also thes number two search engine behind google. i said that was surprising information so talking about the underdog aspect i don't know how widely known it is a search engine. >> it was a driving force why google scooped it up early and youtube's life agreeing to buy one.$6 billion which at the time was a norman sticker shock for the media world and so you to buy then already had enormous success finding an audience and it already started to become of the wider culture but google saw youtube as a fantastic search property. and has a threat in the way that google wants us to become the best search engine on the internet. so youtube people weree going there to look for entertaining clips to pass the time and idle entertainment as well as how to it information that hasn't changed you can only become stronger where it is remarkable that any specific thing we are looking to do their is probably a a youtube video that explains how to do it and someone who makes money from it and is the breath of the platform to come to terms with. >> an

youtube has teams at moderate google search in google images and so on. forgive me for that. >> host: thanks for clarifying that but ultimately puts a lot of burden on these content moderators who are contractors. maybe people are not aware they don't get the big salaries and benefits of google and youtube employees and often work in different parts of the world. could you talk about the difficulties this is put on individuals and kind of the blowback that in a partly happened? >> guest: yeah. to your point a lot of them are contracted out, so to vendors that google hires rather than being full-time youtube employees, the company says the reason they do that is they just want to hire people very quickly, which is in a sense it's accurate the way youtube tends to hire people takes some time for their hiring. for one, certain types of content and i've talked to people who've had these jobs, their job was to youtube calls it violent extremism, like this is some of the most graphic violence and a lot of it is -- youtube's goal is to build software that can de

a new tool from google aims to help. now we're giving you even more controls will be an online presence. it's called result about you. it makes it easy to request the removal of search results that contain your phone number home address or email, even though to moving these results doesn't scrub your contact information from the web overall, doing everything to safeguard information. i'm to do it. search for yourself and find result containing personal information then hit the 3 dots next to the results and tap the button for remove results. >> google will ask some questions, then let you know if they can remove the result. it's an exceptional first step by google. haley kaplan is a cyber privacy expert and helps people reclaim their privacy online. it's critical that you care that information can be used against you in so many different situations, including identity theft and personal safety and protecting against malicious intent. google's tool is helpful, but it's just a start. it is always best to remove it from the

i was trying to google that very quickly but i will| google that very quickly but i will let the producer have a look, they will be quicker than me. what did you make of the fifa boss and his comments, pandora, you are already shaking your head.— shaking your head. utterly bizarre. talk about reading _ shaking your head. utterly bizarre. talk about reading the _ shaking your head. utterly bizarre. talk about reading the room. - shaking your head. utterly bizarre. talk about reading the room. i - shaking your head. utterly bizarre. | talk about reading the room. i think everyone _ talk about reading the room. i think everyone was surprised. it was bizarre. — everyone was surprised. it was bizarre. i— everyone was surprised. it was bizarre, i don't know who briefed him _ bizarre, i don't know who briefed him also — bizarre, i don't know who briefed him also a — bizarre, i don't know who briefed him. also a complete disrespect as well to— him. also a complete disrespect as well to the — him. also a complete disrespect as well to the hundreds of workers who lost their— well to

gonzalez the google -- gonzalez v. will. it addresses -- gonzalez v. google. the pattern in each cases involve incidents where someone was hurt or killed in a terrorist attack and the petitioners are -- the plaintiffs were arguing in the lower courts that the platforms had liability for this because they in some way allowed it to happen and boosted algorithmic contents that spread propaganda from isis and they allowed people to get in touch with one another and help them fund terrorist attacks. this is been very broad but not specific to the cases but the general fact pattern. the court decided they relate to similar issues but there are different questions in east -- eats -- each case. the first one is the 230 protection that shields platforms from liability for user generated content. the question concerns whether the platform use of an algorithm to boost or down rake content is protected by section 230 or not, the argument being while a terrorist group, there was content that was boosted on the algorithm and that is not user generated content but produced b

