legal journalist stuart taylor was highly critical of the way it was handled calling it peculiar. even the obama justice department weighed in. it filed a brief and the supreme court argued that judge sotomayor's panel was wrong to simply dismiss the case. so, madam president, it's an admirable quality to be a zellist for your client, but judges are supposed to be passionate advocates for they have a fair application of the law, not their own preferences. in reviewing the richie case, i'm concerned that judge sotomayor may have lost sight of that. as we consider this nomination, i'll continue to examine her record to see if personal or political views have influenced her judgment. i yield the floor. >> madam president. >> the senator from alabama. >> madam president, i thank senator mcconnell for his thoughtful comments. he's a former member of the judiciary committee, a lawyer who studied these issues and cares about them deeply. i value your comments. i do think that as you know, senator mcconnell, while you're here that once a nominee achieves the supreme court they do have a l