tv The Beat With Ari Melber MSNBC October 19, 2018 3:00pm-4:00pm PDT
i promise, the voice will be rested and ready. "the beat with ari melber" starts right now. >> i don't want to make you talk too much with your voice, but we do enjoy seeing you on the road and back in the home court advantage. we'll be watching this sunday. >> i'll take it. that's it. voice gone. out. >> see you, chuck todd. we have a lot to get to in our friday night show. donald trump speaking out late today about his support for illegal violence against a journalist. an important story later in the show. >> also, tonight, president obama's point person on health care is here with facts about the gop ads backing health care. and later, a definitive breakdown on midterm ads with rob reiner and the comedian joe mandy. we begin with breaking news on election interference. news breaking today. federal prosecutors are indicting a russian national for interfering in this election. the one in 18 days.
if that sounds like a new and significant development, it is. here's why, very simply. first, this is the first criminal charges for election interference in 2018. you're hearing the right. what you're seeing on your screen, this is happening. second, the defendant, a russian named elana kushinova has linked to putin and was posing as an american to try to trick voters in our country. third, this ongoing effort doesn't just repeat 2016 tactics with those attacks on american politicians. it also includes attacks on the very probe into those 2016 tactics with public criticism designed to trick americans into having trust issues, you might say, with bob mueller. we'll get into that in a moment. the new charges come from the doj, not the special counsel. and the charges are sowing division and discord in the political system, creating and amplifying a divisive social media and trying to elect
particular candidates. that echoes what we have seen before. i want to be clear as we unpack all of this. there are no indications in the new filing that this particular effort has links to american collusion or trump, to be certain. but having said that, i want you to look and note how this strategy that has been uncovered today plays so clearly off donald trump's rhetoric. because the feds are charging that this effort was trying to hype up scandals of robert mueller, telling americans he's a puppet of the establishment who is damaging to the country with, quote, proven connections to the u.s. democratic party. mueller, of course, is a republican who rose in republican administrations before a stint in the obama administration. this russian effort, a blatant remix of donald trump's material. >> mr. mueller has a lot of conflicts also, directly. you know that. mr. mueller is highly conflicted. >> i can say that the people who have been hired are all hillary clinton supporters.
some of whom worked for hillary clinton. the whole thing is ridiculous. >> i call it the rigged witch hunt. i think that really hurts our country, and it really hurts our relationship with russia. >> so that is big. the doj moving forward on these 2018 election charges. meanwhile, there's a related seen playing out in virginia, where mueller's investigation into the 2016 campaign continued with its most high-profile guilty convict, paul manafort, arriving at this hearing in a wheelchair. that's the first time we have seen that. reporters noted he was wearing only a left shoe, that he looked visibly grayer, he was in a green prison jumpsuit with the words alexandria inmate on the back, and the judge was dismissing the ten deadlocked counts from the first trial, setting a new sentence date for february 8th, which means bob mueller has plenty more time to talk to manafort. he's cooperating, and also, look at this. the "wall street journal" today reporting mueller is probing wikileaks contacts with conservative activists.
meanwhile, former trump fixer michael cohen, who has been talking to mueller, had this to say about the stakes of the upcoming election. >> how have you been doing? >> i'm okay. >> yeah? >> okay. here's my recommendation. grab your family, grab your friends, grab your neighbors. get to the poll because if not, you're going to have another two or another six years of this craziness. make sure you vote. >> make suria vote. two to six years of crazy. let's break it down. congressman ted lieu is here on set with me. nbc news analyst howard fineman who has been covering the story and has new reporting about roger stone, and betsy woodruff, who as always is all over the russia probe. my thanks to all of you for being here. congressman lieu, americans watching would be permitted for wondering what did i just hear? why does this keep happening? what does it mean when you look up on the news going into the midterms and being are being indicted in real time, innocent until proven guilty, but
indicted for new meddling? >> i think this indictment of the russian operative is significant for at least three reasons. first, it's not just russian interference in our elections in 20 sane. it's now, in 2018. second, this was not a small operation. based on public reporting, we're talking about at least $35 million. and this is one of many operations the kremlin engages in. and third, i think what's interesting is you have the department of justice, the head of the fbi, putting country over party. clearly, this is not a topic donald trump wants to talk about. but yet, you have these trump officials putting this out before the american people because they realize interference in our elections is so important. >> which you vow as a positive as a time we're told so many things aren't working, you vure that as working. this would be a kind of potential exception to the attempt not just by the special counsel but doj writ large to stay quiet before the midterms, but you can't be quiet about an ongoing effort if you think it's