google was also worried about the issue. it giving service to this program and white listing campaigns it would then have to show up as an incumbent on those campaign reports. the answer from the fcc in august was you are cleared to do that. maybe it was an ironically what the dnc taking the portion of this rulemaking said absolutely we should not feel this pilot program is giving bad users of this email given what this material is listing. they have become a participant in this program. >> that brings us to the bigger question of the challenge of the internet, what stays up, what goes down, who is in charge. do i get to decide what i'm seeing. it does the algorithm continue to give me things. there is a lot of people doing things that are unhappy. moving beyond gmail, can we talk about the most recent supreme court taking up several cases? talk to us about --. >> there are two cases of the supreme court, we are expecting to hear them later this term. they both concern a problem that has been on people's radar for a long tim

>> one thing we've seen from google in particular, there are websites dedicated to the google graveyard. there are milestones and be checks and balances when something doesn't hit a particular adoption curve, a return on investment curve, they shut it down like stayed yeah recently what we have seen is as they shut down some of the production they keep the head count and deploy them. in a different environment you have the right to do so. what i would imagine is they look at these initiatives. they're going to shrink or steepen the requirements required to keep investment levels going the tci level, what we've seen with pairs if there was ever a time for them to get a little bit more serious on taking costs out or winding some of the initiatives down, there's probably never been a time for more cover than we have now. >> mark, it seems to me that it's important to note more money isn't be always better for young initiatives, right sometimes you give the team too much money, they sort of spend it kind of like investors. give them too much money and they deploy it in things they shouldn't

>> well, i think the growth especially for generals, you know microsoft, apple google, amazon, maybe meta, i think growth runway is shorter, all acknowledge that go back to great foreign minister crisis. that year google generated 22 medicine revenue this year slated 220 billion in revenue that is bigger than back then, so, of course, it is more mangro impacted than back then, worst case in great financial crisis google grew 3% year offer year today a similar economic sayings i don't think going to see that if you were google would probably decline 5, or 10% year-over-year as they get bigger more impacted tailwinds last strong more exposed if economy softens they will soften i think companies will recover growth rates back half of '23 assuming modest recession house call this would be great buying, premium versus gdp versus omni vr markets, other companies but the growth rates are going to be slower than they were nast just law of large numbers. >> great analysis from you i want your take on the president ftx changes one facing billions we don't know stolen lost during bankruptcy hea

what is google doing to prepare for maybe an onslaught? we have been actively engaged with congress karan: we have been actively invaded -- there are some big issues in the technology space that we want to see the u.s. government address. privacy is a good example. this is a space that the u.s. has lacked a comprehensive privacy law now for years. we need to have a single, unified law, one that will allow certainty, people will understand what their roles and responsibilities are. privacy is a hugely important issue for us, it would be great if there was a comprehensive law adopted. misinformation is another topic that gets a lot of attention. steven: inc. so much for your time. that is it for now from the apac leader summit. tom: fantastic, thank you very much indeed. coming up, ecb policy makers are considering a slowdown of interest rate hikes. we will go live to frankfurt next. this is bloomberg. ♪ tom skate welcome back. key figures are gathering in frankfurt for the european banking congress. ecb president is set to give the keynot

again, you can always get dw news on the go, just download our app from google play or from the apple app store and give you access to all the latest news from around the world, as well as cushioning, vacations for any breaking needs. that's all from me for now. coming up next business news with chris code that i'm on your hips in the can and i'll be back to the top of the next hour. but more international headlines thought youth ah she uses can't be destroyed. what you can try, but it's impossible to movies. ah, she performed for her life and oh, schmidt's was the nazis mm. to musicians who lived beneath the banner of the swastika, assume about the sounds of power. inspiring story about survival. music under the swastika starts november 19th on d, w ah, a sunny place to make lots of renewable energy. the indian government tells the country as the perfect location to produce great hydrogen boy here from our correspondent what's behind the idea and why india is also still relying heavily on the burning of coal. also coming up countries in latin, the have some of the biggest reserves an

