Skip to main content

tv   All In With Chris Hayes  MSNBC  December 30, 2020 5:00pm-6:00pm PST

5:00 pm
this isn't somebody who has to go and try to seek higher office and therefore apiece a lot of people. this is the time to get it done. america americans absolutely can't wait. and he has the power and privilege to make that happen. >> yes, absolutely indeed. he is having to do fdr, woodrow wilson, all of it with the pandemic. brittany cunningham and michael beschloss who is the room of the year winner, thank you both. >> thank you. >> thank you so much. happy new year, friends. that's tonight's "the reidout." "all in with chris hayes" starts right now. tonight on "all in," a republican senate officially cosigns the anti-democratic fantasies of a defeated president. tonight what senator josh hawley's endorsement of a coup means for january 6 and beyond. then -- >> here is what the leader of the republican party says.
5:01 pm
he says $2,000 asap. >> mitch mcconnell's latest blockade for americans desperate for covid relief. senator bernie sanders joins me live. plus, how did policing and all the stark warnings about the nashville bomber. new questions about the vaccine delay roll-out for the trump administration. and from the massive federal failure on covid and beyond, how america keeps paying for the republican party's enduring anti-government fetish. >> the nine most terrifying words in the english language are "i'm from the government and i'm here to help." >> "all in" starts right now. good evening from washington, d.c. i'm mehdi hassan in for chris hayes. throw weeks from now donald trump will no longer be president, and a lot of people will be breathing a huge sigh of relief. but one of the big worries for many of us is what happens when the next trump comes along, someone who appeals to the base
5:02 pm
and is just as amoral and cynical as trump, but who is smarter and savvier. well, today we got something like an official candidate announcement for that role. it came from missouri republican senator josh hawley, who casts himself as a reformist and a populist, a young senator willing to break with the old ideas and the old elites in charge of both parties. hawley partnered with bernie sanders in calling for $2,000 covid relief checks after trump took that stance, and some of his positions, including his very justified attacks on the power of big tech are shared by many on the left. but hawley is also a calculating politician who many believe is positioning himself for a presidential run in the post trump era. and he has decided that the best way to do that is to show that he is willing to overturn a democratic election. and american democracy itself in order to keep republicans in power. hawley announcing today that he will object to the certification
5:03 pm
of some states' electoral college results on january 6th when congress is scheduled to ratify joe biden's very legitimate victory. it's a move opposed by mitch mcconnell because it means that every republican senator will have to go on record and vote to either side with trump and take a stand against american democracy, or instead defy the trump base by acknowledging the legitimacy of the election result. that's because if a single senator, as well as a member of the house objects to the electoral college totals, lawmakers will have to vote on whether they bring to the objection. now there is virtually no chance for such an objection to succeed since democrats control the house and will not vote to overturn biden's victory. but a number of republican house members have said they will object any way, and now josh hawley has as well. and to be honest, hawley has done us a favor, because while many republican senators still haven't publicly accepted the election results, none have gone this far. hawley has now outed himself as
5:04 pm
the lead plotter in the senate in donald trump's attempted coup. it's a scarlet letter that should follow him forever. he's gone on record against democracy, and he is forcing the rest of the gop to good on record too. it's important to understand how unprecedented this is. as we noted earlier this week, not a single democratic senator objected when al gore was declared the loser of the 2000 election, even though there was a much more credible case for the election having been stolen then. and when house democrats objected, citing the incomplete vote count in florida, it was gore himself who was presiding over the proceedings in congress who shut down the challenge. >> mr. vice president, there are gross violations of the voting rights act from florida. >> the gentlewoman -- >> and i checked and it is not signed by a senator. >> the chair thanks the gentlewoman from california on the basis previously stated. the point of order may not be received. >> we should also note that
5:05 pm
after the 2004 election, there was one democratic senator who did object, senator barbara boxer of california, but it was a very different situation. john kerry had conceded and boxer made clear she wasn't trying to overturn the election, but rather to spotlight problems in ohio, such as voters being forced to stand at some precincts for 10 or even 12 hours. what josh hawley is doing is very different. donald trump continues to insist that the election was stolen from him. last night he was rage tweeting deranged attacked on republican officials in georgia who won't steal the election for him, including a claim that the secretary of state's brother, quote, works for china. it turns out the georgia secretary of state does have a brother, but he has nothing to do with chinese tech companies or voting machines. he's just an ordinary guy. then today seemingly in response to hawley's announcement, trump tweeted january 6th, see you in d.c. on what basis is josh hawley contesting the election on the
5:06 pm
6th of january? georgia just finished yet another audit of its results that confirmed once again that biden won and that there was no fraud. trump's crack team has not been able to find evidence of fraud anywhere else. and their legal challenges have been laughed out of the courts again and again. at one point, they lost cases in six states in a single day. and look, it's one thing for some of the most infamous republican back benchers in the house, the usual suspects to play along with trump's coup attempt. nobody expects much else from these people. but josh hawley is supposed to be a smart guy, the future of the gop. i happen to think he knows what he's doing in trying to undermine a legitimate election. he just doesn't care because he thinks it will help him win over the trump base. hawley is a self-styled populist who loves to rail against the elites, despite being a member of the elite himself. the senator attended stanford university and yale law after
5:07 pm
graduating from prep school. and is there anything less populist than telling more than 81 million americans that their votes shouldn't count? so that he, senator joshua david hawley can scheme his way into the oval office come 2024. for some perspective on all this, i'm joined now by yale university history professor timothy snyder, author of "on tyranny: 20 lessons from the 20th century." you've been sounding the alarm about rising authoritarianism, fascism for many, many years now. what do you make of this latest development, a sitting republican senator aiding and abetting donald trump's ridiculous attempt to overturn the election? >> the thing that strikes me most and maybe the thing which is the most shameful and dangerous is the endorsement of the big lie. senator hawley knows that the claims he's making are not true. he knows that he is in effect endorsing a conspiracy theory.
