tv The Rachel Maddow Show MSNBC December 9, 2019 9:00pm-10:00pm PST
happy monday. you know, at least today we knew in advance that there was going to be way too much news to keep up with, right? so, we knew -- you know, as long ago as the end of last week that today is the day for which we should gird our loins. i don't even know what girding our loins means. its sounds terrible. bracing ourselves, if you will. but if you nevertheless did end up feeling overwhelmed by the amount of news today, it may make you feel a little better to note that it wasn't just you. it wasn't just you and me and everyone we know. we are not the only people having a hard time keeping up with a news day like today. the justice department also
today had to ask for a little extra time, please. just couldn't keep up. one of the things we were expecting today was for federal prosecutors to file notice with the judge who was overseeing the criminal case of this man, president trump's deputy campaign chairman rick gates. federal prosecutors were due to notify the judge in gates' case today as to what sentence they think rick gates should get. this has been an eagerly anticipated part of this case and indeed part of the overall trump scandals and their criminal case components because unlike paul manafort the president's campaign chairman who said he would cooperate with prosecutors and then didn't and lied to prosecutors and now he's in prison for seven plus years because of it, unlike manafort who said he would cooperate and didn't, manafort's deputy rick gates who worked with manafort in his ukraine work and working
from pro criminal and political parties who also came to work with trump on the campaign in 2016, rick gates has been cooperating. manafort said he would and he didn't. gates said he would cooperate and he certainly has, including testifying in multiple trials so far. gates has been a cooperating witness for prosecutors for almost two years now. so, we've been really anticipating this statement from prosecutors summing up the extent of his cooperation, the value of his cooperation, how they think a judge should weigh his cooperation against his felony convictions and the stuff he has con fessed so. it should be super interesting, right? this is the super cooperator in terms of the criminal cases. seeing what prosecutors have to say should tell us a bunch of stuff we probably don't know already. we've been waiting for this a long time.
that document was due by close of business today. surprise, in a last minute filing right before the close of business today, right up against the deadline, the u.s. attorney in washington, d.c. filed instead this short notice with the court ak nocknowledging thae judge had told the prosecutors and the defense that they both had to have their sentencing memos about rick gates in today. but the prosecutors say they are not ready. quote, the government the continuing to gather materials for the government's memorandum in aid of sentencing. with the court's leave, we also plan to file under seal a supplemental motion regarding mr. gate's assistance, a supplemental motion that continues sensitive information relating to ongoing criminal matters. oh, therefore the government, quote, respectfully requests a one-day extension of time to file its memorandum in aid of sentencing and moves this court to file under seal its
supplemental motion. mr. gates consents to the government's request. so, i mean, who knows why they need just one extra day to the extent that i had deadlines today, i'd put my deadlines off too. it was one of those days it was impossible to keep up with everything. it may be possible that there's something materially significant about exactly which day it is that they're asking for as an extension. maybe they really needed something they couldn't get until tomorrow morning. but they've asked for a one-day extension. and it is news itself that rick gates is still providing assistance to prosecutors even at this last date, something that relates to ongoing criminal matters and is sensitive and has to be filed under seal. that's new itself. i mean, we kind of thought that rick gates testifying against paul manafort, testifying on the stand in the roger stone trial, we kind of thought that was it. but apparently not. apparently there's more to get out of rick gates and it is sensitive enough that we, the public, won't be allowed to see
whatever it is that prosecutors are going to file. that was a little bit of a curveball tonight. and i should tell you just as we were getting on the air, just as i was heading down to the studio just a few minutes ago, we did get in the defense submission, gates' defense lawyers telling the judge in his case why they think he shouldn't get prison tomb. that alone is interesting. but we're still waiting for what the prosecutors have to say which should be fascinating. we'll have more on that coming up later on. i should also mention that we originally thought that we would be seeing trump national security adviser mike flynn finally getting sentenced around now as well. it was this time last year that mike flynn was initially in court expecting to get his sentence for the felony counts on which he's pled guilty. this time last year when he showed up for his sentencing, that's when things sort of fell apart for mike flynn in open court when the judge made clear there was a real possibility that flynn was going to get the book thrown at him by his sentencing judge. after confronting flynn with all
sorts of things he thought about him, the judge showed mercy and allowed flynn to delay that sentencing so he could go back to prosecutors and cooperate some more to try to alleviate what otherwise looked like it was going to be a really stiff sentence. that was a year ago that the judge sent him away and said you probably don't want to be sentenced by me right now. you probably want to try to help yourself a little more in term of what you can stack up against the sentence i'm thinking about giving you. a year ago on that basically advice from the judge, but over the course of this past year, that's really not how it went. mike flynn didn't go to prosecutors and help them lots more so prosecutors would say he's being even more helpful. we want you to be more lenient than he might have otherwise been. didn't go that way. prosecutors to the contrary are now expressing dissatisfaction with the degree to which flynn has continued to be helpful to them. flynn has switched to a