sort of google key? oh paul, our school. no, we didn't use it to build speech recognition. if you need to, foster you, there will be more than one sort of speech recognition, brain mama over the planet balcony to go eat the cherokee. the largest indigenous population in north america. want to use smartphones to prevent their language from dying out. with cellphone maker, motorola, they have developed a smartphone interface in the syllabic language. for me, the fact that motorola and companies like them are utilizing the, the technology that they develop to really reach out and include and, and propagate a language or anything for a minority group. is to me a way to demonstrate, you know, that corporations can care to close the digital divide. technology must also align with the local populations, needs and features and ivory coast company has developed a smartphone, controlled by voice commands in the local language. with this phone was developed in ivory coast and use his voice commands for those who can't read or write i was in love with him of nava by the seminar. i just

the commission has decided to find google at 2400000 euros, and the european union has hit google with a record find equal to $5000000000.00. has media doodles? middleton 2015. an important step on the road to independence. the e. you declared war and the monopolies of individual tech giants, the 1st public institution in the world to do so. apple, unless we cover up to 13000000000 euros in unpaid taxes, the e u has set out to curb the dominance of individual market players to give citizens more control over their own data and to hold social media accountable for publishing, fake or harmful content. what is happening right now is that democracy takes back sort of control of the essentials for a very long time. really essential decisions have been taken in close boardrooms. i'm not in our democracy. and that is not to exclude the commercial side of technology, but that is to say that it's that 100 percent legitimate, that it is our elected representatives. ah, who sets the direction and in our society's it's hard to imagine the huge tech corporations backing down. they have a powerful l

talking about the websites same with google/chrome as well. what's happened at this point, cost of doing ecommerce suddenly year over year gone up dramatically the last two years, tripled, and with that in mind, there is a physical realm at this point in the market that comes to direct upsides versus, say, the retail ecommerce websites retailer commerce, say a non-element, walmart.coms, kroger.coms or bestbuy.comes a premium in the market at this time we sdexpect to see retail side f the equation takes lion's share of the ecommerce growth and going to be at expense of companies like traditional companies, see that physically start to settle into the market. >> yeah. more specialty retail. you know, guru, pretty much everyone from amazon to shopify to walmart, thought would go up than did a more muted growth. as they accommodate that, amazon in particular scales back that plan weighing on gross margins how do you see that playing out over the next year or so how does an amazon, a shopify take that medicine to revert costs or will it play out ov

con duracell, pueden durar más. ♪ ♪ (mÚsica) ♪ >>> hoy la plataforma google le da vida a una tradiciones mÁs importante de mÉxico, los pueblos aztecas que ven que las almas de los muertos podrÍan visitar a los vivos y siempre reciben a sus seres queridos con foto, velas para guiarlos a casa los altares decorados definen esta costumbre que ha sido adoptada incluso en otras tierras este 2 de noviembre es la celebraciÓn en grande del dÍa de muertos en mÉxico. y miles de panteones en todo el paÍs estÁn listos para recibir las almas de sus seres queridos, pero hay lugares como por

the two most interesting parts to me were google, the first quarter that google said there was weakness in the search. they said that in september. search is usually considered to be the most not recession proof, but recession resilience. if google is seeing a down in search, every other company is seeing it. amazon in the june quarter is asked whether they have seen any signs of consumer softness. the cfo said no. they are starting to see softness. not surprisingly, they are bleeding over to the u.s.. how much worse could it get? we know it is getting softer, will it get softer and for how long? that is a hard one to know. i think all of these companies especially if they have exposure to the consumer, microsoft and amazon with aws are seeing the enterprise is starting to slow down. demand trends are softening. any company who tells you that is not the case is probably is not being honest. emily: interesting point about pinterest. the new ceo is going to be on the show in a few minutes. i will put your point to him. i want to ask about the partner advertising landscape and what your ou