illegal and is designed to subvert the midterms. >> that's correct. there's what donald trump thinks and then what everybody else thinks. in his administration, they realize the russian threat to our elections is real. they're trying to stop it, and they want to warn americans that that facebook post or twitter post you see may be coming from the kremlin, not from someone down the street. >> betsy woodruff, how do you view this in the context of the wider reporting you do on the russia probe? as always, we can talk about the caveats. nothing here about collusion and nothing that ballparks the scale of this, any crime, any single crime is bad. crimes that have mass impact are worse. but with those caveats said, how do you view this and what does it say about what the doj is doing? >> the important thing to remember that this new indictment highlights but which we knew before is that russian meddling didn't stop on election day 2016. the russians had been endeavoring to influence american politics prior to the 2016 election. they dramatically amped up that
activity during the 2016 election. and they kept it going in the subsequent months and now as this indictment indicates, in the subsequent years. that's because the russians'project based on everything we know, both what the intelligent community has found, what reports have found, what we understand from talking to people who are close to the kremlin who understand the way the kremlin works is that the project wasn't solely or even simply trying to get trump elected but broadly trying to sow a lack of confidence, trying to undermine confidence and faith in american democratic institutions. one of the top priorities of putin and his government is making democracies around the world sort of doubt their competence. doubt the integrity of their governments. we see this not just in the united states but in the baltics, in ukraine, in georgia, throughout eastern europe and other countries the that are in russia's sphere of influence. it shouldn't surprise anyone that this malign activity has been continuing and frankly, we should expect to see these erchts from the russians continue, honestly, for years to
come. >> before i turn to howard and turning the page to roger stone, congressman, i want to ask you about one more piece of this, which is with foreign crimes, you always have the gavel, which is what our justice system can do, and the hammer, which is the full foreign policy power of the united states. and so moving apart from the doj, the wider concern here is that as betsy said, this will continue. but it will continue even more aggressively if there is a view that the united states under donald trump never uses the hammer on russia. i want you to take a look at something frank fig losy said in response to the new stuff. take a look. >> nothing to do with my campaign. >> continue to do it because they feel they have impunity. they feel there's a president here that's not going to call them out on it. he's not stopping them. we have had over two dozen russians and russian intelligence officers indicted for meddling, for hacking, for social propaganda. we have tied it directly to at least the colonel level of the
gru, and our president doesn't come out and call them out on it and demand they stop. >> do you think frank is right that the president not ever using the hammer is basically provocative and brings these attacks on us? >> he's absolutely right. there was bipartisan outrage when donald trump cowtowed in front of vladimir putin at the helsinki summit. what the russians see from that is the president of the united states is not going to do very much against the russians for meddling in our elections. when donald trump keeps saying this is a hoax, this is a witch hunt. that just incentivizes the russians to keep trying to attack us, and that's why they have been so brazen. i'm pleased that at least the department of justice officials under donald trump see this differently. they're going to go after these russians and try to do what they can to stop this meddling. >> while that's going on, howard, the russia probe continues the investigations. reporting we had this week that manafort, who was, as i mentioned, in court today, is be asked about roger stone and walk us through what you know from your reporting. the history of their relationship and what you heard
from mr. stone today. >> right. before i get to that, if you don't mind for one quick second, i would say to bring it back to the united states, not just the ukraine and balkans and so forth, what we're seeing here, every time i think i have seen everything, i see something new in this. what's happening here is the offshoring of obstruction of justice. by interfering in the mueller probe, the russians are basically doing the administration's bidding in terms of trying to obstruct justice. and that's amazing. not to mention the fact that the same money guy in russia who was behind the 2016 efforts, apparently, is also the guy behind the activities that were indicted -- that led to the indictment today. as for roger stone and paul manafort, they have known each other since the '70s, literally. they have had an on again/off again relationship personally, but they basically have been allies in terms of politics and money for all that time.