5:08 pm
he knows that what he's doing is endorsing a story in which mr. trump is the victim. mr. trump has been stabbed in the back. and from the point of view of american history and american voters, the sad, the tragic thing about this is that the real victims in the history of american voting are the people whose votes are not counted -- african americans historically. and the way mr. trump's story runs is it's those black people, those people in the cities who stole the election. so what mr. hawley is doing, and that is what is shameful about it for him, i think as a young man, as a white man, it's shameful to stand up there and endorse the claim that black people voting is fraud. but in addition to the moral shame of it, there is the political consequences. when you make claims like this, you're basically saying the other side has cheated, and so we're going have to cheat the next time around. >> yeah. very true. and some people -- we talk about
5:09 pm
cheating. let's just get our language straight here. some people say we shouldn't call this a coup or a coup attempt. it's hyperbole, they say. but what i don't get is what should we call an attempt by the sitting president and his party in the legislature trying to overturn the result of a free and fair election that was called almost two months ago? >> i think there is no problem at all calling this a coup or a self-coup or an attempted coup. the only thing which is a little bit different about this historically speaking is how much of it mr. trump broadcast in advance. he spent six or seven months before november telling us how he would try to throw the election after november, and he did basically all the things he said he was going to do. i mean, for people who think the military has to be involved, it's not for lack of trying. in early june, mr. trump tried to bring the military into the streets of washington. he has been talking to general michael flynn, who of course as we all know advocates a military coup to carry out military-run election. he's tried basically everything,
5:10 pm
but i'd also emphasize that the way goes down isn't always in some kind of flash of lightning or gunpowder. it's often a technicality, like the thing being organized for january 6th where you take some rule that's meant to be a little thing and you push it as far as it can possibly go and break the system that way. so taking the opportunity to render an objection and using that as a way to question the whole system, that's the breaking of norms. highways the stretching of rules which undermines democracy. >> indeed it does. it doesn't matter whether it succeeds or not. people say it's going to fail, who cares. attempted robbery is still a crime and something we should call out. what do you make of senator josh hawley specifically? because i've always worried that the real long-term threat of authoritarianism, of fascism even is not from trump, but from someone who comes after trump, who combines trump's rhetoric and policies and the doors that trump has opened with a more
5:11 pm
acceptable face and less personal baggage. >> yeah, you're making a great historical point. very often the authoritarians we remember in the past had someone who went before them and paved the way. and that someone then gets forgotten when the next person comes along. look, mr. hawley is someone who ran for attorney general 2016 complaining about ladder-climbing politicians. ten months later he announced his run for the senate. 18 months later he becomes a senator. at this point he is basically auditioning for president. we have the realize what he is doing is not just a challenge to the system. it's also a form of self-dealing. because the situation in 2024 is very possible, namely the republicans control the congress. mr. hawley is the republican candidate, and he loses the presidential election, but we get to do operation crybaby a second time around. so what mr. hawley is doing now is making that scenario more thinkable and more plausible. he is setting up a plan b by which he himself can become
5:12 pm
president after losing a presidential election. that's one more thing which is wrong with this. >> i think you're right about that. timothy snyder, we'll have to leave it there. thank you so much for being with us tonight. thank you for your insights into operation crybaby indeed. one of the reasons donald trump is so obsessed with not leaving office is because on january 20th, he faces a number of potential legal issues. but will no longer have the shield of presidential immunity. and now "the washington post" is reporting that manhattan district attorney cy vance has hired forensic accounting experts as part of the d.a.'s criminal probe into trump and his business operations. for the latest on that probe and the various investigations into trump and his possible legal exposure, i'm joined now by nu law school professor who served as lead prosecutor in are special prosecutor robert mueller's office as well as chief of the fraud department. what do you make about the news
5:13 pm