different legal team which is a fox news pundit legal team. that new legal team has made overthe top allegations about the evil justice department and evil fbi and innocent mike flynn being targeted by some deep state cabal and the fbi being the real criminals. just a couple weeks ago mike flynn's sentencing was delayed again because the new lawyers said there was this inspector general report coming out at the justice department which would shed important new light on the bogus case against mike flynn. the judge in flynn's case, the same one who sent hum away a year ago who said you might want to try to help yourself before you hear the sentence, that same judge agreed to, once again, delay flynn's sentencing this time until after the inspector general report came out so everybody could see what the inspector general concluded about the propriety of the case
against mike flynn and the investigation into flynn. well, now as of today, that inspector general report is out. if you were the judge in mike flynn's case, it's easy to imagine you might be annoyed at this point if you delayed the sentencing because of what you believed were good faith assertions by mike flynn's lawyers that this new report was going to change everything. it was going to make the case against mike flynn fall apart. it was going to expose the dastardly fbi for only having pursued flynn because of some flit cal vendetta against flynn or against donald trump. whatever else they thought this would give them, you might imagine that the judge today now having had the opportunity to see this report might be annoyed because the inspector general report that is out today does discuss the fbi opening up their investigation into mike flynn. and they conclude that it was no problem. i.g. took a hard look at it. seems pretty kosher is pretty much the conclusion. definitely nothing wrong with
the mike flynn investigation. this is what's in the inspector general report. quote, the initial cross fire hurricane, the russia investigation, was to determine which individuals associated with the trump campaign may have been in a position to received the alleged offer of assistance from russia. after conducting open source and database inquiries, intelligence analysts on the cross fire hurricane team identified three individuals, carter paige, paul manafort, and michael flynn associated with the trump campaign with either ties to russia or a history of travel to russia. on august 10th, 2016, the team opened separate counterintelligence requests under code names assigned by the fbi. six days later on august 16th, a counterintelligence case was opened on flynn under another code name assigned by the fbi. each case was designated as a sensitive investigative matter
because the individual subjects were believed to be prominent in a domestic political campaign. inspector general then explains the predicate information that was cited as the reason for opening fbi investigations into each of those people including flynn. quote, the opening electronic communication, the opening statement for the flynn investigation stated that there was an articulate factual basis that flynn may have wittingly or unwittingly been involved in activity on behalf of the russian federation which may constitute a federal crime or threat to the national security. the document cross referenced to the cross fire hurricane and flynn was an adviser to the trump campaign who had entities to russia and travelled to russia in december 2015. so, that's what the fbi did when it opened its investigation into flynn. was there anything wrong with
them opening that investigation into flynn? the inspector general says no, not at all. from page 352, quote, we concluded that the fbi had sufficient predication to open full counterintelligence investigations of papadopoulos, paige, flynn, and manafort in august 2016. as with the opening of cross fire hurricane itself, we concluded that the quantum of information articulated by the fbi to open these individual investigations was sufficient. particularly in the context of the fbi's separate and ongoing efforts to address russian interference in the 2016 u.s. elections. so, the fbi was looking at russia interfering in the 2016 elections. they were looking specifically at whether anyone on the trump campaign might have been in a position to accept that offer of assistance from russia or otherwise coordinate with russia wittingly or unwittingly while they were carrying out this operation to interfere in our election. the fbi looked at people in the trump campaign who might have been in a position to do that
sort of thing and flynn is one of the people they investigated. that's the investigation that ultimately resulted in him pleading guilty to a felony. that's what he's waiting to be sentenced on. to the extend that mike flynn's sentencing was delayed again because the lawyers were sure and told the inspector general report was something the judge wanted to see before effort to sentence mike flynn, since the fbi set him up, let's wait to see that report that shows that he was -- the inspector general report concludes mike flynn was not set up and the fbi did nothing wrong when they opened the investigation. there's no indication in the inspector general's report that the fbi did anything wrong over the course of the case which resulted in him pleading guilty to a felony. so, president trump's national security adviser mike flynn is presumably running out of rabbits in terms of what his lawyers have available to continue to try to pull out of a
hat, to try to keep the judge in his case from pronouncing his sentence. we know he wants a presidential pardon. it would appear he's at the end of his rope in term of what he can continue to use to delay his federal court sentencing. we're waiting to hear any time from the judge in the case. the inspector general report is out. it offers flynn no help for this somewhat crazy defense he and his fox news lawyer have been mounting in court. when it comes to rick gates, we expect to hear from prosecutors about the rick gates sentencing tomorrow. some of that will be filed under seal. it's not known if the ongoing criminal matter that rick gates is still helping with pertains maybe to mike flynn. after all, the mike flynn case is still open. flynn still hasn't been sentenced. it could pertain to anybody else from trump land, right? but the criminal cases adjacent to this president and his campaign and the various trump presidential scandals, all these criminal cases, so many of them are still live and underway.