if there's anybody on the planet who can explain roger stone, it's paul manafort. paul manafort has spent 50 to 60 hours at least talking to the investigators. at least partly, i'm assuming, about roger stone. and don't forget, roger stone indicated, seemed to indicate that he had advanced knowledge of what was coming down about the e-mails. roger stone has flatly denied that in a way, over and over again, but he also sent me a text today when i asked him about it that i thought was interestingly and carefully worded. he said manafort knows nothing whatsoever to contradict what i have said previously. there's no collusion, et cetera. and the fact that he said that manafort knows nothing to contradict what i have said sounds to me at least a little bit carefully worded here. and really, one could argue that donald trump himself was inviting publicly the russians to interfere, and i think in
that famous statement that he made about how, you know, please, russia, if you have those e-mails, let's see the e-mails. that, to me, and i think probably in mueller's mind, in and of itself is evidence of collusion. if anybody would know about that, it would be roger stone. >> and so howard, you talk about their link. the director of get me roger stone, who obviously picked up on a very newsworthy subject in his profile, was on the beat last night talking about how it was roger who elevated manafort and be careful what you wish for. take a look. >> ironically, even though this was manafort's opportunity to get back on the national stage in an extremely important role, it ultimately has proven to be his undoing. >> you have done some hard reporting there. i would like you to do some soft speculation. if you're willing. it is television, howard. what is going through donald trump's mind as he thinks about these two people, one being
wheeled into a courthouse today with bob mueller controlling his future. the other on the outside, still talking tough, mr. stone. and what they know. >> well, i was covering the campaign when manafort came into the picture. i think it's probably fair to say that roger stone had something, not definitive power, but had some role in suggesting that paul manafort would be a good guy to run the campaign at that time. when roger did that, you know, he knew that he was going to get a guy in power there, in the campaign that he, roger stone, had worked with on and off for 40 years. i think that's a relationship that's got to be one of the things that mueller is looking at very carefully. as you said, roger stone flatly denies that he had any involvement in any kind of collusion and so forth. but it's bob mueller's job and his assignment to pick apart every detail to set up the
timeline, to figure out what roger knew when he knew it. and i think that is going to be more important in the long run than perhaps we might have thought at the very beginning. >> betsy, final thought on all the above. >> the important thing to remember with the mueller probe is that it's simultaneously a criminal investigation and a counterintelligence investigation. there are two different silos. as these indictments come out, and if any future mueller indictments come out, they will cast significant light on the ways the russians try to influence the election process in 2016. however, mueller's also gathering an enormous amount of information that will never see the light of day because it's going to be related to the way the united states monitoring foreign espionage. much of it will be highly classified. as people are trying to make sense of the probe and figure out what impact it will have on american politics going forward, everything we know from mueller's team is very much going to be the tip of the iceberg. >> my special thanks to betsy and howard. congressman lieu, we'll see you
as part of our programming in l.a. tomorrow. i want to move to another news item. thanks to all of you. >> turning to breaking news from saudi arabia. we can report tonight, saudi arabia's state news agency is now conceding formally that "washington post" reporter jamal khashoggi is dead. while that has been reported widely in western media, this is significant because it is actually, believe it or not, the first official confirmation in the saudi government that they are publicly admitting khashoggi is dead. saudi prosecutors also state that 18 saudis have been detained in connection with all of this. this comes one day after president trump, facing significant criticism for his ongoing response to the controversy, publicly said that it appears to him that khashoggi had died. we'll have more on that story as warranted. we wanted to bring you that as soon as it broke. when we come back, the gop' midterm problems on obamacare. why they're for it after being against it. obama's health secretary, kathleen sebelius on the beat.
>> also, donald trump doubling down on violent rhetoric about attacking journalists. this time inside the united states. and we're going to speak with award-winning director rob reiner about the best and worst ads of 2018, including what happens when life imitates "veep." >> the liberal left wants to chop defense spending. no way. >> well, someone is chopping back. selina meyer thinks she can chop our prosperity, our dignity. >> i'm about giving our troops the edge. >> you can't make it up because "veep" already did. and later tonight, fallback friday. the first time we paired sinbad with richard painter. i'm ari melber on "the beat" where the trump baby blimp is flying over the skies of southern california. we'll be right back.
our dad was in the hospital. because of smoking. but we still had to have a cigarette. had to. but then, we were like. what are we doing? the nicodermcq patch helps prevent your urge to smoke all day. nicodermcq. you know why, we know how. ato be there... for the good. and not so good. for the mundane. the awe-inspiring. the heart racing. the heart breaking. that's what life is all about... showing up. unless migraine steals your chance to say "i am here."
that's why, we created aimovig.. a preventive treatment for migraine in adults. one dose, once a month. aimovig is proven to reduce the number of monthly migraine days. for some, that number can be cut in half or more. the most common side effects are pain, redness, or swelling at the injection site and constipation. these are your days what will each one bring? doesn't matter, as long as you can say... "i am here." talk to your doctor about preventing migraine with aimovig. and be there more. - anncr: as you grow older, -your brain naturally begins to change which may cause trouble with recall.
- learning from him is great... when i can keep up! - anncr: thankfully, prevagen helps your brain and improves memory. - dad's got all the answers. - anncr: prevagen is now the number-one-selling brain health supplement in drug stores nationwide. - she outsmarts me every single time. - checkmate! you wanna play again? - anncr: prevagen. healthier brain. better life. you can do things like change your settings, learn tips and tricks, troubleshoot,
and even manage your account. finding your xfinity username or wifi password, restarting your equipment, or paying your bill is easier than ever with x1. x1 help. another reason to love x1. say "teach me more" into your voice remote to get started. we are back with more breaking news from saudi arabia. the state news agency has now been widely reported for many days. jamal khashoggi is dead. this is a development given their past inability to state. >> congressman lieu, you were speaking about some of the foreign policy issues. what we see is a movement by saudi arabia.
