our next question is from joe ferguson for mr. garcia. >> mr. garcia, the nuclear plant is clean energy, would you agree it should be counted as a clean form of energy? >> i've heard both sides that it should or should not be included as clean energy. the key here is renewable energy that we're focusing on so we can have an energy source that continues to renew itself, continues to contribute. my focus is going to be on solar. it's low-hanging fruit in arizona. and it's low-hanging fruit in arizona because we have so many solar resources. let's start there. let's work on solar energy. i am in favor of proposition 127 because we need to do more in energy. one of the things you get with doug dusey is a lack of imagination. telling us over and over again what we can't do, instead of foe us -- focusing on what we can. we can do more solar energy. we need to do more on solar energy. yet the governor, mr. dusey, continues to talk about what we cannot do. my focus will be on what we can. >> mr. dusey, response? >> i believe nuclear energy is clean ener

the first question is from joe ferguson. garcia, why should the state attract out-of-state companies instead of nurturing companies that originated here? what is the level of investment to be focused on that? >> on attracting outside companies? not sure of the question. >> can you clarify? >> how should the state balance attracting out-of-state companies with nurturing companies that started here. what level of investment should we focus on that? >> the key issue for economic development in and -- in arizona is education. talks about people coming from outside arizona but i'm but a focused on the 17 people inside arizona -- the 7 million people inside arizona. we have to balance out attracting companies from outside arizona as well as developing talent inside arizona and it's about investing in human capital. it begins with k12 but extends to colleges, high-tech manufacturing jobs, and investing in our universities as places for research and technology and it -- innovation. it's an investment in education canhe people of ari

rivera: next question is from joe ferguson for mr. garcia. , would you agree that the nuclear plant should be counted as clean energy? mr. garcia: in this discussion i have heard both sides that it should and it should not be counted as clean energy. we need an energy source -- my focus will be on solar. it's low hanging fruit in arizona. it is low hanging fruit because we have so much solar resources. let's start there. proposition 127. look, one of the things you get with doug ducey is a lakh of imagination and saying over and over again what we can't do. energy,o more in solar and yet the governor continues to talk about what we can't do. ms. rivera: mr. ducey, your response? gov. ducey: when mr. garcia asks you to imagine cannot you should imagine dollar tax increase. not only feature family in the state of verizon, imagine what -- in the do to our state of arizona, imagine what that would do to our schools. we want to allow renewables to come here. this in a way that is not mandated at the ballot box. >> this next question is fro

and joe ferguson of the arizona daily star. before we begin, here are the rules for the night's discussion. each candidate will get 92nd opening statement. our journalists will ask questions. the questions will be direct to one candidate who will have one minute to respond. the other candidate will have 30 seconds to rebut. both candidates will have 45 seconds to respond. will alternate who gets each question and strictly enforced the time limits. mr. garcia. >> thank you. excited to be in tucson tonight. i'm david garcia. i am running to be governor of my home state. my story is arizona. the fourth generation arizona. the first and last to go to college, army veteran, a teacher and a father of two amazing girls. i am writing to build the state that billed me. at the end of four years, the administration is leaving behind a slew. past broken promises. our state is not secure. we are unable to patrol our highways 247. leaving behind the rest of us. he has been ineffective because he is a follower and not a leader. he is not look

here's joe lynskey. please give the warmest old trafford welcome to sir alex ferguson. cheering and applause. this is the sound when 70,000 people bring a loved one back home. sir alex ferguson's influence is in old trafford's foundations. these stands are united when he takes up his seat. he says the pre— match nerves are still the same but when his old side went in front, this felt like the old days, the problem is today's man united less lethal doorway and wolves are a side building their own brand, half the team and the manager are portugal's new stars, they make life ha rd to are portugal's new stars, they make life hard to their compatriots. are portugal's new stars, they make life hard to their compatriotslj life hard to their compatriots.” think the result is fair, i think they deserved the point. and i think we deserve the punishment of getting only one point. being the away team at anfield feels like punishment right now. especially if liverpool get a head start. that own goal had southampton up against it and this year the side in bread have found an extr