and don't forget all of these federal case are under the auspices of the department of justice run by barr and that's a weird and concerning dynamic because the prosecutors who have brought all of these cases against manafort and against gates and against flynn and papadopoulos and stone and all the russian military intelligence officers and constantine kilimnik and the guy who ran the russian troll farm for the kremlin, all of these federal cases that have been brought by prosecutors that are along side or abutting trump and his presidential scandals, all the prosecutors who brought all of those cases are working under the auspices of bill barr. and bill barr appears now day by day to increasingly be at war with the justice department that he is leading, including
specifically on this inspector general's report which doesn't just clear the fbi and the justice department in term os of their handling of the mike flynn investigation. it concludes this whole fantasy that the whole russia investigation was a deep state plot designed to sabotage donald trump's political chances, the inspector general chased down the fuzzy threads of their hair ball conspiracy theory and found it to all be nonsense. look at the conclusions of the report. there's a long executive summary. look at that. look at the conclusions. conclusion page 410, quote, the decision to open the investigation was by bill prista. we concluded, meaning the inspector general's office, concluded that prees tap's exercise of discretion in opening the investigation was in
compliance with department and fbi policies. we did not find evidence that political bias influenced his motivation wechlt found that cross fire hurricane was opened for an authorized investigative purpose and with sufficient factual predication. as to the use of informants and confidential sources and these, you know, allegations from the president and from attorney general william barr that the trump campaign was somehow spied on and that was the real scandal here, well, the inspector general ran all that down. quote, we did not find any documentary or testimonial evidence about political bias or improper motivation influenced the fbi's motivation to conduct these operations. we found no evidence of placing human sources within the trump campaign or recruit members of the trump campaign as human sources or task human sources to the report on the trump campaign. so, the inspector general concluded that the individual investigations they opened up into people associated with the
trump campaign, those were simple. the russia investigation and the specific investigation into trump campaign was into what russia was doing, that was fundamentally sound. the report did criticize the way the fbi filled out the court application for the one fisa warrant they obtained over the course of the investigation. it was a fisa warrant into trump campaign adviser carter paige who we knew before that his involvement with the trump campaign was someone whose name surfaced in other investigations in the united states. but the inspector general's report broadly debunks the conspiracy theories on the right that everybody in these investigations had fisa warrants against them. it turns out it was just one guy. carter page. they do take issue with the way the carter page warrant was applied for and the way the updates to those applications went, but that's it. the inspector general debunks
that there was any sort of antitrump political bias that was motivating or driving any of these decisions. they debunked the idea that the christopher steel dossier against trump was the basis for opening the fbi investigation. it absolutely was not. and oh, by the way, no, there was no spying on the trump campaign. >> so you're not suggesting though that spying occurred. >> i don't -- well, i think spying did occur. yes, i think spying did occur. >> spying did not occur according to the justice department. justice department's inspector general report came out today concluding definitively that the trump campaign was not spied on. which you would -- i mean, given the seriousness of the allegation that the trump campaign was spied on, given the fact that the attorney general
made that allegation while giving sworn testimony in congress that he threw that out there, now that his own justice department has concluded no, they weren't spied on. under normal circumstances, that would be the occasion for the attorney general to resign, right? from having thrown out an allegation that serious, that grave with no reason for doing so and then being disproven. under normal circumstances, a senior government official being call out that badly on something that serious, you might expect a resignation. rather, what we actually got to was attorney general william barr releasing a statement taking issue with the findings of the inspector general's report saying he doesn't believe it, trying to spin the findings of the inspector general's report to make them seem much more in line with the criticism he and the trump white house have been promoting for months. it's like when the mueller