that in just a moment plus, the latest tech layoff as hp cuts thousands, an rumors mount that even googl may be at risk by the way, a lot more on apple, as violent protests rock the massive iphone plant in china, john >> the health of the consumer' top of mind for investors, looking ahead to black friday, and the rest of the week, with a rolling stride of playoffs -- from china to amazon what is the impact on tech here? >> jon chu joins us with a look >> so john, as we take a loo at sentiment within technology services and of course tha all-important consumer secto around this holiday season, it turns around into these thre sectors being the real drivers a lot of the downside action w have seen. as you can see, some of th outside moves to the outside are the three most important sectors. if you want to take a look a some of the names that might have more of a consumer focu within those three sectors a the holiday shopping season an consumer spending takes center stage. so we ran a screen with s&p 50 companies within those three sectors. tech calm services and consume discretionary. 153 n

we have the details coming up in another forecast. >> we review the new google smartphone. does the pixel 7 fix previous software issues fix previous software issues and how does this stack this is what voting yes on prop 31 means. yes on 31 ends the sale of candy flavored tobacco products. yes, stops big tobacco from targeting our kids. yes, protects kids from nicotine addiction. vote yes on 31. vo: climate change is fueling a wildfire crisis. destroying our forests. threatening our communities. polluting our air. prop 30 taxes those making over $2 million a year. no one else pays a penny. 30 will reduce the tailpipe emissions that drive climate change. and prevent wildfires and toxic smoke. so we have clean air to breathe. this is about our kids' future. omar: prop 30 helps contain fires and combat tailpipe emissions. vote yes on 30. this is what voting yes on prop 31 means. yes on 31 ends the sale of candy flavored tobacco products. yes, stops big tobacco from targeting our kids. yes, protects kids from nicotine addiction. vote yes on 31. >> google just released their ne

should google be broken up? >> i mean, i don't want to say specifically what the outcome ought to be until we're done with all the investigations or at least done with more of the investigations, but i don't think we should take that off the table. maria: okay. ag, thanks very much. we'll be watching all of this. jonathan skrmetti joining us this morning in ten see. thank you, sir. quick break and then consumers are fed up with record high prices this holiday. fox business' gr gray -- grady m gradytrumble is here with a bren of what's eating up your holiday budget. that's next. ♪ my needs are small. ♪ i buy them all at the five and ten cent store.ak ♪ i'vine got pl plenty to be thl for. so you know all you need for recovery. and you are? i'm an investor...in invesco qqq, a fund that gives me access to... nasdaq 100 innovations like... wearable training optimization tech. uh, how long are you... i'm done. i'm okay. ♪ choosing miracle-ear was a great decision. like when i decided to host family movie night

calling them the google parent to cut costs aggressively. adding that head count and compensation are too high. the london based hedge fund owns north of $4 billion. cost per employee is simply too high, karen. do you agree >> yes but i think hopefully he's not -- it won't be falling on deaf ears. i think they are receptive to that message i think they are starting to do that anyway. we have talked for years about luke being the grown up in the room and really she clarified, made more transparency in the income statement in the district divisions. i think they're totally up for it now, it is a built tilting at windmills. it's for the kids, you know? but i like alphabet a lot of course it is my biggest position. but you will not have any control. they know that, of course. but i think it will be well received i think it's already there maybe he's trying to prod them to do it anyway. the part where he's saying let's just be done with whamo, that part i don't know they will do that. >> it is interesting we had an activist i don't know if you ca

the only phone engineered by google. switch now and get google pixel 7 or pixel 7 pro for free. i love what downy does for my sheets and towels. but did you know downy provides 7 benefits for your clothes, like making them softer and fresher. plus, downy fights fading and stretching. make your laundry softer, fresher, and look newer longer. announcer: type 2 diabetes? discover the power of 3 in the ozempic® tri-zone. in my ozempic® tri-zone, i lowered my a1c, cv risk, and lost some weight. announcer: ozempic® provides powerful a1c reduction. in studies, the majority of people reached an a1c under 7 and maintained it. ozempic® lowers the risk of major cardiovascular events such as stroke, heart attack, or death in adults also with known heart disease. and you may lose weight. adults lost up to 14 pounds. ozempic® isn't for people with type 1 diabetes. don't share needles or pens, or reuse needles. don't take ozempic® if you or your family ever had medullary thyroid cancer, or have multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2, or if allergic to it. stop ozempic® and get med

