anti-trumpism in the republican party, which was basically mormons. it was mike lee who never endorsed him, it is jeff flake who never endorsed him, people found to be vulgar and beyond the pale and not sufficiently patriotic. but a lot of those people have come back in the fold including senator crapo from idaho, but so by having him twist in the wind for a long time, and getting those people's hopes up, that level of kind of opposition to trump gets smaller. a lost nat of names floated. theyom massey's name. it is to placate that s anti-trump libertarian -- >> there is politics there, but there is also some of trump doing what some suspect is mocking other people, others suspect -- there is a
personality trait he has that he wants to talk to people himself, he's -- i was on a show early this weekend and talked about how it is to be an out of bo borough new yorker and he called me and made news. he's the kind of guy that will pick up the phone and talk direct to people and deal with people and you don't know what his motivation is and he knows -- he and i don't agree on much of anything. but he'll talk to you. and you never understand the motive and some of it is just him and some of it is maybe having a little evening the score. >> i'll go and say we're talking about the first reality tv show president. and the idea is that a lot of his voters, millions of voters i think remember him from the apprentice. i think he's having a really good time having these people come in, kiss their the ring, having the people floated in front of the cameras. this is someone who hasn't held a press conference for months now, when you look at the
pictures of people coming in, he was holding chris christie's hand on death lock, saying, you know, we're still posing. i don't want to hear what you're talking about, we're still posing. those moments are as a journalist what to me tells me he's really enjoying his time and taking his time and likes -- >> he always enjoyed his time, whether we agree or not. the question becomes will he act like this in the oval and what will the impact be on the nation, on people that really need serious leadership. because clearly when you look at his speech the other night, and his victory tour, he said i'm not going to hold you in suspense, i'm going to tell you my nomination for secretary of defense or i was going to hold people in suspense until monday. why even suggest holding people in suspense? we're talking about the defense department here. >> right. because he's telling them they're getting something special from him.
that he -- >> what about the -- >> i'm well aware, so to your original question, is he going to change once he gets to the oval office. of course not. he's never once changed. all the times we have been waiting for the pivot, for the gravity of the situation, it never came, and it never will come. i mean, we saw that with him calling the president of taiwan the other day, you know, first president since 1979. >> yeah. >> to speak to the u.s. president, what is -- this is just what he's going to do. and some of it is going to seem really refreshing and different to his supporters and some of it is going to get him in a lot of trouble. >> at the same time, let's not underestimate that there is a line here because the people that he has selected are almost the same kind of ways he satisfied certain factors in the party. so even he may relish the parade, he seems to know strategically where he's going or where he's taking council.
>> there is -- he put nikki haley, ambassador to the united states, a big middle finger to ann coulter and that wing of the party and ann coulter very famously calling her an immigrant, which she's not, and a bunch of other things. he is picking people from different -- mike flynn is not the same guy as mad dog mattis. they will buttheads. he'll have some team of rivals among each other inside of his cabinet and they'll represent different constituencies and it is -- >> and a strategy, what i'm saying is -- i propose and dealing with all of that now, but he's been many things, stupid is not one of them. and we can debate about how smart he's been on terms of understanding people and their pain, but he's a strategist. >> he likes to have people in conflict. you think of steve bannon, they're going to be arguing in the white house all the time. i think he also likes the idea of people roughing it out and then him saying, okay --
>> he's got to make the ultimate decision. joan walsh, yamesh, matt, thank you for your time. still to come, standing their ground at standing rock. there's more to the story behind one group's battle against big oil. will your business be ready when growth presents itself? american express open cards can help you take on a new job, or fill a big order or expand your office and take on whatever comes next. find out how american express cards and services can help prepare you for growth at open.com. find out how american express cards and services ♪ everything your family touches sticks with them.
i'd like to close the show this morning with a shoutout to the protesters at standing rock. neve been c they have been camped out for months, trying to stop construction of a pipeline they say threatens the environment and sacred native american land. authorities have ordered them to leave their camp by tomorrow. veterans are now moving in, starting today, to protect them and act as human shields. the protests have been
dangerous, police have allegedly used rubber bullets and tear gas. they also sprayed water on protesters during freezing temperatures. there is nothing glamorous about this. those protesters are cold. they're hungry. and until recently they weren't getting any attention from the outside world. but they didn't give up. and whether you agree or disagree with their cause, you have to respect that because that's how change happens. i know in my life i've seen protests that led to change. sometimes we went to jail, i went three months one time. people can't pay you or give you enough publicity. it has got to be something you believe in, and for even those causes that i disagree, i respect people that will pay a price because that's what will make us all move more toward a
i've been on my feet all day. dr. scholl's massaging gel insoles have a unique gel wave design for outrageous comfort that helps you feel more energized. dr. scholl's. feel the energy! hi, good morning, everyone. i'm alex witt. it is 9:00 a.m. here in the east, 6:00 a.m. out west. here's what's happening. still unknown, the full scope of tragedy after that deadly oakland warehouse fire. the big fear remains what officials might now find in the shell of a building. the election recount under way, do the numbers add up and why has it stalled in at least one state? bitter end, new perspective on the battle over the 2016 election and whether one key group helped donald trump win the white house. new questions this morning in that road rage incident that left an ex-pro football player dead. the gunman is free today as we learn more about his past. first, we have this breaking news. the latest