and india ministry of defense and that really. documents only in relation to disappearances ought to be located and that witnesses of those disappearances should come forward so there's going to be let's say a process of a truce and reconciliation in relation to disappearances starting up fairly soon and i saw that would be the next step from the french government a really historic step in this regard because it is the first time that such documents are going to be declassified. i understand when you say that former french colonies should move forward and leave behind the past but you know what we're talking about families of thousands of people for in algeria for example who were kidnapped or arrested by the military back during the colonial rule of france the of never been able to see them again and people are saying would like to see justice done words should be followed with did. i believe that these kind of problems need. we didn't hear of through walk and that think what i see for my butt is the french foreign so much that h

to the defense ministry and the military, a lot of legacy platforms and the need to support those. i think what we want to do is have conversation with india that's not about the past and their legacy but about the future look at the nature of his regime. look at crimea, ukraine. i called it the laundry list when i was in that the chemical attack in the uk. look at russia's own future, their demographics. this is i think not a country that you would want to have a strategic partnership well into the future. we can be a more reliable, better partner so that is sort of at the macro level. to deal with issues like caatsa a potential sanctions, i think we need to be very careful here. secretary mattis did, in fact, go to capitol hill and often use used india as sort of the flagship example as to why we wanted a waiver for the secretary of state. so i think that created a certain impression that we're going to completely protect the india relationship can insulate india from any fallout from this legislation no matter what they do. i would say that's a bit misleading. we would still hav