and google is just out with a new smartphone. yeah. does the pixel 7 fix previous operations and how does that stack up with the iphone? we've got rich demuro. >> taking a closer look in today's tech smart. last year's google pixel smartphones were plagued by software issues and a slow fingerprint reader. does the pixel 7 fix that? here's my review. >> google's pixel 7 might be the smartest smartphone around when i'm using it. i remember how useful it can be to have instant access to all of google's knowledge by pressing and holding the side button, tapping a microphone, the homescreen search bar or saying, hey, cool. >> how many cups are in 3 and a half gallons dancers. 56 us voice typing on the pixel is so good. you might not even need the keyboard. and the other cool thing is that you can put something like a smiley face emoji and you're taxed. this is a software first smartphone. it's not the most powerful hardware on the planet. if you want that go apple or samsung. >> but this year, major issues gone. the fingerprint reader works

the only phone engineered by google. switch now and get google pixel 7 or pixel 7 pro for free. (♪♪) this season, you can spend less and make holiday dreams come true at t.j. maxx, marshalls and homegoods, with amazing gifts for everyone on your list. these little cups would make great stocking stuffers. ♪♪ but how about right-now-in-your-mouth stuffers. happy holidays to your mouth. not sorry. reese's. laundry truths: the bargain jug. ♪♪ that's a huge jug of detergent. yeah, isn't it a bargain? you know that bargain detergent is 85% water, right? really? it's this much water! so, i'm just paying for watery soap? that's why i use tide pods. they're super concentrated, so... don't pay for water. pay for clean. it's got to be tide pods. ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ( cheers and applause ) >> stephen: welcome back, everybody! thank you for joining us for yet another act of our wonderful show. ladies and gentlemen, my first guest this evening is a u.s. senator from the great state of massachusetts, and a former presidential candidate. please welcome back to "the late show," s

if you google it, you're welcome video of your machine. what a couple easy, but normally we started to sell you a deal, so you deal with too much money. you bought national senior school with the choice of a thing that's a piece of him because there's nothing they be shared with. i'm not a little boy, a few minutes just to go to pick up on him. do not set up with the problem. margin the price i see on you digital know now fullest. give me taylor will be done with the senior for them. so when you happens to political idea as to who i grew up with you, when you think would be, well if question is that to change the quote in there? could i use a machine of a yeah, i need a bundle. get an idea. i mean, one of the most popular series is that innocent blood was spilled as a result of a so called popular uprising that women, ukrainian farmers in those areas turned against that polish neighbors who lived in the same area at the bellagio beach, a poorer shop or the survey star on a boat that was put in my water, show them the shimmer of an issue, b

. >>> still ahead here at 5:00, google has just agreed to the largest consumer privacy settlement in the u.s. history. today's announcement. >>> what i would say to people watching is be very careful. you're being tracked. >> the bay area church has provided spiritual energy to its parishioners for years. now it's pr >>> a woman who works at sourdough & co. in rohnert park has been arrested for allegedly shooting someone at the restaurant. police say they caught jade cutrer last night as she was running from the business. the victim is a 16-year-old girl who police say is being treated at a local hospital. no word on a motive, but policen cofirmed the two knew each other and it was not a random act. >>> a terrifying ordeal for passengers on board a frontier airlines flight from cincinnati to tampa. authorities took a man off the plane in handcuffs friday after it made an emergency stop in atlanta. investigators say he got two box cutters through the check point and then made violent threats towards passengers on the flight. tsa said they did not properly use the identification proces