of cyrus vance hiring fts consulting. how big a deal is it? should trump be worried? >> we don't know yet whether in terms of the manhattan district attorney's office will make its case, but if there is something there, if there is a there there, then yes, you would be worried if you were donald trump, his family, and his companies. and the reason is one, the president cannot pardon himself out of state criminal liability. and the new york state criminal investigation is something that will go on, regardless of what the president does with his pardon power. but more than that, the forensic accountants that are reported to have been hired are true experts. a forensic accountant essentially is a fancy word for an expert who can follow the money. and fti is an outfit that is
5:14 pm
really reputable. in fact, i know them pretty well because not only do they have former fbi agents and analysts there, they have one of the lead forensic accountants that works for the special counsel investigation is actually at fti. and they are really good at detecting fraud and following at tracing money, and particularly good at attribution. what i mean by that is if somebody sets up sort of offshore accounts, uses fake or sham names, they're really good at tracing money flows so that they can attribute that money to a particular person. and the reason that's important is if you're not paying taxes on it and you can show that that's income, then you can make a criminal case. and that's exactly, for instance, what we did in the paul manafort case, which was we traced all of his bonds across
5:15 pm
the globe with the help of spectacular forensic accountant. so i suspect that's exactly what manhattan is going to try to do here. >> so it's interesting you mention paul manafort, who of course was just pardoned by the president after being convicted for all those crimes. and i wonder, how much do you think a desire to avoid being prosecuted himself, a desire to keep his own immunity is driving this ridiculous effort to overturn the election result and stay in office beyond the 20th of january? >> well, you know, again, no one knows for sure, but if there is criminal liability, it's a very powerful motive for the president to want to stay as president, because he then enjoys a federal de facto immunity because the department of justice will not prosecute a sitting president. and it also confers some
5:16 pm
advantages even in state law in terms of being able to delay things, in terms of the investigation. so if there is criminal liability there, that is a powerful motive to want to stay in office, although as you reported in the last segment, it's a fool's errand at this point because, you know, on january 20th, the president will actually no longer be the president, and he is going to have to contend with this state investigation, which by all accounts is doing exactly what a good follow the money investigation should be doing. >> one last quick question before we run out of time. a lot of people are putting a lot of faith in these state lawsuits and trump facing, you know, court, some form of court battle after he leaves office. will a former u.s. president ever really see the inside of a u.s. prison cell? i doubt it. >> you know, this is one which is very interesting, and it's
5:17 pm
useful to think of this from a global perspective, because we hold ourselves out as a nation where the rule of law is the crown jewel of our democracy. and yet we haven't seen a former president or president being held to account criminally. hopefully, that's because there hasn't been the kind of criminality that would lead to that result. but if you compare that to other countries that are so-called western democracies, you know, there are countries that do apply the rule of law to leaders. it's going on right now in france. it is going on in israel. and there is no reason if you really think about it if you believe as the supreme court has held that the president of the united states, the presidency is not above the law, then there is reason to support that kind of resolution. >> i hope you're right. that's all i can say.
5:18 pm
andrew weissmann, thank you so much for your time and your insights tonight. next, there is bipartisan support for increasing the covid relief checks to $2,000. so why is mitch mcconnell refusing to budge? i'll talk to senator bernie sanders on his fight to make it happen, after this short break. i felt gross. people were afraid i was contagious. i was covered from head to toe. i was afraid to show my skin. after i started cosentyx i wasn't covered anymore. four years clear. five years now. i just look and feel better. see me. real people with psoriasis look and feel better with cosentyx. don't use if you're allergic to cosentyx. before starting, get checked for tuberculosis. an increased risk of infections and lowered ability to fight them may occur. tell your doctor about an infection or symptoms, if your inflammatory bowel disease symptoms develop or worsen, or if you've had a vaccine, or plan to. serious allergic reactions may occur. five years is just crazy. see me.