more important for foreign policy implications is the underlying facts. what is your view? >> first of all, i'm pleased that saudi arabia has finally realized that when you cut up a human being into little pieces they will in fact be dead. i think it is outrageous that president trump continues to defend saudi arabia. this was a murder of a journalist inside a saudi embassy by a team sent by saudi arabia. clearly, the crown prince is either implicated in that or responsible. it is his government, and he has a lot of explaining to do. congressman jim mcgovern and i introduced a bill today that makes it easy for the house of representatives to halt arms sales. we need to look at the arms sales pending to saudi arabia. they need to suffer consequences so they don't do this again. >> stay with me, congressman. msnbc's ayman mohyeldin is joining me by phone. i want to get your analysis as well. this question to both of you. i'm going to read more from the statement because while it acknowledges the death, it also puts forward what you can
charitably call a theory of the case, and what many critics would be calling a cover-up. it says there were -- this is from the general prosecutor of the saudi press agency. discussions occurred between mr. khashoggi and the persons who met him while he was in the consulate in istanbul. then it says, i'm reading, for listeners and viewers of our program, not reading the fact. this is reading their allegation and statement. quote, that led to a quarrel and fighting by hand with jamal khashoggi, which led to his death. reading that again and then i'll get both of your responses. the saudi prosecutor saying there was quarrel, fighting by hand with khashoggi, which, quote, led to his death. >> that is on its face ridiculous. the public reporting is they brought a bone saw to interrogation. you don't do that unless you expect to dismember the human being. in addition, khashoggi is facing up to 15 highly trained saudi killers. he's not going to get into a fist fight with 15 people. that is absurd on its face. >> and ayman mohyeldin joining
us by phone. your view of this new statement from the saudi government. >> yeah, this is obviously a story that is developing quite rapidly, ari. we're getting now information on a few different levels. officially from the saudi press agency which is the official spokes agency if you want to call it, the media agency of the government. here's what we're learning. they identified 18 people that are now being subject to investigation, according to the public prosecutor's statement, that is being broadcast. in addition to that, interestingly enough, we now have two individuals that have been named as part of this investigation who have been removed from pretty senior positions within the saudi government. first of all, the deputy head of general intelligence, that is a name that has been floating around in the media for some days now, but we know he's been removed from his position. that's a pretty powerful position, and pretty senior. he's in the intelligence
structure of the saudi government. in addition to that, a royal adviser, a royal court adviser, has as well been removed from his position. now, why those two names are significant, because there have been questions as to how high up the chain of command this investigation would go and who would be held responsible. now, immediately, a lot of people are going to be questioning how is it possible that the deputy had -- the deputy general of intelligence carried out an operation like this or carried out some kind of botched operation had he not been given a clear command from somebody within the royal court. those are going to be questions that i think a lot of people are going to be watching closely in the coming hours and coming days. what we do now know from the prosecutor's statement is that 18 individuals are being investigated in addition to how this has initially played out, as you were reporting, that jamal khashoggi was somehow involved in a brawl of sorts --
>> a quarrel. >> with individuals inside -- yeah, a quarrel, with individuals inside the saudi consulate. again, it is certainly on the surface seems to be addressing some of the initial questions that a lot of journalists were asking. but at the same time, it immediately raises a new round of questions that i just outlined. >> stay with me. as we have been reporting here, the saudi government for the first time both acknowledging the death of the u.s. resident journalist jamal khashoggi, that occurred inside the consulate, and also putting forward a brief description of what they say happened. amyman mohyeldin here as part o the breaking coverage as is congressman ted lieu. i want to add to our discussion howard fineman. howard, do you see the headline here that under pressure, the saudis havic acknowledged what others knew and said and reported or the headline that we're seeing them settling on a kind of of a cover story that
says that there was a, quote, quarrel and fighting by hand, which led to his death? >> well, i have been struck, ari, by the fact that over the last two or three days, multiple reports and multiple media outlets have been reporting on what the saudis were going to cook up as their cover story. it's, again, one of those things you never thought you would see, active reporting on how they would construct their story. i have a really good source who knows the royal family very well and says of mbs that he's a kind of jekyll and hyde character who obje on the one hand loves the approval of the west in terms of trying to modernize certain aspects of saudi society. but a guy who can run off the rails at any time. that's one branch of the story that's going to be pursued. the other is the, frankly, ludicrous story that's just been put out that's not going to withstand the light of day for, you know, ten, 12, 24 hours. and then, most important for americans is the question of
donald trump and moral leadership in the world. do americans care that a president of the united states seems to be willing to look the other way? not only look the other way, but perhaps actively cover for the kind of autocratic characters that he seems to favor. that may crystalize that in the minds of americans. does it mean it will be pivotal in the midterm elections? probably not, but does it mean the larger question of donald trump's leadership is going to be on the table? absolutely. that's the american political perspective, and that is just going to be a growing story, not one that's going to end with this story put out by the saudis. >> stay with me, howard. ayman mohyeldin, who has been part of our coverage by phone, are you still with me? >> yeah,ium wi iu'm with you, a. >> you hear the breakdown on the domestic side. what else can you tell us and tell viewers about why this is happening now.