report was completed but we couldn't see it yet and william barr put out the report saying i've read it and it's awesome for donald trump. that was oddly effective in terms of the public understanding, public misunderstanding of the mueller report when barr did that the first time. it appears that he is trying to do that again with this inspector general report. this inspector general report debunks all the conspiracy theories about the russia investigation. barr has put out a statement saying well, as far as he can tell, none of that's right. i mean, the problem this time is that number one, we've all got the report and we can read it ourselves wechlt don ourselves. we don't have to rely on bill barr summarizing before we're allowed to see it. number two, we've seen him pull this trick before, right? so, we can now more easily recognize that, yeah, this is what bill barr does as trump's attorney general. him putting out a statement today disenting from the findings of the inspector general of his own department,
we know that's about bill barr and how devoted he will remain to whatever fake exculpatory theory he and the president are promoting about the behavior of the president and those in his campaign. it tells you something about william barr as attorney general. we now know better than to expect his statements about things like this tell you anything about what's in the report. so, we can all read the inspector general report ourselves. in terms of the criticism of the way the fisa application for the carter page fisa warrant went, the fbi has already said they not only accept, they embrace those findings of the report and they embrace the recommendations of the inspeck sor genertor gen how to improve those policies and procedures. apparently there will be a follow on report about reforming the way the fbi and the justice department seek wiretapping applications from the fisa court.
okay. but the whole witch hunt idea, the deep state cabal, the russia investigation being a coupe against president trump, all those talking points today took a hard blow from the deep examination of all those crazy claims. and that report arrives in the middle of what may be the climactic impeachment hearing today before the judiciary committee. the committee spent the first several hours of this impeachment hearing today having one long opening statement after the other from the committee chair from the ranking member from the committee counsel then from the other committee counsel then from the witness who was also a committee counsel and then from the other witness who was also a committee counsel. i mean, for many hours today at the start of this hearing it was just individual guy lawyers talking out loud. when they finally started mixing it up and cross examining the witnesses and having actual back and forth between the
questioners and interrogating the record and the impeachment scandal, that moment in the hearing is when they released the inspector general report. so, everybody had to go pay attention to something else for a while right when the hearing was finally getting super interesting. but we've got to pay attention to everything at once now. this is just what it's like at this point in our nation's history and in this news cycle. in the end this impeachment hearing today will go down in the record of the scandal as the sort of definitive summation of what the president is accused of having done, what he's being impeached for. and some of the questioning these members of the judiciary committee did a very good job drilling down not just the nature of the president's alleged crime here but the direct culpability for it and the ongoing danger of what the president did which is ultimately why the house of representatives says they're moving fast now to get this resolved before the next election is monkey wrenched too. >> just two days ago president
trump stated publicly that he hopes his personal attorney rudy giuliani will report to the department of justice and to congress the results of mr. giuliani's efforts in ukraine last week to pursue these false allegations meant to tarnish vice president biden. president trump's persistent and continuing effort to coerce a foreign country to help him cheat to win an election is a clear and present danger to our free and fair elections and to our national security. >> mr. goldman, who sent rudy giuliani to ukraine to smear joe biden? >> president trump. >> who fired the anticorruption ambassador in ukraine marie yovanovitch? >> president trump. >> who told ambassador sondland and ambassador volker to work with rudy giuliani on ukraine? >> president trump. >> who told vice president pence to not go to president zelenski's inauguration? >> president trump.