5:19 pm
learn more at and ask your doctor about biktarvy. biktarvy is a complete, one-pill, once-a-day treatment used for h-i-v in certain adults. it's not a cure, but with one small pill, biktarvy fights h-i-v to help you get to and stay undetectable. that's when the amount of virus is so low it cannot be measured by a lab test. research shows people who take h-i-v treatment every day and get to and stay undetectable
5:20 pm
can no longer transmit h-i-v through sex. serious side effects can occur, including kidney problems and kidney failure. rare, life-threatening side effects include a buildup of lactic acid and liver problems. do not take biktarvy if you take dofetilide or rifampin. tell your doctor about all the medicines and supplements you take, if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, or if you have kidney or liver problems, including hepatitis. if you have hepatitis b, do not stop taking biktarvy without talking to your doctor. common side effects were diarrhea, nausea, and headache. if you're living with hiv, keep loving who you are. and ask your doctor if biktarvy is right for you. he used to worry about how to fix the world's oral health problems. - i think i've got it. - [narrator] then he invented therabreath formulas. - you want fresh breath? i'll give you a fresh breath.
5:21 pm
- [narrator] for fresh breath, healthy gums, dry mouth, and healthy smiles. - whoa, that's fresh. - [narrator] now, the world's mouths have never been healthier. (sighs contentedly) - works for 24 hours, i guarantee it. therabreath, it's a better mouthwash. - [narrator] available at walmart, target and other fine stores. -to all the businesses make it through 2020... thank you for going the extra mile... and for the extra pump of caramel. thank you for the good food... and the good karma. thank you for all the deliveries... especially this one. you've reminded us that no matter what, we can always find a way to bounce forward. so thank you, to our customers and to businesses everywhere, from all of us at comcast business. we have a very unlikely ally
5:22 pm
in president trump. nobody here has disagreed with trump more times than i have, and yet here is what the leader of the republican party says. he says $2,000 asap. so even on this issue, amazingly enough, the president of the united states is right. >> that was senator bernie sanders today arguing for $2,000 stimulus checks for all americans in this terrible pandemic, and noting the push from donald trump for that same thing. but while the leader of the republican party wants those checks to go out asap, mitch mcconnell does not. that's why the senate majority leader made sure when he introduced a bill for those payments to load the bill down with completely unrelated provisions, one to repeal certain legal liability protections for internet platform, and one provision to investigate supposed mythical voter fraud, both described by democrats as poison pills to
5:23 pm
kill the effort to expand financial relief. senator bernie sanders, independent of vermont, has been leading the charge for increased stimulus checks for weeks, and plans to continue raising the motion for that house bill in the senate. he joins me now from the senate. senator, thanks for coming on the show. mitch mcconnell is upset with you. susan collins is upset with you. the republicans want to go home and celebrate new years. but am i right in saying you want the keep them this down as long as it takes and force a vote on this, because many americans are unable to put food on the for new year's. >> you got it. nobody wants to stay here any longer than we should, but it's unconscionable fleeing to our families while all over this country we have families struggling to put food on the table. you're looking at millions of people who are worried about being evicted from their homes. you have people in the midst of this terrible pandemic cannot afford to go to the doctor.
5:24 pm
they're accumulating massive debt. no. we have got to stay here and do the right thing, and that is pass legislation that was passed already in the house and that's providing $2,000 for every working class person in this country. >> so you mentioned providing it to every working class person. "the washington post" editorial board is saying today going from $600 to $200 checks is a waste of money. it could be better spent elsewhere, they say. "the post" also reported a couple of weeks ago that you and senator manchin of west virginia had a direct change over direct checks versus unemployment. what do you think of the argument that the money shouldn't go to most americans because not all of them need it. it should be targeted at the unemployed instead. what do you say to that? >> well, we have put into the legislation that just passed an extension for 11 weeks of unemployment benefits with the $300 supplement. i would go higher than that.
5:25 pm
i fought and wanted to see a $600 supplement on top of normal unemployment. >> yes. >> so it's not either or, mehdi. it is a question of understanding that right now we are looking at a working class in this country that is in more desperation than at any time since the great depression. you have half the people trying to survive living paycheck to paycheck. the pandemic is getting worse. people don't know how they're going get to a doctor. people are worried about being evicted. there is enormous desperation out there and you can't turn your become on that. now i find it interesting, and my friends at "the washington post" or the republican leadership, if it comes to tax breaks for rich people or corporate welfare or bloated military budgets, that's okay. but when you stand up and say that working class families need sohelp, oh my god, the world is going to collapse. so i am a little bit tired of that hypocrisy. i'm tired of companies like
5:26 pm
amazon making billions and billions of dollars and not paying a nickel in federal taxes. no one talks about that. but you're helping a mom trying to feed her kids, oh my god, we can't afford it. this is hypocrisy. >> yes. indeed. indeed. and those tax cuts cost four times as much as these checks, but they never mention that. >> correct. >> what has been good to see, senator, is the democratic leadership get behind you on this fight. in fact, vice president-elect kamala harris was one of the sponsors on your bill earlier this year to get monthly checks to americans until the crisis is over. you think the biden/harris administration and the democratic leadership in congress will now get behind more of the policies you're pushing on spending, on relief, on stimulus in 2021, or will they get pressured to focus on the deficit, on austerity as previous democratic administrations have? >> well, i think you mentioned a moment ago a disagreement that senator manchin and i had.