what pressure was brought to bear? obviously, this is a very sparse statement. you don't have to be a foreign policy expert to say, well, if the guy went into the building and that was on tape and didn't come out of the building and your best cover story is they got into a fight, which adds some doubt to it, why now? >> yeah, i mean, that's a very good question, ari, but the stort answer to that is without a doubt, it's the international pressure that has mounted since october 2nd when jamal khashoggi disappeared. and just because this information continues to trickle out, i think one of the important things to emphasize real quickly if i may is that what we're also witnessing this evening is a massive shakeup of the saudi intelligence apparatus. there have now been several positions that have been announced in the last few minutes i have been on the air with you, several senior figures of the saudi intelligence agency that have now either been dismissed or removed from their positions. so what we're seeing right now is a massive undertaking by the
saudi government to clear out, if you will, some very senior officials of the saudi intelligence agency. now, that in itself is going to raise a lot of questions, but going back to your point as to how we got to this point, it really began with the disappearance of khashoggi and the international pressure that mounted shortly after that, beginning with the turkish government, which made very clear early on that not only did khashoggi, according to their initial assessment, not only was he killed inside the saudi consulate, but they had overwhelming evidence to support that conclusion. although they never made any of that evidence public, they slowly began to release it and leak it to turkish media and share it, according to turkish sources with their allies. did they release the recording? nobody that we have spoken to that the turks say they have, nobody that we have spoken to was able to confirm that they heard an audio recording. but it was enough to change the international momentum, to really put pressure on the saudis. keep in mind, the saudi
government very early on, the crown prince himself, said that they believed jamal khashoggi walked out of that consulate alive. they did not have any reason from their perspective to feel or fear he had been killed. obviously, that was certainly something a lot of the international community did not believe. we started getting reports from the u.s. that the intelligence community in the u.s. is drawing their own conclusions that he was not alive. we also heard that from president trump over the course of the past several days. the growing conclusion was he was not alive and there was mounting pressure as to whether or not the saudi pressure, all the way from the king to the crown prince, was going to thoroughly investigate this. here is the interesting part. the news from this evening as well, and there are a lot of questions as to how the politics of the saudi royal family may play out with the crown prince himself be pushed aside, would somebody else take that position? what wewood see in terms of the shakeup of the royal court? it seems as of now, as of this
evening, nothing is happening inside the royal court so far with the exception of the removal of a senior adviser and most of the dismissals have been taking place on the intelligence side or the general intelligence agency of saudi arabia. that's where all of the shakeup seems to be happening this evening. and the timing of this, ari, should not be lost on anyone. you're talking about friday at the end of the week. it's 1:00 a.m., 2:00 a.m. here now in this part of the region, in saudi arabia. and this news is just beginning to trickle out, coming out. this is in western standards would be considered a friday news dump in the middle of the night. >> ayman mohyeldin made several important points, both about the internal dynamics in saudi arabia as well as timing. it is friday night here, even later there. stay with our breaking coverage. at 6:30 p.m. on the east coast, 3:30 on the west coast, the news development is about a scandal that has really overtaken foreign policy in the trump white house. saudi arabia now confirming the
u.s. resident jamal khashoggi was basically killed, is dead, and putting forward a theory for what happened. i'm joined by chief white house correspondent hallie jackson, who has been reporting on the trump administration's efforts to deal with this. the changing story line. you're there on a friday night in front of the white house. what is the latest from your reporting? >> so ari, nothing yet from either the national security council or from president trump in the white house here, but keep in mind where he will be in actually almost to the minute three hours from now. he'll be on a stage in arizona. he's at a campaign swing out there, and the president may find that to be the forum during which to address this breaking news now, coming out from turkey and saudi arabia about the death of the presumed death of jamal khashoggi. a couple points to note here. the president when he was in arizona a couple hours ago was fairly chatty about this. after acknowledging, as ayman pointed out and you pointed out, that he did believe, he saw no other option than khashoggi is dead, as the saudis are now for the first time acknowledging, he
also today opened the door to what exactly these new punishments might be against the saudis if he deems that is what's appropriate. he said that congress would end up heavily involved in that. he said they -- members of congress would be consulted closely on what he would do. he also opened the door to the possibility of sanctions. we have talked about this $110 billion arms deal and the president closing the door on anything happening there, but it is coming at a time when there's that major conference in riyadh next week. business conference, business leaders, international leaders from around the world will be attending. not treasury secretary steven mnuchin. however, "the washington post" is now reporting mnuchin may still go to saudi next week for a separate counterterrorism conference. i was told that the reason for that is the counterterrorism is a huge focus and effort for some of the treasury department's portfolio and obviously the center happens to be in riyadh and that's where he has to go, but it's interesting timing particularly given what we're hearing tonight. i think we will hear more from
the west wing. listen, it's a friday night, and the president is out of town. he's in arizona, but it doesn't mean that the white house is not still looking at this, obviously, as is the national security council. i have been strucked by based on my sources they really let this be a diplomatic effort so far. john bolton is involved in this, in briefing the president. chief of staff john kelly as well. but it's mike pompeo taking the lead. >> right. taking the lead and taking the lead in the changing tone, because this is certainly different, both the building you're standing in front of as well as what we're hearing late in the middle of the night in saudi arabia tonight. hallie jackson, thank you for your reporting. as we mentioned, the saudi government confirming for the first time jamal khashoggi was killed inside that consulate, putting forward a theory as to why. we'll stay on the story as warranted. up next, we'll return to our midterms coverage and a bunch of other important story on "the beat" when we come back. . that's right no fees on loans to remodel your bathroom.
