between siberia and moscow german doctors who treated him later said he'd ingested the nerve agent novacek the kremlin has denied any involvement accusing the west of monkey russophobia i guess this week for most go is richest love nikonov a member of president putin's party united russia and the lawmaker in the lower house of parliament the duma why is it that those who speak loudest for the russian opposition run the risk of mortal danger. you choose to have any kind of welcome to conflict zone. let's talk a bit here we may 1st of all about the opposition figurehead alexy vile need who fell ill in organized on an internal russian flight germany which ended up treating him said it was beyond doubt he was poisoned with one of the novacek class of nerve agents developed in the soviet union the kremlin denies any role in this if it wasn't them who do you think it was. well many questions about that actually i don't think much about now wildly anyway. do you remember angela davis she was one of the leaders of the american communist party back in the old soviet days and she was the most import

the unsubstantiated claims come hard in the hills of a british newspaper report says there was a 2nd novacek attempt on the valleys life before he was airlifted from russia to germany the times cited unnamed intelligence sources as saying the would be assassins try to finish off the top kremlin critic while he was an eye color but failed. german security sources have told their associates in the u.k. that the attackers struck again as the valley lay in an induced coma before being put on a medical flight to germany this was with a view to him being dead by the time he arrived in berlin one source said the sunday times is a sunday rug for dressing gown reading there is fake news then there are reports that can probably be described by 6 into english words there is such a word as well that report is i won't say anymore alexina valmy fell through a very ill during a domestic flight on the 20th of august the pilots made an emergency landing in 5 beriah where the politician was put into an induced coma 2 days later he was flown to berlin where a military lab concluded that he had been poisoned wi

into the program welcome back a british newspaper claimed that alexina violently was poisoned with novacek not once but twice before being earl it did from siberia to germany the time cited all named intelligence sources as saying the would be assassin tried to finish the russian opposition figure off while he was in a coma but fit. german security sources have told their associates in the u.k. that the attack has struck again as in the valley lay in an induced coma before being put on a medical flight to germany this was with a view to him being dead by the time he arrived in berlin one source said some background alexina volley passed on during a domestic flight on the 20th of august the pilot made an emergency landing in where the politician was put into and use coma 2 days later he was flown to berlin where a military law concluded that he had been poisoned with a nerve agent from the novacek group western governments were quick to point the finger of blame at the kremlin which has denied any involvement moscow's also were previously asked for access to the large results but to no avai

flight germany which ended up treating him said it was beyond doubt he was poisoned with one of the novacek class of nerve agents developed in the soviet union the kremlin denies any role in this if it wasn't them who do you think it was. well many questions about that actually i don't think much about now wildly anyway. do you remember angela davis she was one of the leaders of the american communist party back in the old soviet days and she was the most important american in the soviet union since she was the head of the commerce party of course no one in the united states knew anything about angela davis or not much so in the valley is and angela davis. first place we have the russian electorate he's he sorry we go for we have our hours of explorations and counter accusations about what happened to him mr putin apparently or as for the accusations i have actually i have a few questions to the german side. question number one what do you mean by the recheck what i know from those guys who worked on this guess it is a binary gas yes it is composed of 2 components to liquids each of which i

flight germany which ended up treating him said it was beyond doubt he was poisoned with one of the novacek class of nerve agents developed in the soviet union the kremlin denies any role in this if it wasn't them who do you think it was. well many questions about that actually i don't think much about now well in any way. do you remember angela davis she was one of the leaders of the american communist party back in the old soviet days and she was the most important american in the soviet union since she was the head of the commerce party of course no one in the united states knew anything about angela davis or not much so in the valley is an angela davis 1st place we have a russian electorate he's he's sorry we go for we have our eyes of explorations and counter accusations about what happened to him mr putin apparently or as for the accusations i have actually have a few questions to the german side. question number one what do you mean by the recheck what i know from those guys who worked on this guess it is a binary guess yes it is composed of 2 components to liquids each of which is n