>> who ordered his own chief of staff mick mulvaney to withhold critical assistance from ukraine. >> president trump. >> who refused to meet with president zelenski in the oval office? >> president trump. >> who ignored on july 25 his own national security counsel's anticorruption talking points? president trump. >> who asked president zelenski for a favor? >> president trump. >> who asked president zelenski to investigate his political rival, joe biden. >> president trump. >> who stood on the white house lawn and confirmed he wanted ukraine to investigate joe biden? >> president trump. >> who stood on the same lawn and said china should also investigate biden? >> president trump. >> as to anything we do not know in this investigation, who has blocked us from knowing it? >> president trump and the white house. >> so, there's a lot of moving parts here right now, a lot of
stuff happening at once. i should tell you this is important breaking news. the head of the foreign affairs committee and the house congressman eliot engel tonight said we should expect a press conference early tomorrow morning in which the chairs of the various committees investigating the impeachment scandal are going to announce their next steps on articles of impeachment. we had been expecting that that announcement might include their plans for what they're going to put in the articles of impeachment against president trump. that's what -- i was comfortable saying we are expecting that when we got on the air. since i have been on the air just in the past few minutes, a senior democratic aide has confirmed to nbc news that the house will introduce articles of impeachment tomorrow morning. "the washington post" has just in the past few minutes reported that their expectations, the democrats are going to -- excuse me -- the house of representatives is going to draft two articles of impeachment against trump, one on abuse of power and the other
on obstruction of congress. so, again, that's breaking news. that's from eliot engel is the chairman of foreign affairs, one of the committees that's been investigating this thing saying that at the press conference they have called that the chairs have called for tomorrow morning, we may be getting the articles of impeachment against the president as early as then. so, it's just a remarkable bookend on this time in our history, right? the night before we're apparently going to get the impeachment articles against donald trump for him inviting a foreign country to interfere on his behalf in the 2020 election, the eve of those impeachment articles being unveiled we also get the validation that the russia investigation was sound and when the fbi looked at russia interfering in our election and started investigating whether anybody on the trump campaign was wittingly or unwittingly coordinating with russia in that foreign interference in our last
election, that decision by the fbi to launch that investigation was sound. it was not a witch hunt. it was not the product of political bias. these bookends, right? i mean, for this to be happening the day before we're going to get the impeachment articles for him trying to get interference in 2020, the spin coming out of washington on both of these developments, the inspector general's report and the expectation of these impeachment articles, the spin coming out of washington on these things is like a blender on puree with the lid off. it's absolute chaotic whirlwind of messy, messy spin, and it will stay like that fair while. but there are fairly simple facts at the heart of this that we are going through right now as a country. we're going to be talking with a member of the just didiciary committee tonight and someone who has a role in the russia investigation. big night for us tonight. stay with us. vestigation. big night for us tonight
stay with us if you live with diabetes, why fingerstick when you can scan? with the freestyle libre 14 day system just scan the sensor with your reader, iphone or android and manage your diabetes. with the freestyle libre 14 day system, a continuous glucose monitor, you can check your glucose levels any time, without fingersticks. ask your doctor to write a prescription for the freestyle libre 14 day system. you can do it without fingersticks. learn more at freestylelibre.us
t-mobile is lighting up 5g nationwide. while some 5g signals go only blocks, t-mobile 5g goes miles... beyond the big cities to the small towns... to the people. now, millions of americans can have access to 5g on t-mobile. and this is just the beginning. t-mobile, the first and only nationwide 5g network. what are you doing back there, junior? since we're obviously lost, i'm rescheduling my xfinity customer service appointment. ah, relax. i got this. which gps are you using anyway? a little something called instinct. been using it for years. yeah, that's what i'm afraid of.
he knows exactly where we're going. my whole body is a compass. oh boy... the my account app makes today's xfinity customer service simple, easy, awesome. not my thing. this is from section 2 subsection a, department of justice national security division. the department was first notified about the opening of cross fire hurricane on august 2, 2016 when fbi official bill pre stap and the intel section
chief briefed several, according to law ofman and his contemporaneous notes of the briefing, fbi officials described the foreign government that caused the bureau to open its initial investigation and the four individuals the fbi with had identified through its initial investigative work who were members of the campaign and had ties to russia. laufman told us his impression was that the information raised alarm bells. he also said that the information the fbi provided presented the question of whether someone in the russian government was work being the campaign of a major party candidate to influence the u.s. elections. laufman told us that, quote, we certainly nad the significance of the matter and the need for further investigation. and he said that it would have
been a deirelection of duty not to find out what was going on. counterintelligence and export control section, served first under president obama and for a year under president trump. his work at the justice department led to the high profile convictions you've seen lately for unregistered foreign lobbying, overseeing the hillary clinton email investigation, and the trump russia probe. he was there from the beginning and joins us now. david laufman. sir, it's great to have you here. that is one of the sections of the inspector general report that discusses you and your involvement at the outset of the russia investigation. let me just ask you whether you take any issue with the way that you appear in this report and how you feel about it overall. >> i'm fine with their mention of me. i think this is a prodigious piece of work that reflects
really credibly on the inspector general and his team. there are a number of serious flaws and irregularities in the fisa process which you talked about before. those shouldn't be poo pooed or swept under the rug. the fbi is going to embrace those and commit themselves to reforms that the department of justice will support. but on the grievances of congressional republicans that asked for this investigation, that this was a witch hunt, this was an effort to foment a cue, there could not be a more utter and complete repudiation of those conspiracy theories. and the meticulousness with which the investigation was conducted is laid out in hundreds of pages for the american people to see. >> this is a dense report. it's 470-something pages and also single space, small type, and at times it's got so much
detail it doesn't read like a beautiful narrative. but we do actually get quite a compelling narrative about the initial -- the initial days of the investigation. and fbi being confronted with information that they believe was adequate predicate to start looking at something they knew was very sensitive. when you told the inspector general's office that the initial information you heard about why the fbi opened the investigation, this information from the australian government that somebody in the trump campaign appeared to have advanced knowledge of what russia had done, according to the report, you said that resonated with you. what did you mean with that? >> what gets lost at times, we have been living for weeks and months for the fbi cybercampaign for the election. we already knew there was an intense state sponsored effort by the russian government to subvert our election.