we've hadfor a long time.is in san francisco and half-measures haven't fixed it. homelessness doesn't just hurt homeless people. it hurts all of us. that's why we're all voting "yes" on c. the plan is paid for by corporations that just got a massive tax break. it's time for them to give back by helping all of us to fix our homeless crisis. with more affordable housing... expanded mental-health services... clean restrooms and safe shelters. vote "yes" on c. it helps all of us.
as mentioned, we're going to keep an eye on the developments out of saudi arabia, where that country has confirmed the death of jamal khashoggi for the very first time. but there's a lot of other news going on, including, of course, the midterms. donald trump sowing fear 18 days out from election day, accusing democrats of mob rule. of course, this is hours after applauding a republican congressman and candidate who attacked a reporter. >> any guy that can do a body slam, he's my candidate. he's my guy. the democrats don't like being called an angry mob. but really, that's what they have become. they're losing it, and they shouldn't be. >> question there, critics asking, who is acting more like a mob leader? there's also fears stoked over immigration. attacks on a caravan of honduran migrants drawing closer to the u.s. border. in a moment, i'm going to get
reaction from wilmer valderrama. he's also on ncis. his family immigrated from venezuela when he was 14, and he has been outspoken oin immigration reform, and i'm also joined by axios political reporter alexi mckaman. i want both of you to take a listen to donald trump's claim that someone is secretly paying this migrant caravan to cross the border. >> we're starting to find out, and i won't say it 100%, i'll put a tiny question mark at the end. but a lot of money has been passing through people to come up and try to get to the border by election day. because they think that's a negative for us. they wanted that caravan, and there are those who say that caravan didn't just happen. it didn't just happen. all caused because of the illegal immigration onslaught brought by the democrats.
>> wilmer? >> okay, so this is like a very old traditional dinosaur tactic of scaring the general public in the midterm elections on what's really going on. this is really another way to distract and divert the real topic, which is answering questions about the economy and health care, which is what people want to hear about in the midterm election. they continue to, you know, focus on things like look this way, don't ask these questions. i mean, it's literally just old tactics. it happens every cycle. they have the same recipe, and it doesn't scare anyone. >> can i just take us back to october 2016? right before the 2016 election, that's when donald trump introduced the phrase bad hombres and ramped up his immigration rhetoric, showing to deport all the bad hombres. he also made the false claim that border patrol agents were illegally allowing people into the country to vote in the
election. you no see that same exact strategy happening ahead of the 2018 midterms because he knows the republican party is in trouble and he thinks stoking this fear or fear of loss is going to turn out republican base voters. >> the big thing for them, and i brought numbers because i think it's important for people to know, florida has now a record, 2.1 million latino voters making up about 16.4% of the state electorate. now, that's something that historically, now, florida is experiencing a moment in time where something can really drastically change. texas has about 41% of latinos who are eligible to vote are between the ages of 18 and 33. so you know, furthermore, 60% of latinos have not been reached out to by any campaign. when you look at the actual potential and what's really going to happen in the midterms and all the scare tactics are not going to get anybody to stay home. they're going to be turning out. >> you think it's mobilizing. >> i think it is.