of that that novacek as you forgot which is in the soviet family of poisons and was used in the poisoning of their case cripple and his daughter in the u.k. in 2018 and then of course in and around the poisoning in in august now we know that they worked out of the f.s.b. offices across the country and 3 of them have been named they were the they were alleged to have followed me to the city of tomsk back in august where he was then poison you know these are very serious charges of course what are the mechanics of this investigation what proof is there behind these allegations well you know as we know it's a joint investigation between this the building kept the message out to journalists and the russian outfit the insider as well as the. they've got a few others now they've gone and done a deep dive into the phone and flight records and have managed to map out what they alleged but we actually spoke to one of the building catch journalists he spoke to had a little earlier someone erik told him he was involved in the investigation so i let you tell a let him tell you rather in his own words

revealing details of the plot to kill him during the 49 minute cool the alleged agent to mitigate that novacek was planted in the film these underwear and that if the flight had been longer things would have turned out differently. moscow has repeatedly denied that they tried to kill navarro on the and the f.s.b. said the phone who was a provocation and foreign security services were involved. what happened the russian government's response in the valley says he will pursue legal action against the men he says tried to kill him. i'm joined on the line from moscow by even just director of alexina bali's anti-corruption foundation your colleague you both sabol was detained last night do you know why she was arrested. my colleague somebody yesterday. now and i spoke directly to. his apartment. door. and after she was in the car she was the tenant for illegal entry. and after nightly explanation. today morning she was really. has been prepared and now 2 of our samantha and. station pendent. administrative offense. alexina bonnie alleges that he talked directly on the telephone to an alleged f.s.b.

revealing details of the plot to kill him during the 49 minute cool the alleged agent to mitigate that novacek was planted in the valleys underwear and that if the flight had been longer things would have turned out differently. moscow has repeatedly denied that they tried to kill nerve on the and the f.s.b. said the phone call was a provocation and foreign security services were involved. whatever the russian government's response in the valley says he will pass you legal action against the men he says tried to kill him. let's bring in correspondent emily sure when from emily the police have now released you both so bold the woman who went to confront the alleged. agent at his home we saw her in the video but 2 employees who work for him of all these you tube channel have now been arrested can you tell us what. well it does certainly look like this is a bit of a crackdown against members of these team we don't know yet but we do know that you both so vote was released but that a criminal case is being opened against her just a reminder that she essentially just went to ring the doorbell of th

flight germany which ended up treating him said it was beyond doubt he was poisoned with one of the novacek class of nerve agents developed in the soviet union the kremlin denies any role in this if it wasn't them who do you think it was. well many questions about that actually i don't think much about now well in any way. do you remember angela davis she was one of the leaders of the american communist party back in the old soviet days and she was the most important american in the soviet union since she was the head of the commerce party of course no one knew knighted states knew anything about angela davis or not much so in the valley is an angela davis. first place we have a russian electorate he's he sorry we go for we have about raj of explorations and counter accusations about what happened to him mr putin apparently or as for the accusations i have actually i have a few questions to the german side. question number one what do you mean by the recheck what i know from those guys who worked on this guess it is a binary guess yes it is composed of 2 components to liquids each of which

impending death that he experienced on board the airplane on 20th august after being poisoned with novacek aside from the comically incompetent russian spies and agents who somehow for many years fooled the world into thinking that they weren't clowns and aside from the valleys amazing resistance to being killed i mean this guy would put bugs bunny or the road runner to shame aside from that what really stood out in this claim that the laughably useless russians have a nano substance which removes all traces of chemical weapons which they somehow forgot to use of the problems of chemical and climbed the 20 invention of numbness or been set for a moving traces of chemical weapons from infected sites crucially at least one member of the f.s.b. squat is in frequent contact with a scientist from this institute now my big question in all of this is about it all looking reading and sounding like fanfiction or cia agents daydream about how he would expose. as the russians would be applauded by his peers my big question is about you know whether any of it's true because there are 2 explanations in