5:27 pm
that's true. and it really has a lot to do with how we conceive of the democratic party. and i believe that the democratic party has got to see itself not as the party of the upper middle class. that's fine, but as the party of the working class. the fact that donald trump has won tens of millions of working class votes, despite being a pathological liar and a fraud speaks to the failure of the democratic party and standing up for those very families. so i will do everything i can to oppose moving into austerity economics. people are hurting. we've got to stand with those people. we have massive income wealth and inequality in america. we've got to address that as well. >> one last question, senator. you mentioned donald trump. you've worked with republican senator josh hawley on trying to get 2k checks into the relief
5:28 pm
bill. today he's announced that he'll be objecting to the election result next week in congress. how is this not anything other than an open and very dangerous attack on american democracy by senator hawley and other republicans in the house? >> you're right. i can't argue with you. you're absolutely right. what trump is doing and those people who support his approach are trying to delegitimize elections in this country, and that is undermining american democracy. it is inconceivable to me that you still have republicans who are refusing to acknowledge that joe biden is the president-elect. kamala harris is our vice president-elect. and they're literally trying to undo the democratic process. and that makes me very nervous, not for what's going to happen next week. we will deal with that. but it makes me very nervous that there are millions and millions of people prepared to support candidates who truly do not believe in democracy. and that is an issue we've got confront.
5:29 pm
>> indeed. i think it makes all of us nervous. senator bernie sanders, thank you so much for your time. we appreciate it. >> thank you. ahead, is there any hope for speeding up the process of getting the vaccine to people? i'll talk to a member of biden's covid advisory panel about what could be done, right after this. are you one of the millions of americans who experience occasional bloating, gas, or abdominal discomfort? taking align every day can help. align contains a quality probiotic developed by gastroenterologists.
5:30 pm
it adds more good bacteria to your gut, to naturally help soothe your occasional bloating, gas, and abdominal discomfort 24/7. support your digestive health with align, the #1 doctor recommended probiotic. try align today, the pros in digestive health. also try align dualbiotic gummies to help support digestive health. welcour new virtual classes were designed for you andving? millions of seniors like you. you can now choose from thousands of live virtual classes every week. get moving wherever you have an internet connection. and when you're ready, enjoy access to thousands of locations nationwide. with silversneakers, you're free to move. enroll today at no additional cost by visiting the website on your screen.
5:31 pm
5:32 pm
5:33 pm
here in the final days of 2020, we are once again seeing long lines in the streets of america. not for voting this time or for testing, but now for the covid vaccine itself. this is what it looked like in lee county, florida overnight as desperate people camped out in line in the cold to get vaccinated. a line that itself has the potential to spread the virus. according to bloomberg, so far states have only used a fraction of the vaccine doses they've received from just over 50% in north dakota, down to barely 11% in maryland. a "washington post" editorial
5:34 pm
about the slow pace of vaccination in the united states includes this startling observation. quote, at the current rate, it would take the united states approximately ten years to reach that herd immunity level of inoculation. that's right. ten years. but so much of the problem isn't about the states themselves. it's about how the federal government has been almost completely absent in creating a vaccine distribution plan. governor gretchen whitmer made that point on this very show, that the states need help from the federal government in crafting a massive national plan to keep americans safe. but the federal government is just saying no. it's up to the states. they're on their own. which might not be that surprising, because it's like the testing debacle all over again when the trump administration claimed there were plenty of tests and blamed states for the shortfall. but states didn't have enough test and said they were abandoned by the federal government. dr. julie marita is a former commissioner of the chicago public health department, and
5:35 pm
she is also a member of the biden transition covid-19 advisory board. thank you so much for coming on the show. the current vaccination distribution rates are so slow that we are being told that it will take ten years to get enough americans vaccinated for herd immunity. ten years. how does a biden administration turn that around, up the pace? >> hi, mehdi. thanks for having me tonight. as you pointed out, these are really challenging and heartbreaking times with record numbers of hospitalizations and deaths occurring. and the president-elect recognizes that in order for us to change the course of this pandemic, we really need to increase the vaccine rate. and he is on record to move heaven and earth to make that happen. what he has outlined is using the defense production act if necessary to increase supplies and materials the manufacturers need, working closely with governors and mayors to make sure they have the resources they need to actually support vaccination effort. it's great that the stimulus
5:36 pm