fwl we talk a lot about the cliche this is a nation of immigrants. eric trump was leaning into that, but more as a defense of their rhetoric. take a listen to eric trump on all this. >> this isn't an american problem. you take care of your own problem. make sure this doesn't show up on our southern border. >> people would say that's heartless. >> it's not heartless. it's not heartless at all. you have to come into this country legally. guys, i'm the product of immigration. my mom wasn't born in the united states. my father's current wife wasn't born in the u.s., but the difference was they came into this country legally. >> you want to go first? >> what i will say about that is that i will make the argument that on both sides, democrats and republicans, we saw earlier this year there was no real incentive for either party to reach comprehensive legislation on immigration. to come to an agreement, because they knew it would be politically savvy. that's not to say some lawmakers didn't genuinely want to find an agreement, but donald trump has
no incentive to find an agreement on immigration legislation, so when eric trump is talking about doing it legally, the president himself is not talking about it. he's talking about building a border wall, which doesn't have extreme support, he doesn't have the money for, and that's not comprehensive legislation to find a comprehensive path to immigration. >> you talk about being a businessman. you know, and you want to deport 50-plus billions in social security that they will never see, and the actual taxes that the illegal, really undocumented immigrants are actually paying to this country, and imagine if you are given the ability to get a real minimum wage and be taxed lie all of us, i mean, where would the economy be, in many of the states where they take the jobs you don't see. to me, it's, again, pivoting, look at this thing. here's a problem they created, but really, the truth of the matter is we're not thinking about the reform. we're not thinking about the road to solution, and how can we be more proactive and more efficient with the situation we
have. i think that it's really silly to think that, you know, that you're going to deport all these immigrants and now question residents and other citizens that were naturalized here. you know, and their contribution to this country. >> finally, i have about 30 seconds and then we're going to an update from richard engel on the other saudi story. when you look at these people saying, well, midterms, young people are never that interested, you have a following. what do you say to young people about voting next month? >> you have a moment right now to make history. this is the moment where march of our lives and young people connected, you know, when you see what happened with march for our lives and see how they connect and mobilize, understand that that passion and that fire has now strategized. the movement is the midterms. we have a coast-to-coast movement now and i'm involved in a number of them. some with latinos and a number of other incredible organizations. i'm going to el paso election
weekend. i'm going to miami, and i'm going back to houston. and we're getting together. we're going to show up. i think that's something that people are going to be not only surprised, but it's going to be historic. you have the power to not only pivot, but texas is going to look different in five or ten years. >> very interesting to hear an update on your work. alexi, good to have you here. >> we're going to take a break, so my thanks to both of you. but we continue our coverage of this breaking news out of saudi arabia. richard engel, nbc news chief foreign correspondent, is able to join us live from istanbul. richard, the latest on your end? >> well, this is something we have all been waiting for for a long time. this is something that the u.s. government, president trump, has demanded an explanation from the saudis. what happened to jamal khashoggi? over two weeks ago, the saudi journalist walked into the saudi consulate in istanbul where i am
right now and was never seen to emerge. even though his fiancee was waiting for him outside. turkish officials have said time and time again that they believe he was murdered inside the consulate, that he was interrogated, tortured, his body dismembered. the saudis until now have been saying they don't know what happened to him, until now. a short while ago, the saudi state television quoting a state prosecutor said that khashoggi did in fact go into the consulate. we all know that. but they say that he got into a fight once he was inside. a fist fight that resulted in his death. they also said that 18 saudi nationals have been arrested in association with this incident, as they were describing it. and in another statement on saudi television, they announced that the deputy head of saudi intelligence has been removed from his position.
he would be the most senior saudi official to be punished for this crime. that's their explanation. there are some holes in it, but that's what they're saying. >> and richard, how do you split the difference there between the emphasis in the statement that they claim they have all these people under arrest, which suggests some sort of rogue operation or people committing crimes, with the cover story, as i'm calling it, that somebody got into an altercation and just mysteriously died and it took this long to even say that much? >> well, they're not exactly saying that it was a fight that happened between two people. there have been some suggestions, hints really, coming out in saudi influence media that this may have been an attempt to capture khashoggi. that this was a rendition. and that a fight broke out, then the fight story fits with that narrative. so they're not saying exactly --
they're saying very little. this statement was just over a paragraph. when you compare it with all the other things that have come out, it seems like the saudi narrative, which i think is going to emerge more thoroughly in the coming days, is that this was an attempted rendition. again, they haven't said that so far. they just say it was a fight, and during that operation, a fight broke out and the fight resulted in his death. now, the problem with that story is, as you were suggesting, is that the turks who have been saying for several weeks now that a 15-member saudi hit team flew in, including a forensics expert, a medical expert, who had a bone saw, who was prepared to dismember the body. and turkish police are searching -- well, they're starting to look at surveillance cameras, anyway, two areas where they think body parts may have been disposed of. so that does suggest more than a fight. but we are starting to hear a
and then, more jobs began to appear. these techs in a lab. this builder in a hardhat... ...the welders and electricians who do all of that. the diner staffed up 'cause they all needed lunch. teachers... doctors... jobs grew a bunch. what started with one job spread all around. because each job in energy creates many more in this town. energy lives here. now sofi has no fees on personal loans.