germany claims it found traces of novacek nerve agent in his body, an allegation later repeated by the o. p. c. w. however, moscow says its own tests found no such substance and that berlin has rejected requests for lab data. we spoke with alexander shogun,, russia's permanent representative to the o.p.c., w e, thinks the claims against russia have a clear political motive. partners in the p. c. w. gainst for the politicizing, the organization which would create deeper divisions and interrupt a normal work in the search for compromises. different countries interpret provisions of the chemical weapons convention in their own way. we should prevent any attempts to spread one's own rules in place of the established conventions of international law, our western partners and their technical secretariat's, when it's convenient for them refer to confidentiality clause. under this pretext, russia has refused access to key aspects of the technical secretary, its reports on providing assistance to germany in the case. but when western countries are not satisfied, they forget all about confidenti

medical training or training with chemical weapons especially with the research and development of this novacek agent which is part of this some salvia family of poisons essentially which was used back in 2018 in the poisoning of saturday script on his daughter and now back in august. we know as well that they work out of f.s.b. offices various ones across moscow and 3 of them are reported to have followed me to the city of tomsk in siberia back in august what proof is there for these allegations well as you've mentioned as well belling cat have been investigating this alongside you know the insider c.n.n. and there spiegel as well as and they went deep into this and they took a look at records but really we spoke with that bell and cat one of the bell and investigative journalists earlier eric toler he spoke to our colleague phil gayle and this is what he told. the russian privacy is pretty much nonexistent without allies there and so we examined the russian data market telecom data and also passenger manifest for flights to look at suspicious so we looked for people who had travel itineraries

volley was poisoned in russia using a chemical weapon, a nerve agent from the novacek group. mr. valley was flying from siberia to moscow back in august of this year when he took ill on the flight and had to make an emergency landing in the city of. he eventually ended up here in berlin to receive treatment. moscow has made numerous requests that share data that is at the very heart of the allegations against russia. so far those requests have fallen on deaf ears. the kremlin, says berlin is actively trying to derail an investigation by the russian side, but where this leaves us is with a deep divide between russia on one side, the o.p.c. w. on the other when it comes to trying to get to the bottom of what happened to alexina valmy, we sounded out a few european politicians and analysts for their thoughts on the latest accusations against russia over the not only case this nation. we urge russia to cooperate and to investigate the case and russia tells. so we don't have any findings share the results with us. so it's, it's the same procedure we have seen in the last month. but no

flight germany which ended up treating him said it was beyond doubt he was poisoned with one of the novacek class of nerve agents developed in the soviet union the kremlin denies any role in this if it wasn't them who do you think it was. well many questions about that actually i don't think much about now wildly anyway. i do remember angela davis she was one of the leaders of the american communist party back in the old soviet days and she was the most important american in the soviet union since she was the head of the commerce party of course no one knew knight estates knew anything about angela davis or not much so in the valley is and angela davis. first place we have a russian electorate he's he sorry we go for we have about rajiv explorations and counter accusations about what happened to him mr putin apparently or as for the accusations i have. actually have a few questions to the german side. question number one what do you mean by the recheck what i know from those guys who worked on this guess it is a binary guess yes it is composed of 2 components to liquids each of which is not

something which has been saved and i feel absolutely valid i mean it and they know that is established novacek was used to have a big critical point know is who use it and there appears to be no proof that this was a moscow hit if i can put it that way. that's is true but what he's interesting also is that we've. got investigation we've got some names we've got some witnesses weeks got some precise elements which are not as us to who felt going in questioning right to questioning is not an evil only related to what happened to me to never leave but what this question was making with iran we still have a meeting of all of us though we have since it's a question we rate of course because you say that this has been alleged by the present with human sense of during the press conference and we have this this recording that alexina valley says is of his conversation with an f.s.b. agent does anything that you've heard in that recording i'm presuming that you've heard it does anything and that recording help your investigation i mean if it's off the water i think it's a very very important element yo