bill provided funding over the weekend, but those resources were lacking up until recently, and it's going to take a little time for the states and locals to take advantage. the president is also having a massive public awareness campaign to increase vaccine acceptance. the president-elect is really committed to doing everything possible to change this course and increase vaccine administration. >> so dr. morita, when states say they aren't getting enough doses out because the federal government isn't supporting them, and the federal government says nope, it's up to the states to do this, we've done our bit, wla where does the truth lie on this? is it one side or the other or in the middle? >> having been a former health commissioner chicago, i understand the challenges we face during these public health emergencies. so it's the same team who are responsible for contact tracing, for testing, to responding to outbreaks and long-term care facilities, supporting health
5:37 pm
care facilities and their surges. they're being asked to do the vaccine administration and coordination of that program. and up until recently, they haven't had the resources they needed. again, the federal stimulus approval this weekend will be helpful. but there will likely be more resources needed to insure these programs can ramp up and get the vaccines administered as quickly as possible. with the resources, i'm confident they can. >> you were involved in the immigration responses to the swine flu and the ebola outbreaks as well during the obama years. what lessons can be learned from them? >> i think there were some critical lessons we learned during ebola, during h1n1, during zika, that a strong federal coordinated response is essential. so the federal agencies were working closely together and also working really closely with states and local so we felt supported and we had the resources we needed. it was also essential to have clear and consistent communication based on science and facts. those kinds of things really helped us to be responsive and
5:38 pm
to do what was appropriate when we needed to do it. the other thing that was really critical is we really leaned into it and engagement with our community organization, understanding what the community's questions were, hearing from them, understanding what concerns they had and who they needed to hear from to really have faith and confidence in the vaccines that were being administered. that those same kinds of things need to happen and to ensure we can respond and turn the tide with this pandemic. >> well, let's hope they do. dr. julie morita, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with us. we appreciate it. >> thank you. tonight, why was the warning local authorities got about the nashville bomber effectively ignored? that story next.
5:39 pm
5:40 pm
5:41 pm
5:42 pm
grandpa, can you tell me the story again? every family has their own unique story. give your family the chance to discover theirs this holiday season, with ancestry. the only thing a disaster can't destroy is hope. donate now at we continue to learn more about the christmas day bombing in nashville, tennessee. a police report obtained by the tennesseean newspaper reveals that the alleged girlfriend of
5:43 pm
the bomber anthony warner told police more than a year ago that he was making bombs in his rv. that's the same vehicle that exploded outside an at&t facility last week, injuring three people and causing destruction across several blocks in downtown nashville, as well as communication outages across the area. after she made the report in august 2019, officers visited his home. but he did not answer the door. they saw the rv parked behind the house, but it was behind a fence. an alarm with wires attached at the front door. officers then sent their report to the fbi to check their databases, and no results turned up. in a statement, nashville police said, quote, at no time was there any evidence of a crime detected and no additional action was taken. no additional information came to the department or the fbi's attention after august 2019. now i have to say, as a brown-skinned muslim following this story, i have so many
5:44 pm
things to say. for a start, black and brown people and muslims in particular don't get visited by the police when we're suspected of making secret bombs. we get our homes raided. we get detained. we get interrogated. we get demonized and smeared in the press. and when a muslim is believed to have blown himself up and hurt people in the process, it's a suicide bombing, a suicide attack. it's not a mysterious motor home blast, as reuters rather quaintly described the nashville attack. brown bombers are almost always terrorists until proven otherwise. a white bomber is a loner, a recluse, mentally ill. now to be clear, we don't know yet what anthony quinn warner's motivations were. reporting he may have believed in conspiracy theories about lizard people and 5g networks. what we do know as a white man, a white christian, anthony quinn warner gets the benefit of the doubt, has a certain privilege, shall we say, that people who look like me and with names like
5:45 pm
mine never get. we're back after a short break. biktarvy is a complete, one-pill, once-a-day treatment used for h-i-v in certain adults. it's not a cure, but with one small pill, biktarvy fights h-i-v to help you get to and stay undetectable. that's when the amount of virus is so low it cannot be measured by a lab test. research shows people who take h-i-v treatment every day and get to and stay undetectable can no longer transmit h-i-v through sex. serious side effects can occur, including kidney problems and kidney failure. rare, life-threatening side effects include a buildup of lactic acid and liver problems. do not take biktarvy if you take dofetilide or rifampin. tell your doctor about all the medicines and supplements you take, if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, or if you have kidney or liver problems, including hepatitis. if you have hepatitis b, do not stop taking biktarvy without talking to your doctor. common side effects were diarrhea, nausea, and headache. if you're living with hiv, keep loving who you are. and ask your doctor if biktarvy is right for you.