now comes the report from the australian government official that someone has said they may come into possession of information derogatory to the rival candidate. and it was like a bookend, to use your phrase to, what we were already living with. and it came from a credible source. we would have been irresponsible not to take appropriate action to commit resources to undertake that investigation. and i think everything you see in that report bears that out. >> are you troubled by the fact that there isn't, as far as we know, there isn't a parallel justice department or fbi investigation into the president's actions to openly solicit ukraine and even china to provide derogatory information about his political rivals for 2020? >> i do think it's curious. the department of justice normally interjects these investigations, they're not known as a bunch of wall flowers when it comes to investigative
creative theory. and here along the side we have this attorney general foments reinvestigations of investigations that were already begun and perhaps closed at the behest of political supporters of the president. but in this current situation involving campaign finance, we're just not even going to start an investigation. that's really kind of hard to add up. >> i want to ask you to stay with us for just a second because i want to ask you about that. we've got statements from the attorney general and also an unusual statement from a u.s. attorney who's been tasked by the attorney general to look into this. can you stick with us. our guest the david laufman. stay with us. stay with us (children playing) (dog barking) ♪ (music building)
experience the power of sanctuary at the lincoln wish list sales event. sign and drive off in a new lincoln with zero down, zero due at signing, and a complimentary first month's payment. ♪everybody needs somebody to love...♪ ♪ find everything you need to get together this holiday, with low prices and free shipping on millions of items at amazon. stop dancing around the pain with low prices and free shipping that keeps you up again, and again. advil pm silences pain, and you sleep the whole night. advil pm
skip to the good part with alka-seltzer plus. now with 25% more concentrated power. nothing works faster for powerful cold relief. oh, what a relief it is! so fast! and my lack of impulse control,, is about to become your problem. ahh no, come on. i saw you eating poop earlier. hey! my focus is on the road, and that's saving me cash with drivewise. who's the dummy now? whoof! whoof!
as we are informed this evening that the congress will be moving forward as early as tomorrow morning with unveiling articles of impeachment against president trump, remarkably because all of these things have to happen all at once and because there are poets among the news gods, remarkably tonight we have also got an inspector general report from the department of justice reflecting on the origins of the russia investigation finding there was not political bias or improper considerations that led the justice department and fbi to open up investigations and the question of whether the trump campaign was in on it. joining us is david laufman.
he was there at the outset of the russia investigation. david, i wanted to ask you about the response to this report today. we just discussed the fact that attorney general william barr put out a statement essentially contesting the findings of his own department of the inspector general. but there was also a second statement from john durham the u.s. attorney from connecticut who has been additionally tasked by attorney general william barr with looking into other elements, criminal investigation into the russia investigation. >> if you think barr's statement was unusual, durham's statement was even more bizarre. you have a sitting prosecutor making a public statement seeming to denigrate the scope and adequacy of the findings of the ig investigation while pointing out that he appears to be in possession of some secret information from some other government agency that the ig had no access to as if to
preserve the possibility that neez findings that you've been talking about today will be undermined later by new revelations. >> it is -- i mean it's worth stressing this is an active u.s. attorney who is involved in an active criminal investigation that is pending and from which we've seen public-facing indictments. even if all he said were positive things that had nothing to do with the sort of controversial ground that he's tread upon, it's weird to talk about the investigation while it's ongoing. >> it's very uncommon to speak about charging documents, opening statements, closing arguments, examination of witnesses thachlt don't just issue press conferences in the mid ofl their investigation to comment upon someone else's investigation and to talk about how much better their investigation is than the other investigation. i've never heard of such a thing happening. >> is mr. durham break a rule at the at the department of justice
doing this? >> i'm not sure there's a specific rule that governs that. that may be because no one has ever done this before. they didn't think they needed a rule. suffice it to say it's highly unusual. i think it reflects poorly on mr. durham to lend his name and credibility into this political arena because this has the patina of political support for barr's own statement, for the statements of other people on behalf of the president have been making. and that reflects incredibly upon mr. durham. >> david laufman, head of the doj under president obama and president trump. good to have you here. stay with us. president trump. good to have you here. stay with us let's be honest, quitting smoking is freaking hard. like quitting every monday hard. quitting feels so big. so, try making it smaller. and you'll be surprised at how easily starting small...