to berlin where adventurously the german doctors said that he was poisoned with a nerve agent of the novacek group moscow keeps sending work west to berlin demanding proof but isn't getting anything in response and one of the latest twists to the story alexina volley and the number of western media outlets published a report in which they blamed a group of russian secret agents for poisoning the kremlin critic that's something the russian federal security service called a provocation and firmly denied. joined live by journalist thomas fassbender for more on this russia has banned a few european officials from entering the country here not a particularly drastic move do you get the sense that neither side wants to escalate this too far. both sides want to escalate go the emphasis is not on cooperation or solution the emphasis on is on getting the opposition and in the conflict we heard right now in the german media half an hour ago that unnamed german and french and swedish government representatives would be. graded from. entering the country and they will know about this when they land in m

flown to berlin or a military law concluded that see had been poisoned with a nerve agent from the novacek group western governments were quick to point the finger out the kremlin which has denied any involvement moscow has also repeatedly asked for access to the lab results but to no avail the valley still in germany appears to be on the road to a full we heard from 3 political commentator i k homer told us that when the story is based entirely on the normal miss sources it raises more questions than answers . more of this silence so ridiculous it sounds somebody hear from somebody you're something from a friend so it's nothing and whenever you are asked for proof whenever you ask for reliable information they say sorry we can't handle it over either it is classified or it is it is not for you or whatever this is ridiculous when you make up stories nothing fits together is the russian secret service is not even able to poison somebody with a deadly poison on its own soil this doesn't fit together at all so this is a big lie story and i think every child knows it and now i think they don't

medical training or training with chemical weapons especially with the research and development of this novacek agent which is part of this some salvia family of poisons essentially which was used back in 2018 in the poisoning of saturday script on his daughter and now back in august. we know as well that they work out of f.s.b. offices various ones across moscow and 3 of them are reported to have followed me to the city of tomsk in siberia back in august what proof is there for these allegations well as you've mentioned as well belling cat i have been investigating this alongside you know the insider c.n.n. and there spiegel as well as the pace and they went deep into this and they took a look at our records but really we spoke with one of the balun investigative journalists earlier eric tolerance spoke to our colleague phil gale and this is what he told. the russian privacy is pretty much nonexistent without allies there and so we examined the russian debt of market telecom data and also passenger manifest for flights to look at suspicious so we looked for people who had travel itineraries th

revealing details of the plot to kill him during the 49 minute cool the alleged agent to mitigate that novacek was planted in the valleys underwear and that if the flight had been longer things would have turned out differently. moscow has repeatedly denied that they tried to kill me and the f.s.b. said the phone call was a provocation and foreign security services were involved. or you whatever the russian government's response in a valley says he will piss you legal action against the men he says tried to kill him from. and with the talk now to correspondent and we show when he was standing by in moscow with the latest hi amalie so we know that the police have now released . but 2 employees who work for and of all these you tube channel have now been arrested can you tell us why. well they were detained yesterday and they're apparently being questioned by police according to these team about disobeying police orders there in detention so far and are apparently awaiting trial when it comes to do both so but she was as you say released but she is now facing a potential criminal case for a sens

agent says that was poisoned was supposed to be killed but was poisoned with novacek nerve agent planted in his underwear and then discuss it in details and throughout the conversation they come back over and over again to this topic just to remind you before to day only repeatedly said that his clothes had been taken away from him before even he left russia and shortly after he was transported to berlin we started hearing from german authorities that he was poisoned with nerve agent and later a german laborde theory claims that found traces of it on a bottle of water from alexina vial is whole tell room no bottles of water were discussed during this phone conversation with the alleged f. is the agent published on monday this topic was not brought up at all during this conversation also never. asks this agent in quote marks why this whole operation went wrong and why did not violently survive at all and the person he was over the phone with by saying that that's probably because plane made an emergency landing and doctors came very quickly to were on the way to help police the violin and