there is a chance that's the last time. 300 miles per hour, that's where i feel normal. i might be crazy but i'm not stupid. having an annuity tells me retirement is protected. annuities can provide protected income for life. learn more at retireyourrisk.org annuities can provide protected income for life. if you want to get take the most details about your family history. my pie chart showed that i'm from all over europe, but then it got super specific. i learned my people came from a small region in poland, and even a little bit of the history about why they might have migrated during that time. those migration patterns are more than just lines on a map, they're really your family's story. i can't wait to see what i'm going to discover next. connecting 20 million members to a deeper family story. order your kit at ancestry.com
consulate. the official statement states that he was killed in a quarrel. i'm joined by phone by steve clemons, washington editor at large for the atlantic, and "new york times" journalist nick kristof. steve, put this in context for our viewers, particularly as u.s. media has reported for some time what the saudis now acknowledge. >> well, the u.s. media has not acknowledged that jamal khashoggi was killed in a fistfight, that this was an interrogation gone bad. this is a contrived lie, ari, and i think it's very important in establishing context to understand that from both turkish intelligence and turkish press sources which have been reporting which the western press is kauchg, we pretty much have a fairly good understanding of what happened, that men laid in wait for jamal khashoggi when he entered the consulate. he was quickly murdered. he was dissected, and his body was done away with. and so it doesn't hold with the truth.
and i think that right now what you see is an elaborate cover-up that the king is trying to preserve the equities of his son, who is now crown prince, and tried to demonstrate that they're trying to place blame on others in this process. and i think we also need to face the fact that the united states has not been a help in getting to the truth. it's actually help assist in helping them come up with a contrived fabrication of what happened. >> and stay with me, steve. nick kristof, your view? >> well, so they effectively acknowledge having lied for 17 days, and now they're shifting to another narrative that is also a lie. and i just find it infuriating. dishonoring jamal in one more way. i mean, this notion that he was killed in a fistfight gone wrong when they brought a bone saw to this event, it's absurd.
and the crown prince himself it seems is going to head a commission that is going to investigate this. you know, that's like putting o.j. simpson in charge of an investigation he was involved in. this is just one more indication that they don't feel under sufficient pressure from the united states and international community and that they think they can get away with an effort to preserve the crown prince and shift the blame to various fall guys. and it's just an insult to jamal and to the world. >> and with that in mind, nick, what do you think is incumbent on the trump administration to do? we just heard from hallie jackson in front of the white house, the president on the road. they haven't at this moment had a reaction yet, but what's incumbent on them to do in response to what you and others have identified as a pretty blatantly false cover story?
>> well, since it's patently absurd, i think the u.s. and other nato countries -- since this happened in a nato country, there is some reason for nato countries to act together, to call for an investigation under the auspices of the u.n. the security council could call for it. the general assembly could call for it, or the u.n. human rights council could call for it. any of those would be feasible. and then nato should jointly expel saudi ambassadors and suspend weapon sales to saudi arabia. i think we could also quietly advise king salman and -- it's a little unclear how with it the king is, but certainly advise the royal family that as long as mbs is the crown prince, then saudi arabia is going to be completely isolated in the world, and that they need to find a new crown prince who is not a murderer. >> put very starkly, but it
makes a lot of sense. nick kristof, stay with me as part of our breaking coverage you called. in steve clemons is on the phone. steve, for you and our viewers, i want to play one of the more incriminating things we heard from the president. very clearly, this is before this news broke this hour, but well after what the president said was flatly contradicted by available media reports, to say nothing of private intelligence. here he was talking about whether perhaps it was not the saudis but rogue killers who carried out this execution. >> the king firmly denied any knowledge of it. he didn't really know. maybe -- i don't want to get into his mind, but it sounded to me like maybe these could have been rogue killers. who knows. we're going to try getting to the bottom of it very soon. but his was a flat denial. >>that flat denial has given way to a partial acknowledgment of the cover story tonight.
steve clemons, having heard that, that was the president on monday with the final minute that we have. your thoughts. >> doesn't he remind you of the 400 pound blogger that might be in the couch in his or her home hacking into hillary clinton's e-mails? it is part and parcel what president trump has brought to his job, which is basically, kowtowing and acquiescing to the autocrats in the world and believing them more than his own intelligence service, believing them more than his own allies, believing them more than logic would bear. i happen to know jamal khashoggi, but it's far beyond that. this is a green light to ought kra autocrats around the world, including erdogan. turkey is no cruise ship for journalists to kill those of white house are trying to create accountability in various political systems around the world. >> right. >> it's outrageous for president trump to engage as he has with
kavanaugh and others to deny, deny, deny. the president of the united states is the most powerful man in the world and he should call out liars and he did not in this case. >> my thanks to steve clemons and nick kristof. the items we didn't get into the show that were preempted we'll get to next week. the special live coverage of this unfolding scenario continues right now with "hardball with chris matthews." so where's the body? let's play "hardball." >> good evening. i'm chris matthews in washington. breaking news tonight in the case of "washington post" journalist jamal khashoggi. 17 days after his mysterious disappearance, saudi arabia has just conceded that khashoggi died while in that saudi consulate in istanbul earlier this month. the saudi press agency reports that the g