...can lead to something big. start stopping with nicorette ♪ do you recall, not long ago ♪ we would walk on the sidewalk ♪ ♪ all around the wind blows ♪ we would only hold on to let go ♪ ♪ blow a kiss into the sun ♪ we need someone to lean on ♪ blow a kiss into the sun ♪ we needed somebody to lean on ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ all we need is someone to lean on ♪ billions of problems. sore gums? bleeding gums? painful flossing? there's a therabreath for you. therabreath healthy gums oral rinse fights gingivitis and plaque and prevents gum disease for 24 hours. so you can... breathe easy, there's therabreath at walmart. wheyou want relief... fast. only thermacare ultra pain relieving cream has 4 active ingredients to fight pain 4 different ways.
get powerful relief today, with thermacare. a lot of folks ask me why their dishwasher doesn't get everything clean. i tell them, it may be your detergent... that's why more dishwasher brands recommend cascade platinum. it's specially-designed with the soaking, scrubbing and rinsing built right in. cascade platinum's unique actionpacs dissolve quickly... ...to remove stuck-on food. . . for sparkling-clean dishes, the first time. choose the detergent that lets your dishwasher do the dishes! cascade platinum. the number one recommended brand in north america. oh no,... ...a cougher. welcome to flu season, karen. is a regular flu shot strong enough... ...to help prevent flu in someone your age? there are standard-dose flu shots. and then there's the superior flu protection... ...of fluzone high-dose. it's the only 65 plus flu shot... ...with 4 times the standard dose. and it's free with medicare part b. fluzone high-dose is not for those
who've had a severe allergic reaction... ...to any vaccine component, including... ...eggs, egg products,... or after a previous dose of flu vaccine. tell your healthcare professional if you've ever experienced severe muscle weakness... ...after receiving a flu shot. if you notice ...other problems or symptoms following vaccination,... ...contact your healthcare professional immediately. side effects include pain, swelling... ...and redness where the shot was given. other side effects may occur. vaccination may not protect everyone. if you're 65 plus, don't settle for a standard-dose flu shot. influenza...going down. move up to fluzone high-dose. see your doctor or pharmacist and ask for it by name. take a wild guess, how many times has president trump met with vladimir putin or talked to him. >> i don't know the number. >> it's 16. >> okay. >> how many times has president trump met at the white house with president zelenski. it's zero. and who is president trump
meeting with at the white house tomorrow? do you know? >> i'm not -- >> it's russian foreign minister lavrov. >> what makes me angry is that this president, president trump, thinks he can get away with it. but he got caught. and he tried to cover it up. but we won't let him do that. >> scenes from today's apparently potentially climactic public impeachment hearing at the judiciary committee. joining us is congresswoman valval deming. >> good to be with you rachel. >> multial pl news outlets are reporting that the house is going to introduce articles of impeachment first thing tomorrow, basically unveiling articles of impeachment against the president at a press conference with key democratic chairman. i'm guessing that you cannot get
out in front of that news. but i'm hoping you can share about what you might know about what seems like a fast-moving series of events co. >> the speaker made an announcement last week that we were proceeding with writing the articles of impeachment. of course we take this process very, very seriously. we were at work all day saturday and all day sunday after t, aof hearing today, and we'll be back first thing in the morning. in terms of what the articles will look like, that is not my announcement to make. but i do expect an announcement will be made tomorrow in conjunction with the committee chairs who have jurisdiction over those committees. >> in terms of putting together the case against president trump here, obviously all those closed door depositions with the 17 witnesses that remarkable series of public hearings in front of the intelligence committee and now these two long public
hearings in front of the judiciary committee talking about not just the factual record but the constitutional basis for impeachment, do you yourself in term of thinking about making up your own mind about how you are going to vote and also what you want to be in those articles, do you feel like you know what you need to know or do you feel like there are holes in the record that may materially affect your base level decision here? >> well, you know, it's been amazing how much evidence that we have been able to accumulate in about 75 days. but the bottom line is this: the best witness, the most effective witness, the most compelling witness in this impeachment inquiry has been the president of the united states. we don't have to guess or try to figure out or surmise on what the president said on the call record from july 25th, the president was clear when he spoke to president zelenski that he wanted him to get involved in
a political investigation. in other words, the president put his own personal political interests above that of the nations' and also really jeopardized our national security. so, while it appears to have been a short period of time, the evidence that we have in this case is pretty overwhelming. the testimony has been very compelling, and i do believe that we have everything we need right now to proceed. >> congresswoman val demings, really appreciate you being here today. i know y'all are working very hard. tomorrow is going to be a big day as well. thank you for making time for us. >> thank you. >> again, we're following this breaking news tonight. i can tell you a little bit of advance in the story. nbc news has now confirmed what "the washington post" was reporting earlier this hour which is that the house is expected to draft two articles of impeachment against president trump. those may be unveiled as soon as tomorrow morning. stay with us. rrow morning stay with us ho!