5:46 pm
so dad bought puffs plus lotion, blows.oving who you are. and rescued his nose. with up to 50% more lotion puffs bring soothing softness and relief. a nose in need deserves puffs indeed.
5:47 pm
5:48 pm
5:49 pm
i think you all know that i've always felt the nine most terrifying words in the english language are "i'm from the government and i'm here to help." >> that line from ronald reagan in 1986 has become the operating governing principle for modern day republicans. they want us to believe that government does not and should not help people. and they never miss a chance to repeat that mantra. >> president reagan once told us that the nine most terrifying words in the english language are "i'm from the government and i'm here to help you." >> remember that old ronald reagan line. >> i believe that ronald reagan had it right. >> i agree with ronald reagan. >> the most feared words in the english language. >> the most terrifying words in the english language. >> the scariest words in the english language. >> the most frightening words in the english language are "i'm from the government and i'm here to help." >> i'm from the government.
5:50 pm
>> and i'm here to help. >> i'm from the government. >> and i'm here to help. >> i'm from the government. >> and i'm here to help you. >> i'm from the government. >> and i'm here to help. >> i'm from the government and i'm here to help you is one of the most frightening lines in america. it's no longer a joke. no longe. >> 2020 was perhaps the year we needed help from the government the most, and yet government was nowhere to be found as a public health crisis exploded in this country, president trump and his administration went from pretending the coronavirus didn't exist to not being honest with the american people about what they knew, to completely dropping the ball on testing, to not advocating for policies that keep americans safe, to missing the mark on distributing the vaccine and endlessly delaying a second covid relief package. their abject failure, their dereliction of duty has led to hundreds of thousands of deaths and unprecedented economic turmoil. not only are they not upset about it or regretful, they have the audacity to be complaining
5:51 pm
about socialism. former trump ambassador to the united nations nikki haley tweeting the other day, quote, 2020 was the year socialism went mainstream. this terrifying trend threatens the future of every american. as we discussed on the show earlier, at the current rate it could take ten years to vaccinate every american. so i'm pretty sure too much government action is not our problem right now. it's far too little. i'm joined now by linda chavez, who served in ronald reagan's white house, and michelle goldberg, op-ed columnist for "the new york times." linda, let me start with you. thank you both for joining me, but linda, let me go with you first. that mantra that government is a problem, that someone is saying they're from the government and they're here to help is the biggest fear an american could have. certainly you can't still believe that in a year of mass unemployment and frankly mass death. >> first of all, the federal government's primary responsibility is to provide for the common defense against a foreign enemy or, in this case, against an enemy that comes in
5:52 pm
the form of a virus. so i actually believe that the federal government is the only government that can successfully be able to distribute this virus, and frankly the current administration, i guess, it's just as well that they didn't try to do it because this has been the most incompetent administration in the history of america, at least during my lifetime. so i don't, you know, think that if ronald reagan were alive today, that he would be saying that the government should not get involved in defending america against a virus that frankly crosses borders. the idea of federalism has no place when you're talking about something that moves with people across porous borders. >> that's a fair point. michelle, though, does it democramake you laugh or cry when you see nikki haley and other republicans obsessing over socialism when food bank lines
5:53 pm
are growing and even a republican president is calling for direct cash payments. >> well, i would say that the only kind of -- kind of one of the only very, very thin silver linings of this extraordinarily terrible era is that it really has put the nail in the coffin of reaganism, right? when josh hawley, when very conservative republicans are calling for $2,000 survival payments along with the entire democratic party, i think that this, you know, sort of right-wing austerity has been killed off for good even if there are still people like nikki haley and ted cruz and some others who are trying to keep its corpse alive. and everyone in the country now has experienced what it's like to live in a nation where the federal government simply doesn't work, and it is dystopian. >> yes. and, linda, michelle mentioned the nail in the coffin of reaganism, and i just want to expand on that.
5:54 pm
wasn't it the war on so-called big government that reagan started and even bill kwlclinto joined in that left the u.s. unprepared to deal with a health crisis like this, rickety infrastructure, lack of universal health care, no real safety net. >> i have to say i still consider myself a conservative. i'm not sure how much longer i can stay a republican. we'll see on january 6th. i may not be able to maintain my republican registration after the republicans do what they're planning on doing with the electoral college vote. but i do think that there is a big difference between believing that there are some jobs that governments should do and some that it shouldn't. and i don't think it's really the nail in the coffin of reaganism. as i say, i think if ronald reagan were alive, i think he would have reacted very differently than donald trump did. donald trump's not a conservative. the idea that he somehow has reagan's ideology is nonsense. the man has no ideology.