they're not going to do that or they could google it. they get it going to put me in the pocket for it. but i've been kid manager by me. i might have but you're going to talk with amazon associates and you'll get that in get me. yeah. but your company is gonna have to even get it as a beach card. cannot be money already planned. let me let me get i, i do have your where are you on? hold for. oh. and wellness committee is made it very good. we had a good artist, mid murder committee grant. he sneered with us. nixon, i'm the can you please me a call when you get home? did i tell any credit at all? will come on the up. you please? i definitely. yeah, but i've been a quick question. where did you go to be about? oh no sir. no. i don't think there is a hillock about nothing's money, but there's some hotel number a good fund until again my why so a little bit though the some on monday i will about little with b r a i then only bought by bobby mommy bought by jani. him and me kinda like a google map us look on that. then to look this up to this

it's gotta be in your global google docs. yeah. not to just be what browser you want. the thank you grange parliament displayed a curious response to the 70th anniversary of the volume tragedy. nearly one 3rd of the value of nevada was not 148 members who mostly communist and from the ruling party of regions were signed an official request to the polish parliament to recognize what had happened 70 years before. as genocide against the polish people, it was with that request triggered a strong response on both sides of the polish ukrainian border. the initiative was heavily criticized in ukraine and described as tantamount to treason with modern you break your school to get it as wiscoe with using clean east him in your cuz i think of a tional it washing shadows. nice thing. excuse fuck the controller. a new thing that number will probably be able to, to will clean, listed on the condition on after mottos, anything eligible in the peers, watch force, customer a switching, you'll be streaming in all kinds of prescribed esther and then also the attacker convertible as if

think google's position or if google decided imagine to get positive returns for one candidate and negative for the other. i don'tay think the government has any ability to say to a private company like google that you have to favor both candidates evenhandedly and we can talk about that point later. i do know we have a disagreement that you can say that if there is reason to believe that you are as a social media company having bias results, then you have to disclose that you are engaging in this or at least the abilityy for a government investigators to look and see if the algorithm has been programmed in this way. than that information is simply reported. so they are about providing with more information if it is manipulated in a particular way. but it's done in a way that favors one candidate or disfavors another and that should be disclosed to voters. if you go to this website you can expect to get bias results. >> word requiring a victim spelled speech violate the first amendment? so in terms of trade secrets i don't think act the newspaper it's easier to tell of the newspaper favors

we're looking at critics of google. again they have done it, with the top 10 critics, they gave preference to the democrats in six of the cases again they pushed the republicans out of, out of the first marriage. so google's manipulating information. this is, i believe, an illegal contribution they're making to the democratic process. they have got to be investigated. the democrats don't want to do it. if the republicans take over they have got to investigate what google is doing because i think the democracy is in danger when they can manipulate the voters this way. jackie: this was supposed to be a huge issue on capitol hill to look into the tech companies and how they operate and try to break it down but it got, you know, overrun by covid and spending and everything else that we're dealing with at this point. >> jackie, now, jackie, they're going after elon musk because what he is saying we'll have transparency. jackie: they liked twitter when it was working for them. now it appears not working for them. all of sudde

the only phone engineered by google. switch now and get google pixel 7 or pixel 7 pro for free. want your clothes to smell freshly washed all day without heavy perfumes? try downy light in-wash freshness boosters. it has long-lasting light scent, no heavy perfumes, and no dyes. finally, a light scent that lasts all day. downy light! ♪ what i want you've got ♪ ♪ and it might be hard to handle ♪ ♪ and how i can't explain ♪ ♪ oh, yeah ♪ ♪ well, well you ♪ ♪ (ooh-ho, hoo-ooh, ooh-oo) ♪ ♪ you make my dreams come true ♪ ♪ (you-hoo, you, you-hoo, hoo, you, hoo) ♪ ♪ well, well, well you ♪ ♪ (you-hoo, hoo-hoo-ooh) ♪ ♪ you make my dreams come true ♪ ♪ (you-hoo, hoo-hoo-ooh) ♪ ♪ oh, yeah ♪ find your beat ♪ (you-hoo, hoo-hoo-ooh) ♪ your moment of calm find your potential then own it support your immune system with a potent blend of nutrients and emerge your best every day with emergen-c ♪ ♪ this... is a glimpse into the no-too-distant future of lincoln. ♪ ♪ it's what sanctuary could look like... feel like... sound like... even