you... you got me. uh, what do you want? i've got uh, ai robots, i've got vr goggles. i want your sled, please. no. [ chuckles ] timmy. it'd be a shame if this went viral. for those who never compromise. the mercedes-benz winter event. whoa. he was pretty good this year. my hands are everything to me. but i was diagnosed with dupuytren's contracture. and it got to the point where things i took for granted got tougher to do. thought surgery was my only option. turns out i was wrong. so when a hand specialist told me about nonsurgical treatments, it was a total game changer. like you, my hands have a lot more to do. learn more at factsonhand.com today. like you, my hands have a lot more to do. [upbeat music] no matter how much you clean, does your house still smell stuffy?
that's because your home is filled with soft surfaces that trap odors and release them back into the room. so, try febreze fabric refresher febreze finds odors trapped in fabrics (bubbles popping) and cleans them away as it dries. use febreze every time you tidy up to keep your whole house smelling fresh air clean. fabric refresher even works for clothes you want to wear another day. make febreze part of your clean routine for whole home freshness. ♪la la la la la. steven could only imaginem 24hr to trenjoying a spicy taco.burn, now, his world explodes with flavor. nexium 24hr stops acid before it starts for all-day all-night protection. can you imagine 24-hours without heartburn? billions of problems. dry mouth? parched mouth? cotton mouth? there's a therabreath for you. therabreath oral rinse and lozenges. help relieve dry mouth using natural enzymes to soothe and moisturize. so you can... breathe easy, there's therabreath at walmart.
i mentioned at the top of the show that we just got ahold of a new court filing for the defense attorneys for this man, rick gates. he's awaiting sentencing in federal court after pleading guilty on federal charges. we just had time to review the submission. rick gates' lawyers are asking for no prison time for mr. gates. quote, we respectfully ask your honor to impose minimum supervision.
the lawyers say the client's extensive cooperation is the reason he should get no jail time. specifically, he spent over 500 hours working with the special counsel's office and other federal prosecutors and note that he testified in the trials of craig, stone, and manafort and he is committed to testify in still other trials if requested. prosecutors told the court they want to file a sealed statement tomorrow about rick gates' cooperation in ongoing criminal proceedings. that is described as too sensitive to be shown to the public. despite all his cooperation, looks like there may be more to get out of rick gates. we will know more within 24 hours. stay with us. more within 24 hours. stay with us (man and woman) [burst of talking to animals] ♪ (vo) it feels good to give back. (attendant) thank you so much.
are eight weeks from tonight. also nbc news is reporting that impeachment articles are expected to be unveiled against president trump tomorrow morning. also tomorrow night, mayor pete buttigieg is going to be joining me here live at 9:00 p.m. here in studio. how do i make all of these things coexist in my kalin da r in a way that keeps me sane? i don't know. that does it for us tonight. we'll see you tomorrow. now it's time for the last word with lawrence o'donnell. >> good evening, rachel. we're going to get to the news. we'll ask about articles of impeachment that will be announced tomorrow morning. we'll get to the inspector general's report. for you rachel, for you in particular we need to report news of isabelle bueso. you helped make this news happen. isabelle's family has issued a statement saying that we are elated to share that on december 6th, our family received official documentation that our deferred action status has been