5:55 pm
he's a narcissist, and he has led like a narcissist, and frankly he's now in the process of trying to destroy the republican party. >> but it's not just trump, i guess, linda. it's some of those republican enablers as we just played the tape of some of those people in congress. >> oh, absolutely. >> who still echo ronald reagan when they're calling for, you know, no spending on unemployment benefits or direct checks in the middle of a pandemic. michelle, let me ask you this. how tough a job does joe biden have? joe biden a pretty centrist politician, supporter of austerity in the past. how tough a job does he have convincing americans to have faith in government again, especially after the last four years of incompetence as linda put it? >> well, it's going to be extraordinarily hard, especially if democrats don't win these two senate seats in georgia because a senate controlled by mitch mcconnell is going to be devoted to one thing, and that is destroying a joe biden
5:56 pm
presidency. the way you destroy a joe biden presidency is you hobble the economy, you hobble any ability to get aid to the states, right? we've already seen this movie once before with barack obama. there's no -- and i think that, you know, mitch mcconnell is savvy enough to know that if the country looks like it's failing, the senate is not going to be blamed even if they are the roadblock. the other thing that joe biden is going to be contending with is he has to put together a vaccine strategy, a strategy to get people inoculated, you know, basically from a standing start. if you look at what's happening in israel, for example -- and i know israel is a very different country than america, but they're on track to basically be done by march, you know. and if you look at the extraordinarily slow pace that even the vaccines that are already out there, how slow it is getting them into people's arms because nobody thought to
5:57 pm
train extra -- you know, extra workers. nobody thought to put together this entire infrastructure. they knew the vaccines were coming down the pike, but they didn't think to kind of create an infrastructure to actually deliver them to people. it's an astonishment even though it's the sort of failure that we've seen over and over again. and so joe biden starting on january 20th has to start creating an infrastructure that should have been in process for months and months now. >> yeah, and there hasn't been that process. you mentioned kind of the cynicism of some senate republicans. linda, would you concede at least -- we said a moment ago it's not just about trump. even before trump, mitch mcconnell was doing the same during an obama presidency. you can't have a stimulus as big as you want because there's a democrat in the white house. trump comes along, he gets a huge stimulus in the middle of a pandemic. now you have ron johnson talking about we have to worry about
5:58 pm
debt. would you accept there is some of that politics going on? this isn't about big government, small government, ideology, theology. >> absolutely. you know, it's very hard, as i say, you know, i don't understand what the republican party stands for anymore. i really don't because they've embraced populism, which has been -- you know, there's bernie sanders populism and there's donald trump populism. i don't like populism of any sort. they've abandoned many conservative principles, and as i say, one of the biggest failings has been competence, which one thing living in washington and being part of government for many administrations, one thing you could always count on the republicans for was bringing in competent people into the government. that's no longer true. this administration has not had the best people, and i'm hoping that the biden administration, at least they have people who have some familiarity with government, who served in positions before. and, look, there may be a role for the military to play. this is a logistical nightmare,
5:59 pm
and you have to have the bodies out there to distribute and get the vaccines, not just -- fedex and ups have done a great job flying the vaccine bottles in, but you've got to get them into people's arms and that's going to require mobilization of the kind we haven't seen in decades in the united states. >> i think you're right, but that would require some kind of political imagination amongst some of the people in congress, especially republicans. one thing i would say, linda, just to be fair. you said that donald trump's populism is bernie sanders' pop yew liz many. that is "all in" for this evening. be sure to check out my show streaming week nights on peacock, including tonight's special report, an entire episode dedicated to the victims of covid-19.
6:00 pm
50 stories of 50 lives lost. now check out my good friend ali velshi who is hosting "the rachel maddow show" tonight. >> have yourself a great new year, meddy, good to see you. >> you too. happy new year. >> thank you, sir. thanks to you at home for joining us this hour. rachel's got the night off and we've got a lot to get to, including the news that republicans have decided to put one last speed bump in the road to joe biden's inauguration as the next president. this one coming from republican presidential candidate in waiting, senator josh hawley of missouri. we are going to be speaking with senator cory booker about this new gambit in just a few moments. but we want to start tonight with an important story that starts with just a guy on a bus. in march of 1947, a 47-year-old businessman took this bus route from mexico city to new york. he was actually on his way to maine, but he was feeling sick,