volley was poisoned in russia using a chemical weapon, a nerve agent from the novacek group. mr. valley was flying from siberia to moscow back in august of this year when he took ill on the flight and had to make an emergency landing in the city of. he eventually ended up here in berlin to receive treatment. moscow has made numerous requests that share data that is at the very heart of the allegations against russia. so far those requests have fallen on deaf ears. the kremlin, says berlin is actively trying to derail an investigation by the russian side, but where this leaves us is with a deep divide between russia on one side, the o.p.c. w. on the all that when it comes to trying to get to the bottom of what happened to alexa and of ali. the united arab emirates has condemned last friday's assassination of iran's top nuclear scientist, the gulf monarchy, call it a threat to regional peace yammer. it's condemns the crime of the assassination. it kosher no sides to practice the greatest possible restraint. so as to avoid dragging the region to new levels of instability and threats

something which has been saved and i feel absolutely hopeless i mean it and they know that he's established novacek was used to the critical point know is who use it and there appears to be no proof that this was a moscow hit if i can put it that way. that's is true but what is interesting also is that we see that investigation we've got some names we've got some weaknesses weeks good some precise elements which a lot of us to call felt in questioning right lots of questioning is not in the only related to what happened to me to never leave but what this question was making with iraq based on that i'm reading of for us though we have since it's a question we rate of course because you say that this has been alleged by the present with human sense of during the press conference and we have this this recording that alexei navalny says is of his conversation with an f.s.b. agent does anything that you've heard in that recording i'm presuming that you've heard it does anything and that recording help your investigation i mean if it's of course i think it's a very very important element you know i had a

medical training or training with chemical weapons especially with the research and development of this novacek agent which is part of this some salvia family of poisons essentially which was used back in 2018 in the poisoning of saturday script on his daughter and now back in august. we know as well that they work out of f.s.b. offices various ones across moscow and 3 of them are reported to have followed me to the city of tomsk in siberia back in august what proof is there for these allegations well as you've mentioned as well belling cat have been investigating this alongside you know the insider c.n.n. and there spiegel as well as pies and they went deep into this and they took a look at records but really we spoke with that bell and one of the belling investigative journalists earlier eric tolerance spoke to our colleague phil gale and this is what he told. the russian privacy is pretty much nonexistent without allies there and so we examined the russian data market telecom data and also passenger manifest for flights to look at suspicious so we looked for people who had travel itineraries

countries including the united states say that navalny was poisoned by a soviet era nerve agent called novacek. he has recovered and he claims to have tricked one of the russian agents sent to poison him to confess. the kremlin denies involvement. russian's president putin said he could have killed navalny if he wanted to. that's grim. >>> all right, coming up next here, house lawmakers pass a bill to beef up coronavirus stimulus checks to $2,000 and now the fate rest with the gop-controlled senate and there's been nothing but silence from mitch mcconnell. "morning joe" will be right back. onnell "morning joe" will be right back lp you remember that liberty mutual customizes your home insurance, here's something you shouldn't try at home... look, liberty mutual customizes home insurance so we only pay for what we need. it's pretty cool. that is cool! grandma! very cool. only pay for what you need. ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ type 2but how canan have a big imit be prevented?e. well, the first step is knowing if you have prediabetes, a serious medical condition that puts you at h

ready to investigate anything if you have specific data the use of specific chemical weapons like the novacek everyone's talking about police to providers with the information we are ready to send our specialists to germany to france and wherever and there. with our colleagues we can address the problem more but you can please come to us. biological material and at least provide us with the official statement of the official results why is it that despite the multiple. the multiple times that our investigative committee has addressed european nations to provide us with this data nothing has been given to us for example. citing the germany for example the opposite w presumably if you did not suggest any information citing germany that prohibited them from disclosing anything why is it happening can you specify that so you're asking me yes i'm asking you. i'm a journalist i'm asking you a question. i apologize so i will continue to. your question. we should just see that this question that i asked also requires answering. now saying the trash is. all good and. there's nothing that we have to bl