think about google's dominant position in the search market, what if google decided be like one candidate but not another, imagine the algorithm to give positive returns for one kennedy and negative returns for the other. i don't think the government has the ability to say to a private company like google or meta you have got to favor both candidates evenhandedly and we can talk about that point later but you and i have some disagreement on this but i do think you could say this close. if there is reason to believe you are a search, and or social media company having biased results, then you would have to disclose that you are engaging in this or you would have to give the ability, not publicly but for government investigators to look and see if the algorithm has been programmed in this way and if it has been, the information is something reported. as with my other solutions, most are about providing voters with more information so if an algorithm is being manipulated in a particular way and all algorithms make choices, if it favors one candidate and disfavors another, that should be disc

when google follows up on th a it doesn't talk to ur language at all. it uses warhol as an example of how somebody can take an original work and make i mean something entirely different and that that's what the fair usdorine wants to protect. i take it that campbell has some lgue that cuts your way in the sense of saying if you are commenting on, that's real. almost d'teed to go any further. but if you're not coenting on the original thers ill the possibility under campbell and then certain under google that yes, this is fair use because it's the kind of thing we think of as truly transformav. >> i would say you should look at holding over a dictum that usea nonstatutory word transformative when the word transformation is in statute . the dictum they're relying on is saying i think when you have up purpose in parity and the process of shedding gh whh i'm quoting your words, shedding light on the origin ,ou benefit society and create new meaning. all that matters in this case is they had an affirmate defense and get didn't give u good reason for copying

it's available at the apple store and google play. download it for free today. your front row seat to washington anytime, anywhere. ♪♪

think about google's dominant position in the search market. what if google decided we elect -- they like one candidate for president would dislike the other when you can imagine h algorithms being program for positive for one and negative forget it. don't think the government has ability to pay to a private company like google or meta. you have to favor both candidates evenhandedly and we can talk d about that point lat. i know you and i have somewhat of a disagreement on this but i do think you could disclose. there is reason to believe as a search company or social media company you're having bias then you would have to disclose that you are engaging in this or you'd haveve to give at least te ability not publicly but for government investigators to be a will to look bn and see if the algorithm has been programmed in thisth way and if it happens thn is to simply report it so people knowh it. as with other solutions both my solutions are about providing voters with more information so the algorithmor is being manipulated in a particular way.

campbell, google, all the things we've talked about. secondly, with respect inspsability, i understood my friend, miss blatt, to again coede that the position she took a brief is not the right e. or at least that she's fine with the governments mh different and lower standard. she went from indispensali in the brief to usefulness here at oral argument. with respect to whether usefulness is required, a couple of things. first of all, goldsmith herself coed usefulness. if you look at page 76 a of the petition appdix, the district court quoted her as conceding usefulness and even perhaps necessity. secondly, usefulness, at in the sense that has been discussed, today has not b briefed argued at any stage in the case. eard about what the existing standards mean. if you t that was some sort of ement, at a minimum, we would need a fair opportunitatisfy that requirement what you tell us what the law as to what the law should, be with respect to usefulne think the real best way to look at this is, it's a qn of justification. and the way you shou

at this level up here where we see them and we're interact with them, gmail, google docks, google maps, all we see is a bunch of free services like they're a big, sweet, kind, generous librarian, okay? >> nice description. >> down here at the business side this is a surveillance company that makes almost all of its money by tricking us into giving up personal information about ourselves 24 hours a day and our kids. and then monetizes it, sells it. i mean aggressively. and they're making $150 billion a year now by doing this and most people have no idea what that business model is and more and more they have been using the information they have to control us, control our kids and indoctrinate our kids and affect the outcome of elections. pete: of course. will: yeah. pete: yes, eye-opening. maybe jaw-dropping but also of course. will: yep. rachel: you say of course but i think people understand, i think most people get that they're surveilling us and we're the product and they think that they're selling us product. i think what was really eye-opening, i really think people ought to watch

c-span now is available at the apple store and google play. downloaded for free today. c-span now, your front receipt to washington, anytime, anywhere -- front row seat to washington, anytime, anywhere. >> middle and high school students, it is your time to shine. you are invited to participate in this year's studentcam documentary competition. picture yourself as a newly elected member of congress. we ask this year's competitors, what is your top priority and why? make a five minute to six minute video that shows the importing of your issues from opposing and supporting perspectives. don't be afraid to take risks. be bold. amongst $100,000 in cash prizes is a $500,000 cash prize. videos must be submitted by january 20, 2023. visit our website at udenam.org for tips, resources, and a step-by-step guide. >> c-span is your unfiltered view of government. we are funded by these television companies and more, including -- ♪ >> these television providers support c-span, giving you a front row seat to democracy. >> defense secretary lloyd austin and

you use the google app, parents will be able to restrict who children can call on the google devices and what songs they can listen to. you have filtering software but, remember, if you have a personal assistant, while it's not going to access a lot of terrible things, you certainly do want to watch what your children are doing or asking that personal assistant. >> of course. >> it's interesting, too, with google, last night i was setting an alarm and was on the phone with a friend, their google picked up my 2:15 call time. >> it's dangerous being friends with us. >> will text you, too. >> thank you, scott. >> you bet. >>> all right, so trending for you this morning, yep, you're looking at the screen. i probably don't have to say much to you. you are probably too engulfed in what you're looking at. trending from captain america to america's sexiest man. >> sorry, i was checking out the picture. >> see what i'm talking about. >> oh, it's my turn to read? a brand-new sexiest man alive, actor chris evans. "people" magazine bestowing the honor on the 41-year-old bachelor from boston. yes

compare that to a google cloud which is a distant number three but investing billions into the space. the fact that amazon is able to sort of eat some of the costs in terms of energy for its customers trying to make it more affordable to their cloud customers that's going to be tough for google because they're trying to gain market share here and their business is still unprofitable, though the profitability is getting better. i'm not saying, of course, that the team is going to pull back on those investments but it will make it harder for them as they're still on the path to profitability. >> yeah. and carl, just about everybody has gotten unprofitable business they're subsidizing. for amount it's retail, right, and shipping at this point. >> good point. >> and the cloud profits are helping with that as well as the cloud profits helping to subsidize customers inflationary pressures. google, of course, has the profitable ads business subsidizing the cloud as they try to stand that up maybe everything is profitable at apple maybe that's - >> interesting bernstein has a good note lookin

went up to google dot com because we don't need to teach people to read and write e key or not because we just need to take them as they are and bring them into the economy or to me, it don't stop stuff that brings economic growth of to do because now you can simply speak to send money or to do businesses below resembled activities. you can just speak and understand is super where before you needed to read and write me, i li, 3 there makes life easier. and in a state like ivory coast, so we need every body's involvement for the country to function. wow, go go. is it a new router to be? ah, ah. destination culture. hannah homer is on the road again with the time constant war in the northeast of germany. magnificent castle. miss serious grayson romantic far is a cultural tour thunder. next on d. w. i. it's a powerful form of protection for the body and soul gentle touch. it's crucial for human survival for our health and psychological development. but what happens when people can't touch it? physical distancing, makes it more difficult to we explore the power of gentle touch in 30 minute

campbell, google, all the things we've taed about. secondly, with respect indispensability, i derstood my friend, miss blt, to again concede athe position she took a brief is not thright one. or at least that she's fine with the governments much different and lor standard. she went from indispensability in the brief to usefulness here at oral argument. with respect to whether usefulness is reired, a couple of things. first a, goldsmith heelf conceded usefulness. if you look at page 76 a of the petition apndix, the district court quot h as conceding usefulness and even perhaps necessity. secondly, usefulness, at least in the sense that s been discussed, today has not been, briefed argued at any agin the case. we heard ouwhat the existingtaards mean. if you thought that was me sort of requirement, at a minimum,e uld need a fair opportunity to satisfy that requirement what you tell us what the law is. as to what the law should, be think the real best way to look justification.'s a question of and the way you should get the justification